Who is P4P if Mayweather returns ?

[Jone2ts]

Until Floyd loses he is P$P also considering Pacman has been brutally KO'd twice Floyd easy...He has Never Lost Ever and until he does or is too old to fight he's the king.

[crj-lead]

Better they fight together to clear it up.

[Smash]

I think he has got to prove it by beating a few top guys. From july 2005 to june 2008 he was ranked p4p no 1 by ring. Coming up to that point and from then on this is who he fought

Henry Bruseles
Arturo Gatti
Shramba Mitchell
Zab Judah
Baldomir
De la hoya
Hatton

Huh?? How did he get p4p with that record?? On top to that hatton at 147 is poor and de la hoya is past it. It just doesnt make much sense to me

[QUISQUEYA]

I think he has got to prove it by beating a few top guys. From july 2005 to june 2008 he was ranked p4p no 1 by ring. Coming up to that point and from then on this is who he fought

Henry Bruseles
Arturo Gatti
Shramba Mitchell
Zab Judah
Baldomir
De la hoya
Hatton
Huh?? How did he get p4p with that record?? On top to that hatton at 147 is poor and de la hoya is past it. It just doesnt make much sense to me

Then, what is Pac accomplishing by beating Delahoya and hatton??

If it wasn't an accomplishment for Floyd, then it is LESS of an accomplishemnet by Pac to beat them two years later. Right?

[El Dominicano]

For me, once Floyd wins a fight he's #1.

What he said and Pac will once again stare up at Mayweather (Something he did for very long)

[El Dominicano]

Then, what is Pac accomplishing by beating Delahoya and hatton??

If it wasn't an accomplishment for Floyd, then it is LESS of an accomplishemnet by Pac to beat them two years later. Right?

Pac is the so called smaller man, when Pac has always weighed more fight night at 130, 135. Pac was 148 against DLH, Mayweather weighed that much in his 1st fight at 154

[Benny Leonard]

On Paper, it will be Pac. You shouldn't take it away from him even though the King has returned. Plus, it may help motivate Floyd to regain "it" which he may need since he hasn't fought like he wanted to prove himself for a long time.


But, let's put it this way: THEY NEED FLOYD MORE THAN FLOYD NEEDS THEM FOR LEGACY. All the talk about how Floyd needs Pac, etc. etc. etc. BULL****. Floyd retired Champ and with his P4P status intact with his "O." That's why I voted for Floyd because it is a symbolic title and when he returns, he'll still be the #1 Most Wanted; Pretty Boy Floyd Mayweather {Jr}.

Can Floyd get a boost in Legacy by fighting certain fighters? YES, and he should fight certain fighters like COTTO, maybe Williams, Mosley, and Pac (if he beats Hatton because if he doesn't, cross that name off). He could even fight JMM because I'm on the same page with some others that any fighter that was in any division you had previously fought in, is OK to fight.

[El Dominicano]

On Paper, it will be Pac. You shouldn't take it away from him even though the King has returned. Plus, it may help motivate Floyd to regain "it" which he may need since he hasn't fought like he wanted to prove himself for a long time.


But, let's put it this way: THEY NEED FLOYD MORE THAN FLOYD NEEDS THEM FOR LEGACY. All the talk about how Floyd needs Pac, etc. etc. etc. BULL****. Floyd retired Champ and with his P4P status intact with his "O." That's why I voted for Floyd because it is a symbolic title and when he returns, he'll still be the #1 Most Wanted; Pretty Boy Floyd Mayweather {Jr}.

Can Floyd get a boost in Legacy by fighting certain fighters? YES, and he should fight certain fighters like COTTO, maybe Williams, Mosley, and Pac (if he beats Hatton because if he doesn't, cross that name off). He could even fight JMM because I'm on the same page with some others that any fighter that was in any division you had previously fought in, is OK to fight.

Come to think of it, I'd perfer Pac at number 1. It'll only push Floyd

[Benny Leonard]

Pac is the so called smaller man, when Pac has always weighed more fight night at 130, 135. Pac was 148 against DLH, Mayweather weighed that much in his 1st fight at 154

Agree; Pac really isn't the "smaller" man. He was 152 pounds with 6% bodyfat in training for Oscar. That's incredible. He weighed in at 149+ for his fight with Oscar. That's the same weight Floyd is said to have weighed in for his WW fights. Floyd's not big at all. Considering Pac weighed in at 147 by fight-night against Diaz {135 division}, somebody is not fighting in right weight class which is why he moved up. Pac's a full grown man now and not a child. If people want to keep bringing up where he started then I'll keep bringing up how he was KTFO twice. He's a Man at 147+ now and is better. That's my thoughts.

[Benny Leonard]

Then, what is Pac accomplishing by beating Delahoya and hatton??

If it wasn't an accomplishment for Floyd, then it is LESS of an accomplishemnet by Pac to beat them two years later. Right?

Consider what Roach had to say about both Hatton and Oscar. Oscar was basically dead by fight-time and Hatton, according to Roach, is past his best since Floyd.