Where do you have Jermain Taylor in the P4P List?

[Easy-E]

My List:

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Joe Calzaghe
6. Jermain Taylor
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Marco Antonio Barrera
9. Antonio Margarito
10. Oscar De La Hoya

Having Tony on your p4p list is absolute lunacy.
Having Hopkins above Taylor makes NO sense.

[Yogi]

Having Tony on your p4p list is absolute lunacy.
Having Hopkins above Taylor makes NO sense.

I don't see Toney on his list, and having Hopkins above Taylor does make sense if you scored one or even both of their fights for Bernard (both close, and entirely possible to have that opinion), as well as considering their most recent performance where Hopkins was the more impressive of the two.

[K-DOGG]

Having Tony on your p4p list is absolute lunacy.
Having Hopkins above Taylor makes NO sense.

Hopkins beat Tarver...that's up two weigh divisions, and Tarver was a favorite in that fight; but B-Hop embarrassed him......Taylor has yet to turn in a dominant performance at middleweight on a championship level. In my book, he's 1-1-1 in his last three fights. He's looked greener than grass, Hopkins didn't look great in that series either; but he looked as dominant as ever against the Light Heavyweigth Champ. So, it makes as much sense as having Winky ranked above Taylor.

Tony's at 9...big deal.

[Parody]

Hopkins beat Tarver...that's up two weigh divisions, and Tarver was a favorite in that fight; but B-Hop embarrassed him......Taylor has yet to turn in a dominant performance at middleweight on a championship level. In my book, he's 1-1-1 in his last three fights. He's looked greener than grass, Hopkins didn't look great in that series either; but he looked as dominant as ever against the Light Heavyweigth Champ. So, it makes as much sense as having Winky ranked above Taylor.

Tony's at 9...big deal.

Still having margarito in any P4P list is insane, Not even P4P Top 20 at the moment

[DiegoFuego]

My List:

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Joe Calzaghe
6. Jermain Taylor
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Marco Antonio Barrera
9. Antonio Margarito
10. Oscar De La Hoya

[QUOTE=K-DOGG;1952390]

wow, I just lost what little respect I had for you

Taylor is a solid #4
1) Mayweather
2) Wright
3) Pacquiao
4) Taylor
5) Hatton (has the better win over Calzaghe)
6) Calzaghe
7) Barrera

the bottom is pretty open, but I'm pretty damn sure Margarito and De La Hoya aren't on it, lol. believe it or not, Freitas should be on there because he only has one loss despite facing stiff opposition. Castillo might deserve to be on it. I guess you could make a case for Cotto at 8 or 9. Toney deserves to be on it simply because he hasn't lost in forever (unless you count the Peter fight). and then of course if Hopkins is still fighting he's behind Taylor, which pushes everyone else back a bit.

[K-DOGG]

Still having margarito in any P4P list is insane, Not even P4P Top 20 at the moment

We'll see.

[K-DOGG]

[QUOTE=DiegoFuego;1952462]

wow, I just lost what little respect I had for you

Taylor is a solid #4
1) Mayweather
2) Wright
3) Pacquiao
4) Taylor
5) Hatton (has the better win over Calzaghe)
6) Calzaghe
7) Barrera

the bottom is pretty open, but I'm pretty damn sure Margarito and De La Hoya aren't on it, lol. believe it or not, Freitas should be on there because he only has one loss despite facing stiff opposition. Castillo might deserve to be on it. I guess you could make a case for Cotto at 8 or 9. Toney deserves to be on it simply because he hasn't lost in forever (unless you count the Peter fight). and then of course if Hopkins is still fighting he's behind Taylor, which pushes everyone else back a bit.

Stop the world, I want to get off. I lived for your respect and now it's gone....woe is me.

[Yogi]

Ah...Tony. Not Toney.

[Easy-E]

Hopkins beat Tarver...that's up two weigh divisions, and Tarver was a favorite in that fight; but B-Hop embarrassed him......Taylor has yet to turn in a dominant performance at middleweight on a championship level. In my book, he's 1-1-1 in his last three fights. He's looked greener than grass, Hopkins didn't look great in that series either; but he looked as dominant as ever against the Light Heavyweigth Champ. So, it makes as much sense as having Winky ranked above Taylor.

Tony's at 9...big deal.

Bottom line is Taylor just beat Hopkins twice in a row and drew against the number 2 p4p fighter in the world.
Hopkins has lost 2 of his last 3 fights and then beat Tarver, who was number 9 or 10 depending on who you talk to.
Tony has beaten absolutly no one that you could even consider being p4p worthy.

[Easy-E]

but isnt the list supposed to be on what youve achieved and not wat potentionally u can achieve

Its about skills, competition and how you defeated that competition.