If Floyd moved up to super-middleweight

[Burner]

If Floyd beats both Cotto and Margarito there will be no question in my mind. No need imo for Floyd to Travel to SMW. If he does these 2 things there is nothing but positive I can say about Floyd's legacy.

Cotto and Marg are fighting each other.........

Floyd will most likely beat up Oscar...then the Mosley-Judah winner........Hatton(if he hasnt lost)......then Cotto(if he hasnt lost)...then call it a career.

[Vladimir303]

random noob:Another Floyd Mayweather thread from vladimir303?

noob2: surely not?

random noob: yes but this time he's mentioned an obscure fighter alongside him?

noob2: who? Miguel Cotto?

random noob: Nope, Joe Calzaghe.

noob2: Ah I see it's the only way he comment on the Calzaghe BHop fight, because vlad only knows one fighter (Floyd) he has to contextualize it in terms of Floyd Mayweather Jr in order to write about it.

random noob: Flashy.

That was not funny. I think you got me confused with Horus.

I've made plenty of non-Floyd related threads.

It think Gomez is a secret fan of mine.

[MikeBrew328]

I think Floyd could do it. He would out-box the **** out of Joe Calzaghe. And against the ropes Floyd would shoulder roll all of those slaps.

[Bobby Shaw]

Everyone knows Floyd would win every round against Joe.He will pick his shots thru the middle and block all Calzaghe has to offer.

[TommyGunn.]

This threads nonsense, Floyd couldn't fight at 168 he'd get owned by anyone in the top 5. Thats like saying Calzahe could go to heavyweight.

This is the reason we have weight classes people.

[BetterCallSaul]

Calzaghe would absolutely murder mayweather. First of all Hopkins made Calzaghe look like **** but he still landed 300 punches. If Calzaghe landed just 100 on Mayweather, he would no longer be "pretty". Calzaghe would overwhelm Mayweather, with not just pressure, but effective pressure.

Mayweather is obviously a great fighter but his record is overhyped so much. Say what you want about Calzaghe, but he has never ducked a challenge, unlike Floyd.

[Vladimir303]

This threads nonsense, Floyd couldn't fight at 168 he'd get owned by anyone in the top 5. Thats like saying Calzahe could go to heavyweight.

This is the reason we have weight classes people.

No this is the reason why we have All-Time great fighters who transcend weight (Pernell, Toney, Jones, Leonard) and move up to become multi-division champions and we have just barely great fighters like Joe Calzaghe - who hang around for a decade in the same weight class defending a WBO title.

Roy Jones started at middleweight, like Joe has been at supper-middleweight and went on to win a heavyweight title. What's stopping Joe?????

Exactly

[Vladimir303]

Calzaghe would absolutely murder mayweather. First of all Hopkins made Calzaghe look like **** but he still landed 300 punches. If Calzaghe landed just 100 on Mayweather, he would no longer be "pretty". Calzaghe would overwhelm Mayweather, with not just pressure, but effective pressure.

Mayweather is obviously a great fighter but his record is overhyped so much. Say what you want about Calzaghe, but he has never ducked a challenge, unlike Floyd.

1. Joe wouldn't murder anybody and specially not Floyd. Those 200 mythical punches Joe landed on Hopkins were pitty patts.......I didn't even notice them.


2. Sure he has........he only waited a decade too long to take the challange of coming over to America and fighting the best around his weight class whether middleweight or light-heavy.

[TommyGunn.]

No this is the reason why we have All-Time great fighters who transcend weight (Pernell, Toney, Jones, Leonard) and move up to become multi-division champions and we have just barely great fighters like Joe Calzaghe - who hang around for a decade in the same weight class defending a WBO title.

Roy Jones started at middleweight, like Joe has been at supper-middleweight and went on to win a heavyweight title. What's stopping Joe?????

Exactly

Floyds already moved up 5 weights since he started though, 7 would be way to much. That is very evident looking at the mass of his body.

Calzaghe is not a HW, he could not go to HW it is insane to sujest he could.

[TommyGunn.]

1. Joe wouldn't murder anybody and specially not Floyd. Those 200 mythical punches Joe landed on Hopkins were pitty patts.......I didn't even notice them.


2. Sure he has........he only waited a decade too long to take the challange of coming over to America and fighting the best around his weight class whether middleweight or light-heavy.

What has fighting in america got to do with being great? Its a world wide sport not an american sport.