Since we're on the subject. Better Resume Floyd or Roy?

[studentofthegam]

Roy's resume is so underrated, it's not even funny:

Toney
Hopkins
McCallum (OK, old I'll give you that)
Tarver
Reggie Johnson
Ruiz
Malinga
Hill
Harding
Griffin

Just because it could've been better doesn't mean it's not stellar.

Cant the same be said for Mayweather. Idont think Roy's is **** but it needs a lot more work than Floyd's overall

ur making it seem like floyd gets/got hit a lot. he didnt and he doesnt. hes tougher for the simple fact that when he does get hit, he takes hits a whole lot better than roy.

as far as the defense thing goes, roy's defense was his offense and his athleticisim. very unorthodoxed and very reliant on his reflexes. when those went away, so did his defense. so yes, floyd is the better defensive fighter. **** b hop is the better defensive fighter...**** fat ass james toney is a better defensive fighter than roy.

My thing is Roy went a long period of time when he was so much faster than his competition he didnt get hit hard at all. When he finally did he went to sleep.

[Battle*Hardened]

Floyd hasn't beaten anyone as good as James Toney or Hopkins. Both of which he did fairly easily.

[Forza]

floyd hasnt been K.O'd by 3 different journeymen either

[Battle*Hardened]

floyd hasnt been K.O'd by 3 different journeymen either

Tarver and Johnson are journeyman?

I think it's safe to say Jones was past prime in each of his losses....

Like I said, Toney and Hopkins are far better then anyone on Floyds resume. It's no contest who has the better resume.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Roy has b hop and lights out.

I'm a Floyd fan but I can't support y'all non sense.

B-Hop was in his prime and went on a 12 year undefeated streak after the fight. Roy just made him look bad

Roy's resume is so underrated, it's not even funny:

Toney
Hopkins
McCallum (OK, old I'll give you that)
Tarver
Reggie Johnson
Ruiz
Malinga
Hill
Harding
Griffin

Just because it could've been better doesn't mean it's not stellar.

Not only has Roy have the better resume but roy also wore the p4p 1# crown better than Floyd.

[jrosales13]

Roy Jones....

IMO it goes Pac>Roy>B-Hop>Floyd for the last 15 years.

Floyd best win is Corrales, that doesn't match Toney or B-Hop. And, really Jones win over Ruiz is just as good as the Corrales win.

And, Roy has a few underrated wins like Jorge Castro, Eric Harding, Antonio Tarver(people forget he won the first fight), Montell Griffin, Julio Gonzalez, Virgil Hill, Clinton Woods. These are solid to good wins that people don't give him credit for. Plus you add what he accomplished.

And, yea is Roy>Floyd.

[badass316]

LOL... Roy has Bhop and Toney on his resume, the debate should be pretty much end there.

[Ryannn]

toney and hopkins are better than any of floyd's wins.

gotta go with roy

[Walt Liquor]

people overrated floyd's resume like a mub.


corrales and castillo are his biggest wins.

according to his fans on here his biggest wins since 2003 jlc were ricky hatton at 147 and zab judah at 147

nice 8 year stretch and counting

[STRUGG]

Roy jones without a doubt.............................it aint the best resume......but its leaps and bounds above floyd