Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[The Gambler1981]

But there is a limit, IMO a one sided fight can't be called a draw by anyone who still have at least one eye.

Yea but it all depends on what can be explained, in a 12 round fight if both fighters clearly win 3 rounds each but the other six could go either way the range of scores can be 9-3 either way. Now 10-2 is messed up because one guy clearly won three rounds.

If a fight is scored 8-4 and people ***** robbery and say the fight should be socred 7-5 or no more you are only talking about 1 round and judging fights is not clear cut.


If you are going to complain save it for the truly bad moments otherwise the term ropbbery loses all meaning. Also results should be honored basically.

[Webber676]

Some times there are guys out there that judges give them the benefit of the doubt and that help them win a fight that in fact they didn't win, so to eliminate that problem those guys you need to knock them down and out.

Said that Mayweather clearly loss the first match but clearly won the second one. So please add me an * in that 41-0 record.

[DiegoFuego]

I've watched it about 4 times and each time I gave it to Castillo 115-113.

ummm how? there were two point deductions...obviously you HAVEN'T scored it or don't know how. Either way, you look ****** here.

[DiegoFuego]

Floyd won 4 or 5 of the first 6 rounds so I don't understand how anybody can act like it was a robbery, even if you gave it to Castillo. I have it 114-112 Floyd every time I score it and it's been at least 5 times.

[V.WEBB]

A lot of people think that Castillo won the first fight with Mayweather and he got robbed. Lederman's card on that night was 115-111 to Castillo. I also think Castillo got robbed. Poll coming up.

So, back when "you were a fan of Floyd at the lower weights" as you claim, you thought that or you think that now that you aren't a fan?

[V.WEBB]

Some times there are guys out there that judges give them the benefit of the doubt and that help them win a fight that in fact they didn't win, so to eliminate that problem those guys you need to knock them down and out.

Said that Mayweather clearly loss the first match but clearly won the second one. So please add me an * in that 41-0 record.

Clearly lost, huh?

[ManOfVictory]

I saw that fight live and Castillo won that fight. Leaving the arena even Mayweather fans were shaking their head!!

[Aut_72]

How many times have this thread been made???

[Vegan101]

without a doubt Castillo clearly out-boxed Scaredy Gayweather.

[Mitch5]

Castillo got robbed, i get mad when i see bad decisions like that no matter who are the fighthers. For exemple: if 1 judge see a draw and the others see something like a 10-2 fight, it's just crazy, they should banned the *******.

castillo did not get robbed,floyd clearly won the first five rounds..for example de la hoya-sturm is a robbery, or funeka guzman.