Is Calzaghe a Top 25 Fighter in the last 30 Years?

[Xplosivo]

Kessler is a great fighter, who will dominate the Super Middleweight division for years to come.... that I am sure of. Hopkins was coming of a career best win vs Tarver and win against a very good Winky Wright. Calzaghe didn't get a gift vs Hopkins don't be so ****ing ****** he outlanded him every single round..... the Reid fight was a close one could have gone either way, but you try fighting a prime Reid who is very underated with one hand and still come out on top. You can pick holes in all those fighters lists like you've just done.

kessler is a great fighter? what has he done...oh wait "he will do it..." he hasnt done **** yet, anyone can make assumptions. he was considering retirement a few days back LOL.

[aussieboxer2320]

gatti has fought better people than calzaghe! but yes calzaghe beat kessler to capture most of the major titles at smw so he has achieved more, but gatti had a million times the heart of that ****wit

[majestiC]

gatti has fought better people than calzaghe! but yes calzaghe beat kessler to capture most of the major titles at smw so he has achieved more, but gatti had a million times the heart of that ****wit

How can you question Calzaghe's heart he fights the 12th round like the first, oooo wow Gatti has heart because he defends with his face.......

[pesticid]

How can you question Calzaghe's heart he fights the 12th round like the first, oooo wow Gatti has heart because he defends with his face.......

We're dealing with two of the most immature posters on this board.

[Drunk Punch]

I voted for Calzaghe, but on reflection I think he would need to beat Pavlik to truly earn a spot amongst such great company.

[Dirt E Gomez]

How can you question Calzaghe's heart he fights the 12th round like the first, oooo wow Gatti has heart because he defends with his face.......

Heart = Stamina?

That's a new one.

I'm not debating his heart.... I just think if that's the evidence you're using then this is an all time low on this board.

[majestiC]

Heart = Stamina?

That's a new one.

I'm not debating his heart.... I just think if that's the evidence you're using then this is an all time low on this board.

Hardly, he could easily run in the 12th round when hes winning on points, but gives the fans what they want by going toe to toe..... just because hes never been in trouble doesn't mean he has no heart....

[Xplosivo]

We're dealing with two of the most immature posters on this board.

says the guy who thinks calzaghe is better than tyson and trinidad and uses trinidad losing at 2 weights above his natural weight class as an excuse...whoever reads this thread will find your posts interesting from now on

either your clearly biased or just seeking for some attention...im sure you will find 3 or 4 people on this entire site who will agree with you that calzaghe achieved more than trinidad or tyson

[majestiC]

says the guy who thinks calzaghe is better than tyson and trinidad and uses trinidad losing at 2 weights above his natural weight class as an excuse...whoever reads this thread will find your posts interesting from now on

either your clearly biased or just seeking for some attention...im sure you will find 3 or 4 people on this entire site who will agree with you that calzaghe achieved more than trinidad or tyson

Oh please Trinidad is as tall as Calzaghe with almost the same reach, its a miracle that Trinidad was as low as light-welterweight at one point, he moved up two weight classes from welter he hardly went up just to fight Hopkins, he looked great vs Vargas and Joppy.

[pesticid]

Oh please Trinidad is as tall as Calzaghe with almost the same reach, its a miracle that Trinidad was as low as light-welterweight at one point, he moved up two weight classes from welter he hardly went up just to fight Hopkins, he looked great vs Vargas and Joppy.

Majestic you're waisting your time. Just point to his poll, it's all subjective and it's equally divided.