who beat the better version of hatton??floyd or manny

[ADP02]

HAHAH did i hit a nerve with the truth???

Hatton was done after the floyd fight..it didn't matter what weight he came in..why are you pacfarts always looking for an excuse..freddy roach said it himself that he was shot and done..why are u **** ryders then saying the opposite..i thought freddy was the man.

Mayweather SR and Hatton thought it was going to be easy because Manny has too many flaws and does the same moves and so on.

[check hook]

depends on what u like, if u like seeing a high speed brawl with punches thrown from crazy angles until someone gets ktfo then the pac fight was for you. If you like to seeing some1 use tactics and skill and basically beat a previously undefeated fighter at his own game...well then u choose the mayweather victory. Either way u cant be wrong for prefering one over the other .

method of victory isn't the question though........??

It's who fought the better version. Now some fans want to argue a version that was savaged and KO'd in 10rds, physically and mentally destroyed in the biggest moment of their life and subsequently rocked in comeback bouts is somehow better than an undefeated version.

.......i just don't see it.

[daggum]

It's a well known fact that roach and arum look for beaten fighters or fighters who don't punch back like clottey,but is someone like mosley comes into the gym and asks for a fight then that's a NO NO because he might have some fight left in him..freddy couldn't take that risk.

we found out he didn't have any fight left in him. i'm sure freddy didn't want to beat up on a old shot fighter. in steps floyd.

[Castor_Troy]

HAHAH did i hit a nerve with the truth???

Hatton was done after the floyd fight..it didn't matter what weight he came in..why are you pacfarts always looking for an excuse..freddy roach said it himself that he was shot and done..why are u **** ryders then saying the opposite..i thought freddy was the man.

lol at that


done after his 1st loss and at a weight he's not comfortable?


Facts :

1. Hatton was undefeated at 140 before Pac

2. Hatton looks mediocre againts Collazo at 147.



140 Hatton > 147 Hatton

[chinoy]

boxers bounce off from their loses....

Ali lost to frazier and norton and then beat the hell out of them on the 2nd fight....

how did you knew he was done after the PBF fight since he won against Malignaggi after his pbr lose

i know you are dumb so please you dont need show it here in the forum.....

HAHAH did i hit a nerve with the truth???

Hatton was done after the floyd fight..it didn't matter what weight he came in..why are you pacfarts always looking for an excuse..freddy roach said it himself that he was shot and done..why are u **** ryders then saying the opposite..i thought freddy was the man.

[Wreckless]

Pacquiao.

Like it's been said, Hatton had most of his fights at 140. Mayweather fought hatton at 147, his natural weight. Where Hatton only had one other fight at besides Mayweather.
Hatton was the lineal champion at 140 and undefeated in 40+ of his fights.

[Frank Ducketts]

To me Floyd took took away Hatton's mindset of invincibility. Pac finished Hatton as an elite fighter. Who fought the better version? Both. Neither Pac or Floyd let Hatton win a round so I'd vote for both.

[V.WEBB]

You dudes are something else. SMH.

[Castor_Troy]

method of victory isn't the question though........??

It's who fought the better version. Now some fans want to argue a version that was savaged and KO'd in 10rds, physically and mentally destroyed in the biggest moment of their life and subsequently rocked in comeback bouts is somehow better than an undefeated version.

.......i just don't see it.

You dont see it?

All the point you mentioned are true but there is a single truth that is greater than all that.


Ricky Hatton is a Jr Welter weight fighter. That was his optimum weight and the lineal and undefeated champion at that weight...

Let me exaggerate a bit...


Calderon at 108 or Calderon at 112 ?
Morales at 122 or Morales at 126 ?
Duran at 135 or Duran above 135?



See it now?

[Castor_Troy]

You dudes are something else. SMH.

refute this bro.


140 Hatton > 147 Hatton.