Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[johnm is...]

This is what it's come to. People are so desperate that they'll dig this far back to complain about a decision victory. Against a guy, mind you, that he clearly beat in the rematch.

...then turn around in the same breath and talk about how there's no way Pacquiao lost to Marquez.

You people are pathetic.

[Harold Lederman]

like it or not..floyds 41-0..no matter how much you complain and post this tired thread over and over and over again..floyds 41-0

I see that makes you all excited inside.

[Jack Napier]

Castillo won
he took the late rounds and closed strong
decision was garbage

[The Big Dunn]

Im just trying to point out th ******ity of the judging to you. Second fight was a clear win for Floyd and it was judged closer than the first fight that in my opinion was razor ***ing close.

Even you can understand why people are upset about the first one.

people are grasping at straws becasue this is the one fight that floyd had that was close. Look, some people really believe he lost and its fine. But if you only think he lost because you don't like him, that's silly.

[pistol whip]

like it or not..floyds 41-0..no matter how much you complain and post this tired thread over and over and over again..floyds 41-0

So is Chavez junior big ***ing deal. It's this obsession fans have with records that have made fighters so reluctent to put that 0 at risk thus making all the big fights we had 30 years ago non existent now.

[pistol whip]

people are grasping at straws becasue this is the one fight that floyd had that was close. Look, some people really believe he lost and its fine. But if you only think he lost because you don't like him, that's silly.

Oscar fight was close and it was even reported that one judge may have accidently given the last round to Floyd(by the ring magazine). So no that wasn't the only close fight Floyd had.

And HBO thought he lost and they like Floyd plenty!

[Mitch5]

Yeah they had it so right that the judges scored the second fight closer than the first fight. Come on Dunn everyday I have a harder time believing that you even watch boxing on a regular basis. Come on my friend there is a world of boxing outside of Floyd.

So you don't think its possible that some boxing fans can score the first fight for Floyd. The fight was a close fight..some had it for castillo some had it for floyd...the judges had it for floyd.

[War Dinamita]

Yeah theres more to the story than this but thanks for leaving out all the details so floyd could be made to look like he has the heart of a lion.

At the end of the day Floyd gave Castillo an immediate rematch instead of waiting years to fight him again. Why would he give Castillo an immediate rematch if he felt he was going to lose to Castillo?

[infamous larryx]

So is Chavez junior big ***ing deal. It's this obsession fans have with records that have made fighters so reluctent to put that 0 at risk thus making all the big fights we had 30 years ago non existent now.

are half of chavez jrs fights title fights??has he won 6 titles in 5 divisions??see thats the differance..and chavez jr has a draw

[pistol whip]

At the end of the day Floyd gave Castillo an immediate rematch instead of waiting years to fight him again. Why would he give Castillo an immediate rematch if he felt he was going to lose to Castillo?

Marquez got and immidiate rematch offered to him from Pac too(after the first draw) he just didn't accept. I don't blame Marquez to much for not accepting it but at the same time you cant call Pac a ducker when he fought the man twice already. Makes no sense "you are ducking the guy even though you went to war with him twice already".