Is Calzaghe a Top 25 Fighter in the last 30 Years?

[daggum]

do bears **** in the woods??

of couse he is

if he is sven ottke and zsolt erdei are as well.

[bsrizpac]

In a word: no

I'm trying to list some guys I know for a fact he isn't better than and I think before I type this out he's around 20 or so. These are in no particular order by the way

1) Mayweather
2) Roy Jones
3) Lennox Lewis
4) Ray Leonard
5) Roberto Duran
6) Marvin Hagler
7) Tommy Hearns
8) Larry Holmes
9) Mike Tyson
10) De La Hoya
11) Trinidad
12) Hopkins
13) Bowe
14) Toney
15) Morales
16) Barrera
17) Pacquiao
18) Whitaker
19) Chavez
20) Shane Mosley

Those guys have all had better careers with more impressive wins, a lot of them in more than one division.

Correct. Calzaghe is a ****ing joke. LMAO@loser Brits who pick him in this poll.

[Clegg]

Correct. Calzaghe is a ****ing joke. LMAO@loser Brits who pick him in this poll.

1. A thread about Calzaghe is created
2. Bsriz*** shows up and says something factually inaccurate about Calzaghe
3. Someone points out that bsriz***'s claim is factually inaccurate
4. Bsriz*** leaves the thread, I begin to wonder if perhaps he's decided to actually watch some boxing before commenting in future.
5. A new thread about Calzaghe is created, bsriz*** notices it and the cycle begin again ad infinitum

[Motofan]

1. A thread about Calzaghe is created
2. Bsriz*** shows up and says something factually inaccurate about Calzaghe
3. Someone points out that bsriz***'s claim is factually inaccurate
4. Bsriz*** leaves the thread, I begin to wonder if perhaps he's decided to actually watch some boxing before commenting in future.
5. A new thread about Calzaghe is created, bsriz*** notices it and the cycle begin again ad infinitum

You two should just **** and get it over with.

[Clegg]

You two should just **** and get it over with.

That's your opinion I guess. Or is it? I mean you have a habit of copying and pasting things that you apparently don't actually believe so...

[Motofan]

That's your opinion I guess. Or is it? I mean you have a habit of copying and pasting things that you apparently don't actually believe so...

It was a joke (no cut and paste.) I just dont see why people have to make ****ish comments to each other in every thread. I figured ****ing would break the tension.

[Clegg]

It was a joke (no cut and paste.) I just dont see why people have to make ****ish comments to each other in every thread. I figured ****ing would break the tension.

It's not like I threatened to kill his mother or something...but I get what you mean, a few people on here take things too seriously and probably end up bursting a blood vessel everytime they post.

[Mushashi]

Wins over an old Eubank, undefeated Lacy & Kessler and Hopkins for the Linear Light-heavyweight title is good.

But good enough to put him in a list of Top 25 fighters of last 30 years?

Not quite.

It's a shame Calzaghe is pursuing these big fights at the age of 36, when he should've been making these moves at 26.

[Xplosivo]

[SkillspayBills]

He's better than Marquez,Toney, Mosley, Wright, Tsyzu, Cotto, Hopkins, Trinidad, Oscar, Lewis and many others there so yes.

The question should be, is he a top 10 in the last 30 years?

I don't know about that one...

He's not.............at all. Top 25 yes he is indeed.