Who's A More Complete Fighter Pernell or Floyd?

[One Hit KO]

Whitaker Trades Punches And Still Dont Get Hit While Gayweather Runs Around Not To Get Hit. Bwahahahhaa. Gayweather Is Hella Boring.

[One Hit KO]

id say floyd might have more power then pernell..everything else would be even..i was just watching mcgirt vs whitaker last night and floyd vs pernell would be one of the best match ups of all time

why would it be a best match up when u have a runner on the ring.

[Vladimir303]

Floyd is obviously better. Floyd's defense is better for longevity. Pernell's defense was great too but it was totally different and it worked based on pure reflexes and athleticism. Once he got older his defense wasn't as effective anymore . Smoking Crack didn't help either. Floyd's defense would work even when he is past his prime just like Hopkins's and Winky's defense.........It's more based on fundementals then natural ability.

Offense......again floyd is a lil better overall. More punching power then pernell even as he keept moving up in weight. Pernell was always on a Pauli Malinaggi, Cory spinks level of punching power.

And let's not forget the overall phisique....Floyd is 5'8 with 72" reach and Pernell is only 5'6 with a 27" reach. A great big boxer always beats a great little boxer. Pernell with his reach and height would have to have a totally different style to bother floyd.

[Wiley Hyena]

Floyd is obviously better. Floyd's defense is better for longevity. Pernell's defense was great too but it was totally different and it worked based on pure reflexes and athleticism. Once he got older his defense wasn't as effective anymore . Smoking Crack didn't help either. Floyd's defense would work even when he is past his prime just like Hopkins's and Winky's defense.........It's more based on fundementals then natural ability.

Offense......again floyd is a lil better overall. More punching power then pernell even as he keept moving up in weight. Pernell was always on a Pauli Malinaggi, Cory spinks level of punching power.

And let's not forget the overall phisique....Floyd is 5'8 with 72" reach and Pernell is only 5'6 with a 27" reach. A great big boxer always beats a great little boxer. Pernell with his reach and height would have to have a totally different style to bother floyd.

Floyd is obviously better? I don't see it. But, a fight between Whitaker and Floyd would be a good one, no doubt. Probably not the most exciting, but a great test of skill.

[Amir K Shareef]

Floyd is obviously better? I don't see it. But, a fight between Whitaker and Floyd would be a good one, no doubt. Probably not the most exciting, but a great test of skill.

yeah it would be the biggest fight EVER easily... but floyd is better hands down... judah is alot like whitaker and floyd beat him.. judah has power and speed just like pernell but he gets tired and hass no defense.. floyd would beat whitaker

[Wiley Hyena]

yeah it would be the biggest fight EVER easily... but floyd is better hands down... judah is alot like whitaker and floyd beat him.. judah has power and speed just like pernell but he gets tired and hass no defense.. floyd would beat whitaker

This post is an official nuthug. Whitaker had defense.

[Vladimir303]

Floyd is obviously better? I don't see it. But, a fight between Whitaker and Floyd would be a good one, no doubt. Probably not the most exciting, but a great test of skill.

Why don't you read the entire post before responding. I think I explained myself very well. Anyway I think people are seriously overrating Pernell Whitaker on here. I mean where was this love when he used to fight? Now people parrot everything that other people say watching youtube highlights of Pernell slipping punches and they think they know it all.

[Amir K Shareef]

This post is an official nuthug. Whitaker had defense.

wtf i never said whitaker didnt have defense damn you been sucking to much ****

[Amir K Shareef]

Why don't you read the entire post before responding. I think I explained myself very well. Anyway I think people are seriously overrating Pernell Whitaker on here. I mean where was this love when he used to fight? Now people parrot everything that other people say watching youtube highlights of Pernell slipping punches and they think they know it all.

hell yeah he dont ever read the whole post.. and pernell is over rated... hes been knocked down too many times to say he got better defense then mayweather

[Wiley Hyena]

wtf i never said whitaker didnt have defense damn you been sucking to much ****

You said Pernell was like Judah and Judah had no defense. Is that not what you said?