Who is Higher All Time Great? Pac or Floyd

[Benny Leonard]

Pacquiao's resume tops Mayweather's at the moment.

In the end I thik it will hurt Mayweather.

If he had fought at least one top guy at 147 that was dangerous, like Margarito, and Won, that would be the end of the debate.

Margarito > Pac's entire resume.

But, Floyd didn't.

That's why I said if he did come back, he could skip Pac and fight Margarito because that is a lot bigger legacy wise; just not money wise.

[nujabes77]

"Originally Posted by FasTHarD
Castillo, Corrales and Hernandez vs Todays pacquiao? It would be all by KO/TKO..."

I say this kindly and because I'm concerned for your health: Lay off the Arsenic

i agree with fast, ko for all these guy. pacquiao is p4p, the best boxer in the world, something they lacked

[nujabes77]

In the end I thik it will hurt Mayweather.

If he had fought at least one top guy at 147 that was dangerous, like Margarito, and Won, that would be the end of the debate.

Margarito > Pac's entire resume.

But, Floyd didn't.

That's why I said if he did come back, he could skip Pac and fight Margarito because that is a lot bigger legacy wise; just not money wise.

margarito > pac's resume? what a joker...

[Fox McCloud]

"Originally Posted by FasTHarD
Castillo, Corrales and Hernandez vs Todays pacquiao? It would be all by KO/TKO..."




i agree with fast, ko for all these guy. pacquiao is p4p, the best boxer in the world, something they lacked

Corrales had a shaky chin... Hernandez quit everytime he was being dominated... I'll spot you those two.

No ****ing way Pacquiao KOs that version of Castillo... 0 chance that he gets stopped.

Calling his chin iron is underrating Castillo's chin.

[Benny Leonard]

margarito > pac's resume? what a joker...

Are you serious?

A win over Margarito would be better than Pac and his resume. I was talking about Floyd.

I'm not saying how good each person was in their weight division and comparing that...but, who is the best fighter out of the bunch? It's Margarito. Why, because in my opinion, Margarito beats them all so that is a greater win in my book.

Understand or do I need to go on?

[MakeDamnSure]

In the end I thik it will hurt Mayweather.

If he had fought at least one top guy at 147 that was dangerous, like Margarito, and Won, that would be the end of the debate.

Margarito > Pac's entire resume.

But, Floyd didn't.

That's why I said if he did come back, he could skip Pac and fight Margarito because that is a lot bigger legacy wise; just not money wise.

Why don't you make a Poll and Ask if Margarito vs Pac is a fair and even fight with your own ****** ideas? You look like a ****** monkey here.

[Benny Leonard]

Corrales had a shaky chin... Hernandez quit everytime he was being dominated... I'll spot you those two.

No ****ing way Pacquiao KOs that version of Castillo... 0 chance that he gets stopped.

Calling his chin iron is underrating Castillo's chin.

True, but he kept getting back up...except with Castillo in their last fight. I think Corrales was burnt by then. I remember people calling it the Greatest fight they had ever see, but when asked if they would like to see them fight again, the majority response: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

His chin was good enough to withstand Freitas and I don't think MAB, EM, and JMM hit harder than Freitas.

[nujabes77]

Are you serious?

A win over Margarito would be better than Pac and his resume. I was talking about Floyd.

I'm not saying how good each person was in their weight division and comparing that...but, who is the best fighter out of the bunch? It's Margarito. Why, because in my opinion, Margarito beats them all so that is a greater win in my book.

Understand or do I need to go on?

trying to justify your absurd statement makes you sound comical. and yes pigs fly, LOLZ

[Fox McCloud]

True, but he kept getting back up...except with Castillo in their last fight. I think Corrales was burnt by then. I remember people calling it the Greatest fight they had ever see, but when asked if they would like to see them fight again, the majority response: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

His chin was good enough to withstand Freitas and I don't think MAB, EM, and JMM hit harder than Freitas.

Even so... he wore down when he went down.

Casamayor was starching him with his straight left.

Pacquiao's straight left > Casamayor's.

Even if he did keep getting up, Pacquiao's chin is unreal... I'm not sure Corrales could break it, and Corrales going down a million times to the left hand means that he loses a decison if it goes the distance.

[Benny Leonard]

Why don't you make a Poll and Ask if Margarito vs Pac is a fair and even fight with your own ****** ideas? You look like a ****** monkey here.

So you didn't get what I was saying?


If Floyd had fought and beat Margarito, that would end the discussion who has the better legacy. But of course, Floyd didn't and leaves himself open.

So how was Floyd vs. Margarito a fair fight?

Like Flawless pointed out: Both Floyd and Manny at 16 weighed the same. You know, the same weight you and some other posters like to continue to bring up where Manny started.

And then considering both Floyd and Manny show up for their fights at 147+ and Margarito shows up as a Middleweight, how is that fair?

My thing against Floyd in this case was that he opened his mouth and said he was the best at 147 yet he didn't fight the likes of Margarito, Cotto, and Williams.

Manny on the other hand, who did go up to 147 and won't fight them as well, didn't say such things and went back down.