What DEFINES Greatness... Skills Or Resume?

[Mickey Gomez]

It's a mixture of both.

[FatBastard]

"Balls" defines greatness.

[talip bin osman]

"Balls" defines greatness.

mayorga & gatti got it...

but they aint that great...

[FatBastard]

mayorga & gatti got it...

but they aint that great...

SO Floyd the coward because he has skills and O losses is great ?

[Bad Boy Dazza]

Skills don't mean **** if you lack the balls to face the best.

What if you are the most skilled race car driver in the world, could out race anyone in your own back yard race course, but never race the best? Who gives a **** about you then?

[talip bin osman]

SO Floyd the coward because he has skills and O losses is great ?

i never mentioned such things mi amigo...

& i really dont think skills should be a criteria in defining greatness bcoz its meaningless if u think about it... its quite misleading TBH...

ivan calderon is one of the best in terms of skills in this era but can u see his name in this website's top 10 this decade?

then this "0" thing...

u hav joan guzman who is as "skilled" as they come with zero losses...
but would an well informed & objective fan be able to tell he is greater than erik morales?

no... not a chance in hell man...

its gotta be ur resume of wins against top opposition above all else...

the circumstances that surrounded those wins...

then perhaps ur longevity...

[hammerhiem]

Resume is the first thing on my list when i judge greatness, second is longevity/era, third is skill and last is impact on the sport/intangables like charisma.

[JAB5239]

Resume is the first thing on my list when i judge greatness, second is longevity/era, third is skill and last is impact on the sport/intangables like charisma.

Excellent criteria!!

[KittenFlaps]

Resume.

Just ask Hagler. He had all the skills of a great, and no one gave a damn till Hearns.

[SplitSecond]

resume = skills