Who has a better resume, Joe Calzaghe or Juan Diaz?

[SirTomJones]

Nice to see Daggum popped in

[studentofthegam]

roy as in roy jones jr? how is that a good win? a big name but he was completely shot.

A win over a shot Roy is still better than a controversial decision over Malignaggi right. Not the greatest win just better than the comparison.

[Steak]

A win over a shot Roy is still better than a controversial decision over Malignaggi right. Not the greatest win just better than the comparison.

youre comparing a win to a loss....

a shot Roy isnt better than a win over Julio Diaz.

Calzaghe has much better wins than his one over Jones, which most people(smartly) dont count at all.

[Naps]

Lacy would have dominated the sport if Calzaghe never existed.

[Steak]

Lacy would have dominated the sport if Calzaghe never existed.

no, he wouldnt have.

apart from the fact he struggled and got a gift in his next fight and he went on to struggle and get more gifts against Mendoza and Griffin, he also had a hard time against Omar Sheika and Syd Vanderpool.

Kessler win>Lacy. even Bika would have probably beaten Lacy.

[IronDanHamza]

It's obviously Calzaghe but Calzaghe's resume isn't too great at all to be honest.

[studentofthegam]

youre comparing a win to a loss....

a shot Roy isnt better than a win over Julio Diaz.

Calzaghe has much better wins than his one over Jones, which most people(smartly) dont count at all.

I didnt say Diaz. I said Malignaggi. Diaz won the first friend. Bhop shuts Diaz down though. I felt like the differences in resumes was that far apart. get it?

Lacy would have dominated the sport if Calzaghe never existed.

Lacy got drilled by that same shot RJJ. Guys this is really easy.

[Steak]

I didnt say Diaz. I said Malignaggi. Diaz won the first friend. Bhop shuts Diaz down though. I felt like the differences in resumes was that far apart. get it?



Lacy got drilled by that same shot RJJ. Guys this is really easy.

if youre assuming that Diaz legitimately beat Malignaggi(most think of it as a robbery and I was treating it as such) then yes, Diaz beating Malignaggi>Calzaghe beating Roy Jones Jr.

regardless, Calzaghe does clearly have a better resume than Juan Diaz.

[BennyST]

Dempsey and Marciano are overrated. Yes Im black. Sorry about that part.....................And posters have turned me against Willie Pep because they say he's better than Floyd. Call it what you want.

Errrr, call it what you want, but Pep has a resume ten times as good as Floyd's, he had a better prime record at his peak and was undefeated at 63-0 while champion before his first loss to the HOF great Sammy Angott then went to 132-1 before his next loss to the other HOF great Sandy Saddler. He also got revenge against Saddler

Before you start talking about fighting bums, go find out who he beat during those periods and come back and tell us all about the many HOFers, legends and champions he beat during his career.

240 career fights with only 11 losses. Two hundred and forty with only eleven losses.

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Joe Calzaghe obviously has a MUCH better resume than Diaz.

Sadly, a lot of people hate good white boxers like Calzaghe and the Klitschkos.

That aint sad at all if they are boring overrated fighters like those two. If you are going to nut hug a fighter just because he is white, at least find a good one. You guys are nut hugging boring ass fighters. Just switch to MMA where there are a lot more white fighters to choose from that are actually decent.