Since we're on the subject. Better Resume Floyd or Roy?

[AKATheMack]

I think Floyd actually has a pretty decent resume, but I give Roy the >> too. Roys greatest wins are better than Floyds by a significant margin.

[BigStereotype]

What do you mean. Everyone knows Floyd is more skilled than Roy. Jones had great reflexes and speed. That pretty much it.

You could say that that's "all" Ali/Clay had against Liston, too. You'd be wrong, and you're wrong about Jones, but those are NOT advantages to be taken lightly. And great doesn't even scratch the surface of Jones' physical advantages over his competition.

I say Jones has the better resume and is the p4p better fighter by far.

[Southpawkiller]

B-Hop was in his prime and went on a 12 year undefeated streak after the fight. Roy just made him look bad

Hopkins 5 yrs plus imo gives him alot more problems..he was bigger and more experienced. just my opinion...anyway i tink Roy wins

[Kagami Taiga]

You could say that that's "all" Ali/Clay had against Liston, too. You'd be wrong, and you're wrong about Jones, but those are NOT advantages to be taken lightly. And great doesn't even scratch the surface of Jones' physical advantages over his competition.

I say Jones has the better resume and is the p4p better fighter by far.

i dont even think hes the better p4p fighter...but by far??? i dont see that at all...roy was an amazing athletic talent, and its not even close. but imo floyd was always tougher than roy, had the better defense, the better skill set etc.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

B-Hop wasn't in his prime and Roy didn't dominate him.

even if that was the case, who says Roy was in his prime either?


roy was what? 20-0? nard was 20-1?

[Southpawkiller]

even if that was the case, who says Roy was in his prime either?


roy was what? 20-0? nard was 20-1?

Agree 100%

[SCtrojansbaby]

Not to mention B-Hop is 4 years older

[IronDanHamza]

Roy fans to Roy : please retire already

Floyd fans to Floyd: retired already?

Credit where it's due.

That's funny.

[Larry the boss]

floyd.......

[SplitSecond]

i dont even think hes the better p4p fighter...but by far??? i dont see that at all...roy was an amazing athletic talent, and its not even close. but imo floyd was always tougher than roy, had the better defense, the better skill set etc.

the better skill set, better defense? i dunno about that, roy just got old

floyd is about to do the same, and i dont remember roy being rocked/hit as much as floyd