Who is the True #1 P4P fighter in Boxing?

[eazy_mas]

its harder to get your body ready to fight bigger guys. and when he moved up he faught the top guys

unfiying belts is mostly a promotional problem but going up in weight is more of a physical problem.

You got guys who outweight you by who weighclass some guy at WW walk around LHW some of them.

[Ray Ray]

This is the biggest line of crap I have seen on this site in a long time. I will give him credit. Calzaghe looked good against Kessler Saturday night. However, he has only fought and beat two world class opponents in his entire 44-fight career, and the P4P title is not based on your performance in one fight. So in his 21 title defenses, 19 of his opponents have been stiffs who posed no serious threat to him. After Calzaghe beats five Ring Magazine champions in five weight classes or, more modestly, beats five world class opponents, then you can mention his name as a possible P4P contender. For now, call him what he is, a good fighter who has spent most of his career fighting limited competition.

GOOD POST and I agree with you 100%.

[WLAD OWNS]

This is the biggest line of crap I have seen on this site in a long time. I will give him credit. Calzaghe looked good against Kessler Saturday night. However, he has only fought and beat two world class opponents in his entire 44-fight career, and the P4P title is not based on your performance in one fight. So in his 21 title defenses, 19 of his opponents have been stiffs who posed no serious threat to him. After Calzaghe beats five Ring Magazine champions in five weight classes or, more modestly, beats five world class opponents, then you can mention his name as a possible P4P contender. For now, call him what he is, a good fighter who has spent most of his career fighting limited competition.

Your opinion dosen't matter, please take your 1 star rating elsewhere, DOUCHEBAG.

[eazy_mas]

Your opinion dosen't matter, please take your 1 star rating elsewhere, DOUCHEBAG.

well you making seemd you dont like Floyd personally but got his skills and talent he is p4p champion by the Ring Magazine and many other boxing expert.

you know going from 130 to 154 getting title is not an easy take and he is still undeafted for some reason.

Imagine it like this Calzaghe going from SMW going to HW will he stand a chance some of the guy at CW and HW e****ally? There is alot of weight around them and Calzaghe could be KO just by hitting them because he got hands problem for long time ago.

[shawn_]

because Nunn is a masterful pure boxer and Jirov has a good work rate southpaw similar to Calzaghe but not weight the same because Calzaghe put his punchs in weirder angle unlike Jirov

and i know little of boxing is true but i know enough to judge how the fight is going to go on.

You just made yourself look ****** TWICE in one sentence. TWICE.
#1. You just compared Jirov to Calzaghe.
#2. You just said Joe is not a masterful boxer.

This forces me to ask you a few questions.
#1. Have you EVER seen Jirov fight?
#2. Have you EVER seen Calzaghe fight?

There is a HUGE difference between a true southpaw and a man that just happens to have his left foot 2 inches behind his right foot while he is walking forward.

[Ray Ray]

Your opinion dosen't matter, please take your 1 star rating elsewhere, DOUCHEBAG.

Hey man that's bull****, he does make a valid and interesting point. First and far most he put on a BRILLIANT DISPLAY against Kessler this past Saturday. IMO the only other names that sticks out on his resume` is Eubanks & Lacy. Who else has he fight to earn the PFP top spot. I willing to hear your thoughts!!!

[miron_lang]

----- Pbf -----

[eazy_mas]

You just made yourself look ****** TWICE in one sentence. TWICE.
#1. You just compared Jirov to Calzaghe.
#2. You just said Joe is not a masterful boxer.

This forces me to ask you a few questions.
#1. Have you EVER seen Jirov fight?
#2. Have you EVER seen Calzaghe fight?

There is a HUGE difference between a true southpaw and a man that just happens to have his left foot 2 inches behind his right foot while he is walking forward.

well as a work rate they are similar and not the same.

in boxing terms you are comparing Micheal Nunn to Joe Calzaghe, Nunn is a master of boxing and he could school even Roy Jones ass at his prime. You did compare Calzaghe to Nunn boxing. Micheal Nunn boxing skills > Calzaghe boxing skills. But Calzaghe most of the time throws alot of furries and a better pressure fighter than Nunn.

I didnt compare Jirov with Calzaghe but I saying that they have high workrate southpaw and told the difference Calzaghe have which make you a and ****** for not reading through whole of the post. do I have to put in bold so you could read it clear too,

Calzaghe and Jirov are high work rate southpaws which is similar in that term but Calzaghe puts his punchs in an odd angle unlike Jirov.

[WLAD OWNS]

Hey man that's bull****, he does make a valid and interesting point. First and far most he put on a BRILLIANT DISPLAY against Kessler this past Saturday. IMO the only other names that sticks out on his resume` is Eubanks & Lacy. Who else has he fight to earn the PFP top spot. I willing to hear your thoughts!!!

Floyd may be the #1 p4p BOXER, but Calzaghe is the #1 p4p FIGHTER. Calzaghe and Floyd are both talented, but what sets Calzaghe apart from Floyd is his HEART,BALLS and his willingness to take RISKS in the ring. Calzaghe is Undefeated and he has won all of his fights decisively. Floyd shouldn't even be undefeated, Castillo beat him and you could argue that the DLH fight was a draw.

[eazy_mas]

Floyd may be the #1 p4p BOXER, but Calzaghe is the #1 p4p FIGHTER. Calzaghe and Floyd are both talented, but what sets Calzaghe apart from Floyd is his HEART,BALLS and his willingness to take RISKS in the ring. Calzaghe is Undefeated and he has won all of his fights decisively. Floyd shouldn't even be undefeated, Castillo beat him and you could argue that the DLH fight was a draw.

well you could also argue that Robin Ried fight was Calzaghe L.

there is so many arguments you could make but going up on weight is not an easy task you lose alot of you power and speed carrying all this weight around and fight.