Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[Megamasterking]

Castillo got robbed, i get mad when i see bad decisions like that no matter who are the fighthers. For exemple: if 1 judge see a draw and the others see something like a 10-2 fight, it's just crazy, they should banned the *******.

[Picazo]

Castillo took it.

[The Gambler1981]

Castillo got robbed, i get mad when i see bad decisions like that no matter who are the fighthers. For exemple: if 1 judge see a draw and the others see something like a 10-2 fight, it's just crazy, they should banned the *******.

Such a stance is kind of weak, scoring fights is subjective if you put 100 people in a room you will get 100 different justification for scores.

2 or 3 rounds especially if both fighters aer doing things (like in this fight) is not a huge difference, hte judges all happeaned to like the work Floyd was doing, if it was different judges JLC might have been the one to get the overly wide scores, which would have been just as wrong~

[Heru]

Mayweather clearly won the first 4 rounds and if you can't find 3 rounds he won after that, then turn in your judging card.

Mayweather was winning the clean punching category, while Castillo was exerting his effective aggressiveness and ring generalship. Most of the punches Castillo landed according to Compubox were partial body shots.

[The Gambler1981]

Mayweather clearly won the first 4 rounds and if you can't find 3 rounds he won after that, then turn in your judging card.

Mayweather was winning the clean punching category, while Castillo was exerting his effective aggressiveness and ring generalship. Most of the punches Castillo landed according to Compubox were partial body shots.

And anyone who follows the scoring of fights know how judges feel about body punches as opposed to head punches~

[Weebler I]

I've been hating on Floyd of late, but imo Castillo didn't win the fight. I scored it a draw, it was that close. No real surprise they gave it to the champion fighting at home, fair enough imo (or at least, it's expected in boxing).

[PACnPBFsuck]

Castillo got robbed, i get mad when i see bad decisions like that no matter who are the fighthers. For exemple: if 1 judge see a draw and the others see something like a 10-2 fight, it's just crazy, they should banned the *******.

This happends in close fights, robbed is not what happened in this fight. You wanna see robbed, go watch Sturm vs De La Hoya, now that's robbery. This is nothing compared to that.

[Dan...]

Yep, because this has never been done before.

[Dan...]

Mayweather clearly won the first 4 rounds and if you can't find 3 rounds he won after that, then turn in your judging card.

Mayweather was winning the clean punching category, while Castillo was exerting his effective aggressiveness and ring generalship. Most of the punches Castillo landed according to Compubox were partial body shots.

Agree 100% with this post. Sums this fight up perfectly in my view.

[Megamasterking]

Such a stance is kind of weak, scoring fights is subjective if you put 100 people in a room you will get 100 different justification for scores.

2 or 3 rounds especially if both fighters aer doing things (like in this fight) is not a huge difference, hte judges all happeaned to like the work Floyd was doing, if it was different judges JLC might have been the one to get the overly wide scores, which would have been just as wrong~

But there is a limit, IMO a one sided fight can't be called a draw by anyone who still have at least one eye.