Who is the True #1 P4P fighter in Boxing?

[me2007]

do you know why he was jumping weight divisions? because he didn`t want to hang around and fight the best. Mayweather is a woman. He is not a man. Just look at him, appearing on these gay dancing shows. He sums up everything bad about todays 'fighters'. It will be a good day when this gay retires..

[slicksouthpaw16]

Mayweather is number 1 and Calzaghe should be number 2. They are both the most dominant champions in the sport and they both are the main champions in their division. Calzaghe should be over Pacman because he has been around longer and accomplished more. 21 titles defenses with no losses. Im not a Pac hater at all but his defeat is coming soon anyway. he will lose next year to Marquez in the rematch or Joan Guzman.

[Technical_Skill]

do you know why he was jumping weight divisions? because he didn`t want to hang around and fight the best. Mayweather is a woman. He is not a man. Just look at him, appearing on these gay dancing shows. He sums up everything bad about todays 'fighters'. It will be a good day when this gay retires..

Yeah Cos He didnt fight the best at 130? lmao who was the best at 130 when floyd was around please tell me the names.

So when he moved up to 135 and fought castillo for the Title in his 1st fight, who else was he meant to face ?

[markosg]

The simple fact of the matter is that Floyd has owned several division and is about to take on the guy that owns the one division that he didn't truely conquer. I am from Wales however i am not naive enough to think that Calzaghe is the best in the world p4p.

It is a simple case of longevity in one divsion vs success in multiple. My idea of p4p is that if all fighter were shrunk to the same size then who would be the best based on their style. That would be floyd.

However regarding the recently relesed ring ratings - i think they are a pile of ****! JMM and Hopkins lose a fight each and disaippear from te top 5 and then on the basis of 1 win against faded (barrera) and out of shape (tarver) fighters they suddenly get elevated to top 5 status against. Hmmm who owns that magazine????

[squealpiggy]

I have Floyd as my number one. With all respect to Hatton who is my favourite fighter and difinitely top ten p4p, I think Floyd would beat him nine fights out of ten. But I think that the one out of ten is coming up, so it doesn't matter.

But Floyd vs Calzaghe if size were not an issue, well I don't know who would win. They are both very clever boxers, both have great defense, Floyd is the better technician, Calzaghe is the better ring general... Floyd would win 6 times out of ten, that's how close it is to me.

[Technical_Skill]

But Floyd vs Calzaghe if size were not an issue, well I don't know who would win.

There isn't a doubt in my mind who would win that fight.

[Burning Desire]

Yeah Cos He didnt fight the best at 130? lmao? who was the best at 130 when floyd was around please tell me the names.

So when he moved up to 135 and fought castillo for the Title in his 1st fight, who else was he meant to face ?

Genaro Hernandez
Angel Manfredy
Diego Corrales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez

All very good names at 130 the only other fighter Mayweather could have faced at 130 was.

Acelino Freitas
Joel Casamayor

Would have loved to have seen Casamayor vs Mayweather.

[Technical_Skill]

Genaro Hernandez
Angel Manfredy
Diego Corrales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez

All very good names at 130 the only other fighter Mayweather could have faced at 130 was.

Acelino Freitas
Joel Casamayor

Would have loved to have seen Casamayor vs Mayweather.

I love casamayor as a fighter, personally, i think he is better than calzaghe skills wise too, and yet no one talks about him,

Bu i also heard that casamayor didnt wanna mess with floyd, personally, i have floyd winning that fight.

But casamayor is a such a skilled fighter.

[squealpiggy]

There isn't a doubt in my mind who would win that fight.

Who would win?

[Technical_Skill]

Who would win?

The fighter who is more skilled, fought better fighters throughout his career, and dominated much bigger fighters than himself.