Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[deuce_drop]

Nuff respect to Floyd he is unbeaten still. But when people look back at his fight with castillo in the majority of peoples eyes he lost that fight.

So in a way Pbf is not unbeaten like and unbeaten guy like marciano who had no controversial wins on his resume.
The castillo fight is not a fight you can say PBF won and you have to be honest there.

i'm with you, but just want to clarify something, marciano had some shady wins, there has been much talk over the years of him having favorable judging in some of his fights, but then again, boxing has always had some kind of shady scoring, and we all know the mob was looking out for every interests of marciano's, whether he wanted it or not........

[Steak]

On a side note, did mayweather actually seriosly hurt himself in the first castillo fight? I'm just wondering, because he was still throwing his right hand throughout the fight, and people like to exaggerate

like how clottey and other people insisted that he broke his hand in the Margarito fight, when in reality I believe it was only a minor stress fracture or something

[hugh grant]

i'm with you, but just want to clarify something, marciano had some shady wins, there has been much talk over the years of him having favorable judging in some of his fights, but then again, boxing has always had some kind of shady scoring, and we all know the mob was looking out for every interests of marciano's, whether he wanted it or not........

You may be right about the mob and marciano. And did he have some controversial wins? I havent seen all his fights, but i never heard Marciano having any favourable decisions

[Mitch5]

On a side note, did mayweather actually seriosly hurt himself in the first castillo fight? I'm just wondering, because he was still throwing his right hand throughout the fight, and people like to exaggerate

like how clottey and other people insisted that he broke his hand in the Margarito fight, when in reality I believe it was only a minor stress fracture or something

he had a torn rotator cuff in his left shoulder i believe

[Steak]

he had a torn rotator cuff in his left shoulder i believe

I've always wanted to get a medical report or follow up interview or something to find out what exactly was wrong with him, but never vould find one

[pasawayako]

I'm a big fan of floyd that time but there is no way that he won the fight, i gave floyd 5 rounds maximum.

[Cherry Picker]

ok is he a judge? if not then who cares

No but he was actually at the fight close to the ring, unlike you who has his head firmly stuck up his poop hole.

[Franco2012]

he landed around 100 more punches than floyd, everyone bar the crooked judges had castillo winning

And Castillo is way bigger puncher and he land clear punches unlike Floyd.

I had 115-111 for Castillo but you can go with 116-110 for Castillo also.

It was one of worse decisions in history of boxing.

[Franco2012]

he had a torn rotator cuff in his left shoulder i believe

medical report or its a lie!



Merchant owned him,he said if in first fight shoulder was the problem then what was now in second fight(second fight scorecards115-113 115-113 116-113)

Then Floyd was like I want to thx Leonard Ellerbe,Top Rank and bla bla bla

[Jatt]

^^^ It was a close fight that could have gone either way, But far from a robbery.