who beat the better version of hatton??floyd or manny

[Left Hook Tua]

same damn hatton.

[Jim Jeffries]

same damn hatton.

No way man, Floyd fought him at a weight where he went life and death with Luis fricken Collazo. Pac fought him at a weight where he was undefeated.

[Doctor_Tenma]

No way man, Floyd fought him at a weight where he went life and death with Luis fricken Collazo. Pac fought him at a weight where he was undefeated.

Collazo ain't some **** fighter ya know.

[ELPacman]

Tough question because Fraud beat Hatton first. But Hatton clearly didn't belong @ 147lbs. Callazo almost stomped Hatton at that weight. Hatton was king at 140lbs and Pac made him look like absolutely nothing. Hatton even @ 147lbs hung in for abit with Fraud with some people giving him a round or 2.

[daggum]

hatton had to lose less weight when he fought mayweather therefore mayweather beat the better version of hatton than pac.

just like corrales had to lose less weight when he fought clottey so clottey beat the better version of corrales than mayweather.

just like castillo had to lose less weight when he fought alfonso gomez so gomez beat the better version of castillo than mayweather.

case closed!

[RockyB]

pretty close i would say,

Mayweather vs undefeated Hatton @ 147 = TKO10
Pac vs 1 loss @147 Hatton at Hattons ideal weight = KO2

I dont know, i'll go with Mayweather.
but Pac's win is definately more impressive.

[badecisioncotto]

lmao i cant believe that many people voted for manny, and the names that voted makes it even more hilarious.

[ADP02]

Boxing has weight classes for something. Hatton was undefeated at 140 moving up to Floyd comfort zone 147. If Floyd who's the one move down to Hatton comfort zone then Floyd beat the best of Hatton. Pac Fought Hatton where he was undefeated in his best weight 140 besides Pac moving down to Hatton comfort zone. Remember Pac last fight he fought Oscar at 147 moving down to 140 Hatton's best weight say a lot of things of his courage.

Yup, but since it's a Floyd vs Manny thing, all logic is thrown out of the window. For me this shouldn't even have been brought up if you know enough about boxing but like I said, bias beats logic every time in these threads!!! lol

Wait, Part 2 will be, who fought the better version of Marquez ..... while I expect it to be closer, you will still see people voting for Floyd.

[daggum]

Yup, but since it's a Floyd vs Manny thing, all logic is thrown out of the window. For me this shouldn't even have been brought up if you know enough about boxing but like I said, bias beats logic every time in these threads!!! lol

Wait, Part 2 will be, who fought the better version of Marquez ..... while I expect it to be closer, you will still see people voting for Floyd.

marquez was stronger at 146 cause he had to lose less weight. floyd just outclassed him using his mad skillz.

[miron_lang]

Mayweather did.

Only an idiot or ******* would say pacquiao.

So if you vote for pac you are either an idiot or a *******.

Hatton is a better @140 than @147. No?