Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[Schmerzen]

for an anti-floyd forum the results look pretty good
usually floyd gets better from round to round, i dont understand why he won the first half of the fight so easily, and struggled in the 2. half..
against judah, mosley etc. he lost the first rounds and then dominated the rest of the fight.

[letsgobrady]

I think thats due the rounds castillo clearly won he won big and landed a lot of punches....but the fight was close its not like castillo blew him out floyd won the first 4 rounds clearly to me

i thought floyd won the 1st 5 rounds but clearly won the 1st 4

[Bhopreign]

TS and cungle are new boxing fans, sad little kids. Floyd won, whats even funnier is nobody ever brings up the fact Floyd was injured going into the fight and STILL WON!! All haters can hang their hat on is a close fight with an injured Mayweather, sad.

[[ILLMatic]]

Im Confused, were discussing mayweather vs castillo, but people are bringing up pacquiao ..

[Mr Punch.]

Floyd got a gift decision in that fight.

[cupocity303]

[SIZE="3"]

Here is how I scored it:

Round 1 - Floyd 10-9
Round 2 - Floyd 10-9
Round 3 - Floyd 10-9
Round 4 - Castillo 9-10
Round 5 - Floyd 10-9
Round 6 - Castillo 9-10
Round 7 - Castillo 9-10
Round 8 - Floyd 10-8 - Ref took away point from Castillo and Floyd was winning the Round.

Round 9 - Floyd 10-9
Round 10 - 9-9 - Ref took away point from Floyd and it was his best round of the fight.
Round 11 - Castillo 9-10 - Floyd stood right in front of him and they traded body shots. Castillo got the better of it.

Round 12 - Castillo 9-10 Castillo's most active round. He threw alot of combinations. His best round.

TOTAL = 114-112

6 rounds to 5 and 1 even.

Winner - Floyd Mayweather


Saying that Castillo CLEARLY WON is absurd, a lot of rounds were swing rounds where neither guy clearly won the round. Those are the ones that determined the fight.

[cupocity303]

Sidenote: why are there so many threads on this.

It's been covered a million times already.

[Bhopreign]

[SIZE="3"]

Here is how I scored it:

Round 1 - Floyd 10-9
Round 2 - Floyd 10-9
Round 3 - Floyd 10-9
Round 4 - Castillo 9-10
Round 5 - Floyd 10-9
Round 6 - Castillo 9-10
Round 7 - Castillo 9-10
Round 8 - Floyd 10-8 - Ref took away point from Castillo and Floyd was winning the Round.

Round 9 - Floyd 10-9
Round 10 - 9-9 - Ref took away point from Floyd and it was his best round of the fight.
Round 11 - Castillo 9-10 - Floyd stood right in front of him and they traded body shots. Castillo got the better of it.

Round 12 - Castillo 9-10 Castillo's most active round. He threw alot of combinations. His best round.

TOTAL = 114-112

6 rounds to 5 and 1 even.

Winner - Floyd Mayweather


Saying that Castillo CLEARLY WON is absurd, a lot of rounds were swing rounds where neither guy clearly won the round. Those are the ones that determined the fight.

I had it 114-113 Mayweather. Yea people dont know what the word robbery means these days.

[PrinceCharlez]

A lot of people think that Castillo won the first fight with Mayweather and he got robbed. Lederman's card on that night was 115-111 to Castillo. I also think Castillo got robbed. Poll coming up.

the fight was a good fight, but just cuz someone actually made it a good fight against Floyd doesnt mean he lost. Floyd won that fight hands down..

[Mr Punch.]

Poll says what the fans thought.