Better Resume - Montiel or Darchinyan?

[Eaner0919]

I did not bring up Rojas you idiot.

idiot?

wait

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10048499&postcount=6

"Should Tomas Rojas count as a notable win?

Also, you forgot to include Z Gorres for Montiel."

isn't that you? I mean is there more than one MXBoxingwhatever?

It was E-4-E who made a list that included Rojas and all I was ask him if he considered Rojas an elite fighter and you get all defensive.

no I didn't it's a debate, something apparently are not use to the way you are throwing insults my way for DEBATING your tired stance

Of course both have questionable guys. They have start somewhere and every now and then they have a tune up.

and that's the point I made as well only you seemingly are the only one on here who can bring that point up lol when in reality you seemingly have no clue as to what you are talking about.

The interim belt is not world championship belt.

while this is true it did give Rojas a legit shot at the legit BC belt, which he lost by KO to Vic.

and ......he went on to win a title showing that while yes he may not be a good fighter resume wise he has shown enough to be a champion

Furthermore, he won the vacant belt against Kohei Kono. Who is not a great fighter.

maybe but it's more than what ____ro Ga___ has done (sorry you said not to mention him again lol)

[Eaner0919]

At a time when Castillo did not matter anymore, yes.

and what does that make Arce? I mean if you think Castillo doesn't matter Arce should be about the same level right? considering he lost a fight he should have won going away and then only had to meaningless fights prior to facing Gallito.

or do you mean it only matters when it's convenient for your argument?

gotcha

[MXboxingfan]

idiot?

wait

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10048499&postcount=6

"Should Tomas Rojas count as a notable win?

Also, you forgot to include Z Gorres for Montiel."

isn't that you? I mean is there more than one MXBoxingwhatever?



no I didn't it's a debate, something apparently are not use to the way you are throwing insults my way for DEBATING your tired stance



and that's the point I made as well only you seemingly are the only one on here who can bring that point up lol when in reality you seemingly have no clue as to what you are talking about.



while this is true it did give Rojas a legit shot at the legit BC belt, which he lost by KO to Vic.

and ......he went on to win a title showing that while yes he may not be a good fighter resume wise he has shown enough to be a champion


maybe but it's more than what ____ro Ga___ has done (sorry you said not to mention him again lol)

Again. All did was was ask E-4-E if he thinks Tomas Rojas is an elite fighter because E-4-E made that list which brings up Rojas in first place and you go and look for some journeyman on Fernando Montiel's record as anybody was giving Montiel credit for that win.

[MXboxingfan]

and what does that make Arce? I mean if you think Castillo doesn't matter Arce should be about the same level right? considering he lost a fight he should have won going away and then only had to meaningless fights prior to facing Gallito.

or do you mean it only matters when it's convenient for your argument?

gotcha

Fernando never fought Arce. Vic did. And I never said Arce cannot beat Castillo.

[jrosales13]

Again. All did was was ask E-4-E if he thinks Tomas Rojas is an elite fighter because E-4-E made that list which brings up Rojas in first place and you go and look for some journeyman on Fernando Montiel's record as anybody was giving Montiel credit for that win.

I think Eaner brought up Isidro Gracia because E-4-E mentioned Garcia on the list of Montiel.

It seems that you ignore that Isidro was mentioned on the OP or Montiel list by the TS but focused on Rojas on Vic list.

[MXboxingfan]

I think Eaner brought up Isidro Gracia because E-4-E mentioned Garcia on the list of Montiel.

It seems that you ignore that Isidro was mentioned on the OP or Montiel list by the TS but focused on Rojas on Vic list.

I see. Well, I apologize Eaner. I did not know Isidro's nickname.

[£-4-£]

Mijares is a great victory for Vic but not Arce come on he was awsome but he was past it already hell i knew he would lose thought by early ko

Rojas is another good victory for Vic

In that case, replace Rojas with Irene Pacheco, who was a very good win for Vic. Pacheco was prime and undefeated

[£-4-£]

It's £-4-£, not E-4-E lol.

[Eaner0919]

I see. Well, I apologize Eaner. I did not know Isidro's nickname.

all good I just like debating rather than all this racial/nationalistic BS this board is now littered with

[theplayerpimp]

Gallito?

no way he was already past his best when he faced Montiel and was dealing with the build up of scar tissue which led him to having plastic surgery after the Nashiro fight in order to keep the cuts from happening. He had three soft fights and clearly wasn't ready for Montiel when they fought

Gallito was the first fighter I really followed when I started working media so I know a little bit about his career

If you follow el gallito than you know how great of a fighter he was. Much better than arce. Gallito was not in his prime but wasnt way pased it either had only lost twice and was holding his own for a little bit againts montiel. Arce on the other hand got destroyed by mijares and was way over hill.