Who is the True #1 P4P fighter in Boxing?

[Wiley Hyena]

Would fighting a guy who outweighs you by 20 pounds be considered a risk? I would say so. Would standing toe to toe with that guy be a risk? I'd say thats more along the lines of ******ity.
Don't get me wrong, I think Calzaghe is a great fighter, but I don't think he's good enough to move up 24 pounds (or 4 divisions, whichever you prefer) from his natural weight to fight other good fighters.

No way that **** happens in the classic weight divisions and one belt. Floyd probably would have had to stay at 135. No way would he have won the WW belt with the crop of fighters we had 2003-2005. So, if you're talking about Oscar hydrating to his plump middleweight self, I would say...big deal. Oscar is a natural WW if anything. I don't give a damn about the lovehandles.

[Jim Jeffries]

Thats the point. Mayweather started at 130 and moved to 154. Do the math and you (hopefully) will come up with 24.

Mayweather's body has matured as he got older. Could he make 130 these days? Not a chance. And one fight against a semi-retired promoter with one fight in three years does not a 154 star make.

[ThaHorseman]

No way that **** happens in the classic weight divisions and one belt. Floyd probably would have had to stay at 135. No way would he have won the WW belt with the crop of fighters we had 2003-2005. So, if you're talking about Oscar hydrating to his plump middleweight self, I would say...big deal. Oscar is a natural WW if anything. I don't give a damn about the lovehandles.

Sorry pal, but these are the times we live in. You can make assumptions and guesses about all kinds of "what ifs", but you're better off sticking with the facts. You can discredit Oscar all you want, but he's a tough fight for anyone out there. Calzaghe has been a great fighter in one division, Mayweather has been great in more than one. Its nothing against Calz, but he's not #1 P4P.

[ElGranLuchador]

u can make a point of pac being pound for pound best fighter hes moved up from flyweight and fought great opposition its not his fault the spotlights are on him now that he is reached his top weight floyd on the other hand has been highlighted from the beggining of his career thats why hes gotten the title shots unlike pac

[Wiley Hyena]

Sorry pal, but these are the times we live in. You can make assumptions and guesses about all kinds of "what ifs", but you're better off sticking with the facts. You can discredit Oscar all you want, but he's a tough fight for anyone out there. Calzaghe has been a great fighter in one division, Mayweather has been great in more than one. Its nothing against Calz, but he's not #1 P4P.

No, Pacquiao is.........Cal is second.

[C'MONMANG']

We who leave personal preference aside when discussing these things are becoming a ****ing dying breed. As of late, simply pointing out facts will get you flamed non stop by people who don't have an argument........other than something that stems from a personal dislike or aesthetic perception difference.

Jesus Christ people, Boxing isn't aesthetics.

Fighter A is either better than fighter B.

The guy who fighter A fought is either better than fighter B.

Not: "Oh he's my favorite, so he's the best" or "I would never rate him because I don't like him". That's called a ****ing bias, and it's just immature and ******ed.

Floyd is the man in boxing, end of story.

Why wont he fight a top welter then?

[Jim Jeffries]

Why wont he fight a top welter then?

Exactly, people are always clamoring about 5 division belts, hell Hearns did that, and Oscar won 6, Floyd needs to unify at least one division to differentiate himself, or at least fight Mosley, Cotto or Williams.

[Jim Jeffries]

We shouldnt have to do this once a week.
Floyd is #1, people.
Deal with it.

Well over a third of the people in the poll so far disagree with you.

[Run]

Why wont he fight a top welter then?

Because there aren't any that are on his level.

Also You can't use the "Why doesn't he fight a top welter" because he's slated and prepared to fight Hatton next month.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[Run]

Well over a third of the people in the poll so far disagree with you.

LMFAO.

Anyone could make for example a poll that asks:

Who produces the best fighters? Britain or the United States? And the majority of the votes would come from U.K. fight fans voting for their guys.

bias knows no boundaries.

If you don't think Floyd is the best fighter, you don't know boxing.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!