Where do you have Jermain Taylor in the P4P List?

[K-DOGG]

My point is that Floyd has faced 11 World Champions in his career, soon to be 12. His level of opposition is high, he has fought very good fighers over his career and has been dominant for the most part.
Dont forget that be beat Hernandez, Chaves, Castillo and Corrales.

I haven't forgot what he did 17 Lbs ago; but you can't ride that wave forever. In boxing, you have to keep proving yourself. Floyd did good in beating Judah and Baldomir; but if he really wants to write his name in the history books, he needs to stamp his ownership on the welterweight division while he's here...'cause I don't see him moving up too much.

...and don't blow the De La Hoya fight out of proportion. Oscar's on the slide too. That Mayorga win means next to nill. Tito looked great against Mayorgao as well. Oscar's still a top p4p fighter; but he's not going to beat Floyd, not at this stage in his career....at leats I don't think he will.

[pink panther]

I have him on pending... as far as I'm concerned he lost 2 out of his last 3 fights, so I can't have him anywhere near a top ten, maybe not even 20. Green as they come.

mmmm - so green

[Parody]

Margarito hasn't lost a fight at welterweight in the last four years while defending his WBO belt. What more do you want, an act of Congress?

Margarito lost to Santos 2 years back, and then has faced nobody of note, did you ever wonder why he did'nt lose? maybe its because of the toughest competition he is facing

i dont want to hear the most feared welterweight and no one is willing to face him etc, 10 fighters called him out but he did'nt take on them, and never replied, all of these fighters had good resumes compared to margarito and were a bigger name.

[Guest]

2 wins over P4P #1 and draw with the P4P #2, and Taylor is supposed to be Green while had these victories, just wait till he is a experienced improved fighter he will dominate the middleweight/ supermiddleweight division.

Yeah, but that's (almost) like me putting Sam Peter in the P4P rankings cos he's got a "win" over James Toney.

[Parody]

Yeah, but that's (almost) like me putting Sam Peter in the P4P rankings cos he's got a "win" over James Toney.

James Toney is'nt in anyones P4P list though whereas Hopkins was #1 in everyones list, and winky was #2 in everyones list before they fought taylor.

[wmute]

how is margarito on a p4p list, when he faced only one fighter bigger than him and lost to him. this implies a pound of margarito is not a great pound of fighter (that's what pound for pound should be about, no? what if a pound of floyd fought a pound of winky?)

[Easy-E]

I haven't forgot what he did 17 Lbs ago; but you can't ride that wave forever. In boxing, you have to keep proving yourself. Floyd did good in beating Judah and Baldomir; but if he really wants to write his name in the history books, he needs to stamp his ownership on the welterweight division while he's here...'cause I don't see him moving up too much.

...and don't blow the De La Hoya fight out of proportion. Oscar's on the slide too. That Mayorga win means next to nill. Tito looked great against Mayorgao as well. Oscar's still a top p4p fighter; but he's not going to beat Floyd, not at this stage in his career....at leats I don't think he will.

DLH is in good shape and is more dangerous than any other fighter Floyd could have chosen.

[Easy-E]

Yeah, but that's (almost) like me putting Sam Peter in the P4P rankings cos he's got a "win" over James Toney.

The whole point is that he beat him twice.
I had him number 8 or so after the first bhop victory, but he proved that it wasnt a fluke, that he really was at Hopkin's level. The Wright draw also improved his standing imo.

[Shanus]

The whole point is that he beat him twice.
I had him number 8 or so after the first bhop victory, but he proved that it wasnt a fluke, that he really was at Hopkin's level. The Wright draw also improved his standing imo.

I thought it lowered it slightly, but seeing as it was officially a draw I kept him at #4 and Wright at #2.

[GunStar]

PBF
Taylor
Pac
Winkster
Hopkins
Barerra