Is Manny Pacquiao a top 20 all time?

[haploid]

ATG list eh? I dont know how to rank these boxers if their not on my era. I will just choose ATGs from my lifetime. If that's the case, Pacquiao must crack the top 15, am 20 y.o.

[boojee]

Actually Pac is more like in TOP 10-15 ATG

[strugler]

Leornard and Duran were undisputed champs at one time. I don't consider Floyd just like Pacman top 20....

I mean Dingaan Thobela fought from lightweight to super middleweight, and was champion at junior lightweight, lightweight and super middleweight, with that logic he has a shot at the top 50....

I see where you re going but sure as hell dont think that Thobela didnt beat multiple future hall of famers and futue Alltime greats while on the way did he? its a subjective list my friend.you can put Thobela in your list really if you want to.

[Great Afrikan]

I see where you re going but sure as hell dont think that Thobela didnt beat multiple future hall of famers and futue Alltime greats while on the way did he? its a subjective list my friend.you can put Thobela in your list really if you want to.

my point is Thobela isn't anywhere close to Top 100 and neither does Manny belong in top 20 ATG. He's great, but not that great.....

[strugler]

my point is Thobela isn't anywhere close to Top 100 and neither does Manny belong in top 20 ATG. He's great, but not that great.....

At this time i dont rank him as top 20 but if he beats hatton( a beast and undefeatedin 140), then floyd (p4p one of the most talented boxer of any era) and Miguel Cotto( I really am not sure how great he could be) he will be the best off this era, top 15 in my ATG at least.
Most dont think he is top 20 right now,

[C.Y.]

no pacman isnt top 20 get off his penis.. he's top 100, you can argue top 50

[Bogler]

**** it if he gets hatton lineal title at 140 and wins over floyd at 147, id put pac in top 10ATG. EASILY.

[boojee]

Floyd is retired, he's my boy too, but i think he wants none of Pac and will stay retired because of that. after Pac beats Hatton, then Cotto. top 10 easily.

[silip03]

Depends how you define generation. If you include Roy, surely you need to include Sweet Pea? In which case, I don't think you can seriously argue Floyd is the most talented.

Yes i will not argue floyd is a talented chicken. he is not even close to top 100 atg. pacquiao has better resume than floyd. floyd always ducking fighter.

[larryx]

hell naw............