Is Calzaghe a Top 25 Fighter in the last 30 Years?

[Xplosivo]

We just had a poll about Tito and TArver and a lot of people think that Tito was a bigger victory for Bhop. So now Tito is too small for Winky but he was just about the right size for Hopkins?

What is wrong with you!

i seriously used to think you were a credible poster

ofcourse tarver is the better win for hopkins, who would be the better win for klitschko, haye or miguel cotto? Tito was a natural welterweight who lost when he moved several weight classes above his natural weight, he was undefeated at WW and beat big names there. something calzaghe has NEVER done in his whole career...not a beat a single great fighter in his prime, NEVER...he has that 0 because he has been cherry picking carefully.

[majestiC]

Pernell Whitaker
Oscar De La Hoya
Felix Trinidad got his ass handing to him by Hopkins
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins was beaten by Calzaghe after coming of a career best win
Floyd Mayweather
Lennox Lewis
Evander Holyfield
Mike Tyson sorry Mike was great in his prime, but any fighter that loses vs McBride can't be considered better than Calzaghe
Larry Holmes
George Foreman
Manny Pacquiao
Erik Morales
Marco Antonio Barrera
Julio Cesar Chavez
James Toney lost to ****ty Griffen twice......
Juan Manuel Marquez
Wilfredo Gomez
Alexis Arguello
Miguel Cotto Bit early to be saying Cotto is better? he was almost KO'd by Torres
Aaron Pryor
Roberto Duran
Kostya Tsyzu Lost to a average Phillips
Thomas Hearns
Sugar Ray Leonard
Winky Wright Lost to Hopkins recently....
Shane Mosley Loses to Forrest...
Michael Spinks
Jose Luis Castillo Far to many loses....

[Xplosivo]

calzaghe is NOT better than any of those fighters.... i can't believe the extent to which some people will nut hug........unbelieveable

it is pathetic...i swear to god i cant believe how extreme can these calzaghe nutlickers go, next thing you know they will argue on why Calzaghe is better than Ray Robinson and try to convince people....

Fact is calzaghe can never say he has beaten a great fighter in his prime....all those other guys can

[pesticid]

i seriously used to think you were a credible poster

ofcourse tarver is the better win for hopkins, who would be the better win for klitschko, haye or miguel cotto? Tito was a natural welterweight who lost when he moved several weight classes above his natural weight, he was undefeated at WW and beat big names there. something calzaghe has NEVER done in his whole career...not a beat a single great fighter in his prime, NEVER...he has that 0 because he has been cherry picking carefully.

Did I vote Tito?

I voted Tarver. That's besides the point though. Check your poll! What does it show? A split opinion.

[majestiC]

it is pathetic...i swear to god i cant believe how extreme can these calzaghe nutlickers go, next thing you know they will argue on why Calzaghe is better than Ray Robinson and try to convince people....

Fact is calzaghe can never say he has beaten a great fighter in his prime....all those other guys can

oh dont be so over dramatic, what are you a ****ing drama queen?

[Xplosivo]

Pernell Whitaker
Oscar De La Hoya
Felix Trinidad got his ass handing to him by Hopkins
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins was beaten by Calzaghe after coming of a career best win
Floyd Mayweather
Lennox Lewis
Evander Holyfield
Mike Tyson sorry Mike was great in his prime, but any fighter that loses vs McBride can't be considered better than Calzaghe
Larry Holmes
George Foreman
Manny Pacquiao
Erik Morales
Marco Antonio Barrera
Julio Cesar Chavez
James Toney lost to ****ty Griffen twice......
Juan Manuel Marquez
Wilfredo Gomez
Alexis Arguello
Miguel Cotto Bit early to be saying Cotto is better? he was almost KO'd by Torres
Aaron Pryor
Roberto Duran
Kostya Tsyzu Lost to a average Phillips
Thomas Hearns
Sugar Ray Leonard
Winky Wright Lost to Hopkins recently....
Shane Mosley Loses to Forrest...
Michael Spinks
Jose Luis Castillo Far to many loses....

this has to be a classic post of how some boxing fans are either really ****** or just plain ignorant. maybe your new to the sport and in need of some guidance...trinidad losing to hopkins does not matter because trinidad is a natural welterweight while hopkins is a natural light heavyweight, and hopkins is considered one of the best fighters. its funny how u hypocrites downplay hopkins win against trinidad yet say trinidad isnt great because he lost to hopkins...some brits are the worst posters here honestly why cant u nationalistic ****s get this out of ur brain for once...Next thing you will say Calzaghe is better than Ali too since he lost too Trevor Berbick right? calzaghe barely edged past that ancient hopkins who a welterweight trinidad faced 7 years earlier.

[pesticid]

You know what's also funny, Shane Mosley is a proven juicer.

[aussieboxer2320]

I guess Floyd's resume is a little stronger than Zaghe's but not by much. How come Floyd is the greatest but Zaghe can't even be the 25th in the last 30 years.

not by much???? floyd has beat corrales, castillo, de la hoya, hatton , baldomir, judah....................who has calzaghe beat???

a washed up eubank?

kessler??? in his prime yes, but definitely not an all time great

a 43 year old hopkins??? (by the skin of his teeth)


****** thing to say mate

[majestiC]

this has to be a classic post of how some boxing fans are either really ****** or just plain ignorant. maybe your new to the sport and in need of some guidance...trinidad losing to hopkins does not matter because trinidad is a natural welterweight while hopkins is a natural light heavyweight, and hopkins is considered one of the best fighters. its funny how u hypocrites downplay hopkins win against trinidad yet say trinidad isnt great because he lost to hopkins...some brits are the worst posters here honestly why cant u nationalistic ****s get this out of ur brain for once...Next thing you will say Calzaghe is better than Ali too since he lost too Trevor Berbick right? calzaghe barely edged past that ancient hopkins who a welterweight trinidad faced 7 years earlier.

oh please, Hopkins isn't a natural light-heavy he was middleweight champion for years fighting smaller guys. Trinidad went up in weight twice, jesus his last fight was at light heavy...., he also got whooped by Winky. Trinidad was hardly a small welter was he?

[~Lucky13~]

not by much???? floyd has beat corrales, castillo, de la hoya, hatton , baldomir, judah....................who has calzaghe beat???

a washed up eubank?

kessler??? in his prime yes, but definitely not an all time great

a 43 year old hopkins??? (by the skin of his teeth)


****** thing to say mate

you'd be in the stone age if it wasn't for calzaghe's ancestors, so shut your mouth you Aussie!