Did Joe Calzaghe do enough to warrent a fight with Roy?

[nathan_nall]

???? I think Roy needed Joe.... at the very best, they needed each other equally.

[S.G.]

yeah, sure he did

they both wanted a payday

Jones is not some holy grail, out of reach to mere mortals

[Enemy/Friend]

Nice response Reed. I don't know if it's a bait thread or just ******, but clearly the Ring Champion and agreed top of the division guy clearly deserves a shot at anyone in it. It's ridiculous to suggest otherwise, when your top dog no matter how you got there, loads of people want to fight you. Did Roy do enough, well he had 3 fights to slowly get him back up in the rankings and looking better, but Reed's right it was also his previous stuff and legend, name that made the fight.

Nard was the #1 guy he'd already beaten, Chad doesn't bring much money or anything really, and Johnson just got beat by him and same applies.

It was, what it was.

I wasn't talking about their current status as fighters. I am talking the period where they "avoided" each other.

[Enemy/Friend]

i am talking about the jones that ment something when he was p4p fighter not a gate keeper

[S A M U R A I]

i want credit for my unbiasness... right now.

Credited. And I agree with you.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[bsrizpac]

i am talking about the jones that ment something when he was p4p fighter not a gate keeper

This thread really shows how many people started watching boxing in the last few years . LOL

[Abstraction]

Fact is, if Roy was as good as he was in his Prime. Calzaghe would not have faced him.

He had his chance in 2001 but he never took it. His own loss

[THE REED]

i wouldnt even call him a gatekeeper at this point

[Kris Silver]

I wasn't talking about their current status as fighters. I am talking the period where they "avoided" each other.

I read Reed's response and thought so, then read your opening post again. You don't make that clear at all, in fact everything suggests it was on actual events.

Anyways despite that sorry for such a response but that was the reason. If your going to talk retrospectively then it might help if you actually state that and also narrow down exactly when in history?

When Roy was at MW, when Roy briefly visited SMW, when Roy was at LHW?

[Enemy/Friend]

This thread really shows how many people started watching boxing in the last few years . LOL

Are these people ******ed? Charlie Zelenoff could get a shot at the current Jones.