Manny Pacquiao Or Marvin Hagler. Who's Greater?

[Bennett]

BoxRec Annual Ratings:
9 Top Ranks - Pacquiao
7 Top Ranks - Hagler

Ring Fighter of the Year:
3 (2006, 2008, 2009) - Pacquiao
2 (1983, 1985) - Hagler

Lineal Titles:
4 - Pacquiao
1 - Hagler

all that **** dont mean ****.

[F l i c k e r]

Can Pacquiao beat Hearns? No.

Can Pacquiao beat Duran? Possibly.

Would Pacquiao do better than Hagler against Leonard? Hell no.



Could Hagler beat ODLH? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Cotto? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Clottey? Hell yes.



That pretty much tells me everything I need to know. Can't bring up MAB, EM, JMM, etc. Too low in weight. If you bring them up, it's 1st round kayo every fight for Hagler.

[Pacquiao'd]

only *******swill vote pac

[jrosales13]

Can Pacquiao beat Hearns? No.

Can Pacquiao beat Duran? Possibly.

Would Pacquiao do better than Hagler against Leonard? Hell no.



Could Hagler beat ODLH? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Cotto? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Clottey? Hell yes.



That pretty much tells me everything I need to know. Can't bring up MAB, EM, JMM, etc. Too low in weight. If you bring them up, it's 1st round kayo every fight for Hagler.

Is that how we rank who is greater now? That is the criteria?

[jrosales13]

only *******swill vote pac

Only Pac haters would say Hagler easily.

[Left Banned Tua]

Can Pacquiao beat Hearns? No.

Can Pacquiao beat Duran? Possibly.

Would Pacquiao do better than Hagler against Leonard? Hell no.



Could Hagler beat ODLH? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Cotto? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Clottey? Hell yes.



That pretty much tells me everything I need to know. Can't bring up MAB, EM, JMM, etc. Too low in weight. If you bring them up, it's 1st round kayo every fight for Hagler.

are you seriously comparing how hagler would do against welterweight pacquiao fought?

seriously?

[The Noose]

Can Pacquiao beat Hearns? No.

Can Pacquiao beat Duran? Possibly.

Would Pacquiao do better than Hagler against Leonard? Hell no.



Could Hagler beat ODLH? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Cotto? Yes.

Could Hagler beat Clottey? Hell yes.



That pretty much tells me everything I need to know. Can't bring up MAB, EM, JMM, etc. Too low in weight. If you bring them up, it's 1st round kayo every fight for Hagler.

Holy **** thats dumb.

If the comparison was between Willie Pep and Valuev.....ah i cant be arsed.

[Left Banned Tua]

Eh, Hopkins 20 title defenses, unified undisputed MW champ. And, went up to 175 to win a title. Hagler resume is better but not that much better. MW resume yes Hagler is way better. But, with B-Hop going to 175 and being a top fighter closed in overall IMO.

bull****.

it's a disgrace to even mention hopkins to hagler.

hopkins sucks balls.

[Left Banned Tua]

Holy **** thats dumb.

If the comparison was between Willie Pep and Valuev.....ah i cant be arsed.

john ruiz would have beat hearns , duran and leonard.

marvin hagler wouldn't have beaten rahman , golota and mccline.

ruiz > hagler

[them_apples]

Hagler he fought the best at their best ,the ducking accusations and picking opponennts when they were fading just can't be leveled again st him. Both are great fighters but Hagler is greater.

no, even him you can pick apart, just like you are doing to Pacquiao. Hagler fought Leonard and Hearns at middleweight, that's not their best. Thats them moving up in weight. He fought Duran was middleweight as well, that's not even close to his best. You can't apply something to one fighter and not the other. Manny fought his oponents in their respective weight class, generally..since he is the top dog right now people make up even softer excuses like they are past it and such.