Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time?

[bsrizpac]

We'll watch Floyd for the future....if there is one. He makes ATG unless he gets seriously exposed. I doubt he'll ever fight one of his truly dangerous peers, though. His track record suggests otherwise. This is the lingering question regarding Floyd.

Didn't you spend countless threads saying Hatton was a truly dangerous peer and that Floyd had ducked him all along?

[Tha_Greatest]

Pro and Con my friend. Just on the fence on this one.

how does it taste

[Wiley Hyena]

Didn't you spend countless threads saying Hatton was a truly dangerous peer and that Floyd had ducked him all along?

I never said Floyd "ducked" Hatton. That doesn't even make sense. But, alot of what you say doesn't make sense. Didn't you say RJJ would KO Calzaghe? That didn't make sense either.

[Dan...]

I never said Floyd "ducked" Hatton. That doesn't even make sense. But, alot of what you say doesn't make sense. Didn't you say RJJ would KO Calzaghe? That didn't make sense either.

I would say that, on the balance of proabilities, it is quite unlikely that Roy Jones would stop Calzaghe in a prime for prime matchup. Having said that, it is not as though there isn't a case that can be made for saying that. If a near 40 year old shot version of Roy Jones who has not stopped an opponent for several years can drop and hurt Calzaghe, it is not out of the question that a prime and determined Jones could have stopped him. Remember, this is the Roy JOnes that could not stop Hashaw, Badi or a blown up and old Tito.

[DrewWoodside]

I never said Floyd "ducked" Hatton. That doesn't even make sense. But, alot of what you say doesn't make sense. Didn't you say RJJ would KO Calzaghe? That didn't make sense either.

this thread embarasses boxing scene and it embarasses calzaghe fans. Someone should delete it.

[Dan...]

this thread embarasses boxing scene and it embarasses calzaghe fans. Someone should delete it.

To be fair it certainly is not alone.

[Wiley Hyena]

this thread embarasses boxing scene and it embarasses calzaghe fans. Someone should delete it.

Yeah, it's tough......for some to consider that what we've seen from Calzaghe is pretty special. ROFL!

[bsrizpac]

I never said Floyd "ducked" Hatton. That doesn't even make sense. But, alot of what you say doesn't make sense. Didn't you say RJJ would KO Calzaghe? That didn't make sense either.

No I didn't I said Roy would lose since this fight was signed. I've been saying Roy was shot on here since 04.

Try again.

A LOT of people said Floyd was ducking Hatton until he fought him. So how does that not make sense again?

Idiot.

[Wiley Hyena]

I would say that, on the balance of proabilities, it is quite unlikely that Roy Jones would stop Calzaghe in a prime for prime matchup. Having said that, it is not as though there isn't a case that can be made for saying that. If a near 40 year old shot version of Roy Jones who has not stopped an opponent for several years can drop and hurt Calzaghe, it is not out of the question that a prime and determined Jones could have stopped him. Remember, this is the Roy JOnes that could not stop Hashaw, Badi or a blown up and old Tito.

There's a case to be made for either boxer in a quality match up. But, it's a little hypocritical to say RJJ would destroy Joe, and then after he lost to say that RJJ was just a washed up old man.

[cuzfozzy]

calzaghe the best ? hell yeah . never defeated
many tried all failed ..