who beat the better version of hatton??floyd or manny

[Castor_Troy]

Floyd beat a better version of Hatton. Regardless if you like Floyd or not, its true. To say PacMan beat a better version is just hattin.

PUTANGINANG Mga ALT's yan....

[check hook]

refute this bro.


140 Hatton > 147 Hatton.

simplistic analysis at best.......at worst it's plain silly.

[Sweet Jesus]

Floyd beat the better versions of Oscar and Ricky. Manny gets credit for the Cotto win over Mayweather/Marquez. Floyd gets credit for the Mosley win over Pacquiao/Clottey.

[whirlwind]

for those of you that say Hatton was overweight and had no business at 147 you know Hatton walking around weight is 195 right?

He was walking around that weight but did you see Hatton won belts at 147 and won all his fight at 147?

[check hook]

Floyd beat the better versions of Oscar and Ricky. Manny gets credit for the Cotto win over Mayweather/Marquez. Floyd gets credit for the Mosley win over Pacquiao/Clottey.

^^^^


this = a sane man talking..............take note ppl!!

[Castor_Troy]

simplistic analysis at best.......at worst it's plain silly.

Dont resort to those.

defend what you claim. You think a 147 Hatton is better than a 140 hatton?


and you're using the word silly on a statement saying "hatton is better at 140 than 147" ??

[V.WEBB]

-He's stronger on the inside at 140 w/c is critical in his style

-His power decreases at 147

How did you come to this conclusion? He had only had one fight at the weight PRIOR to fighting Mayweather at 147? He put Collazo down WITH HIS FIRST LEFT HOOK in the first round. Power decreases?

But Hatton and his trainer said that THEY WEREN'T PREPARED FOR COLLAZO when they fought him at his first fight at 147. Also, Collazo wasn't a push over. He was champ at the time Hatton fought him. Collazo also gave Berto a tough fight where many thought he won. His OPPONENT had alot to do with how he looked at his first fight at 147.

[Frank Ducketts]

Dont resort to those.

defend what you claim. You think a 147 Hatton is better than a 140 hatton?


and you're using the word silly on a statement saying "hatton is better at 140 than 147" ??

Hatton's weight was going to be his downfall in the end wether he lost at 140 and 147. People might say Hatton was better at 140, but he sure felt good going into those fights at 147.

[Frank Ducketts]

How did you come to this conclusion? He had only had one fight at the weight PRIOR to fighting Mayweather at 147? He put Collazo down WITH HIS FIRST LEFT HOOK in the first round. Power decreases?

But Hatton and his trainer said that THEY WEREN'T PREPARED FOR COLLAZO when they fought him at his first fight at 147. Also, Collazo wasn't a push over. He was champ at the time Hatton fought him. Collazo also gave Berto a tough fight where many thought he won. His OPPONENT had alot to do with how he looked at his first fight at 147.

Exactly!!!!!!!

[goldenglove2]

How did you come to this conclusion? He had only had one fight at the weight PRIOR to fighting Mayweather at 147? He put Collazo down WITH HIS FIRST LEFT HOOK in the first round. Power decreases?

But Hatton and his trainer said that THEY WEREN'T PREPARED FOR COLLAZO when they fought him at his first fight at 147. Also, Collazo wasn't a push over. He was champ at the time Hatton fought him. Collazo also gave Berto a tough fight where many thought he won. His OPPONENT had alot to do with how he looked at his first fight at 147.

exactley... Collazo was a very good opponent. Ricky, DEPSITE KNOCKING COLLAZO DOWN with his first left hook of the fight..went right back down to 140 stating 147 was a bit too much for him. Please dont act like Collazo didnt give that kid the worst beating of his career to date when they fought..he nearly stopped him.