Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[gqjohnb]

Everyone thought Castillo won. He did win, but the judges said PBF won and thats what counts.

PBF won that fight. His record will show that. Castillos records shows he lost it.
But Castillo won that fight. Even ray charles can see that.

Naw Ray Charles wasn't a boxing fan...

[Pacquiao'd]

funny how people dont wanna mention floyd was fighting with one arm(torn rotator cuff)

gave an immediate rematch(healed arm) won that too

[Mitch5]

Even Floyd thought he lost that fight. And the fact that the judges didnt. Floyd thinks he is unbeatable if it goes to the decisions now. A fight he feels he clearly lost, he actually won.
Does wonders for the self esteem and belief. No wonder he believes in God if he delivers like that.

He did not clearly lose it was a close tough fight..jesus christ you people act like this was de la hoya-sturm or funeka-guzman...

[hugh grant]

funny how people dont wanna mention floyd was fighting with one arm(torn rotator cuff)

gave an immediate rematch(healed arm) won that too

I dont know if this is true, i havent read the reasons why he performed so poorly. But he did look like he performed like he had something wrong with him. Thats how poor he looked to me. Good at evading punches. But that is about all.

[Cherry Picker]

I had Castillo winning by 2 points, Mayweather didn't do enough to win the fight in my opinion. Sorry Floyd fans.

[deuce_drop]

i was at both those fights live and at the time i was rooting for mayweather, and being at both fights being very close to the ring, i thought castillo won both fights, and was actually in shock that mayweather won both fights, fighting the same in both fights.



watching it on tv, it was a lot closer, but still had castillo winning both fights, it's all OLD ASS NEWS, and doesn't mean a thing now.




ps, haha, lots of boths in my statement!!! made me laugh.

[hugh grant]

Nuff respect to Floyd he is unbeaten still. But when people look back at his fight with castillo in the majority of peoples eyes he lost that fight.

So in a way Pbf is not unbeaten like and unbeaten guy like marciano who had no controversial wins on his resume.
The castillo fight is not a fight you can say PBF won and you have to be honest there.

[Cherry Picker]

i was at both those fights live and at the time i was rooting for mayweather, and being at both fights being very close to the ring, i thought castillo won both fights, and was actually in shock that mayweather won both fights, fighting the same in both fights.



watching it on tv, it was a lot closer, but still had castillo winning both fights, it's all OLD ASS NEWS, and doesn't mean a thing now.

There you go guys, this dude was at both fights and he could see who really won.

[Mitch5]

There you go guys, this dude was at both fights and he could see who really won.

ok is he a judge? if not then who cares

[hugh grant]

There you go guys, this dude was at both fights and he could see who really won.

You hear something new everyday. I never saw the second fight, but by all accounts PBF won it clear to make up for the first one i heard.