Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Greb vs the great heavyweights

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Greb vs the great heavyweights

    Found this on Facebook in a boxing group I read. Found it absolutely fascinating.

    https://m.facebook.com/story.php?sto...ibextid=Nif5oz

    “Cassius Clay wouldn’t know where he was once Greb began to swarm and climb all over him. He would bewilder and confuse Clay.”—Ray Arcel, 1966 .
    “I don’t put nobody over Greb. He could have licked Dempsey, Tunney and Louis, all in the same week.”—Whitey Bimstein
    .
    “All Abe Simon had to do to make Joe (Louis) fumble like a novice was to feint him fast, and you can imagine what Billy Conn will do to a fellow who fumbles like that. And he had Joe very tired by the ninth round. If Joe tired under a pace like that imagine what a fast-moving Conn will do to him. He'll gore the champ to death. I shudder to think what Harry Greb would have done to Louis last night.

    I was in Dempsey’s training camp when Jack Kearns ran in Greb as a sparring partner. It was murder. Greb was too fast and hit from too many angles. We had to chase him out. It’s going to take speed to beat Louis, and Greb had speed. He was on top of you before you knew what had happened, with both hands working….I think he would have given Louis a bad headache. You can’t afford to let Louis get set. It was always hard to get set against Greb.” —Tommy Walsh
    .
    “In my opinion, Louis would have had as much trouble handling Harry Greb as anyone else.”—Grantland Rice
    .
    Over the decades, several respected boxing persons who saw them fight in person have given the opinion that Greb could have beaten Jack Dempsey and Joe Louis. Now even the great Ali can be added to that list.

    Many people who never saw Harry in action chuckle at the notion that he could beat these all-time greats of the heavyweight division. And perhaps justifiably so. But keep this in mind:

    Nobody ever talked about Stanley Ketchel, Tiger Flowers, Mickey Walker, Sugar Ray Robinson, Carlos Monzon, Marvin Hagler or any other of the middleweight greats as having a chance vs Dempsey, Louis or Ali (nobody even mentions them as having a prayer against Gene Tunney on the night Harry beat him either).
    .
    Only Harry Greb is ever mentioned as having a real chance. Not just to be competitive against these heavyweight greats, but to win. Whether we agree or not, it's still a notable trend.
    .
    Tony Galento, who actually fought Joe Louis and many other top heavies, stated that Harry would have beaten him "and everybody else....he was the greatest fighter I ever saw. No one else was close to him."

    Even Jack Blackburn, who fought Greb and trained Louis, admitted that Joe would have major problems dealing with Harry’s awkward, elusive attack.
    .
    Out of all the all-time middleweight champions, it is only Harry Greb who is considered a match for the greatest heavyweights in history. And not by fanciful historians in their dreamy flights of fancy, but by expert eyewitnesses who saw both Greb and these heavyweights firsthand.
    .
    As they say online these days, “let that sink in…”

  • #2
    699670_d7b7c185d47b4c65b8bd5faacc0863b5_mv2.jpg

    Does size count?
    them_apples them_apples likes this.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by Willie Pep 229 View Post
      Apparently not to Greb.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post
        "Cassius Clay wouldn't know where he was once Greb began to swarm and climb all over him. He would bewilder and confuse Clay." —Ray Arcel, 1966.
        Lol... doesn't get much more ridiculous than this!

        Comment


        • #5
          He was always described as having this overwhelming and brutal unpredictable style, be so curious to see how it would look.

          interestingly enough, there are just so many boxing writers and even guys that fought after him that sparred him that lost to greb or went on to say he was the best fighter ever.

          considering he lost his eyes and was likely punch drunk greb sounded like a throwback in even the throwback era. All the bare knuckle guys before the marquee of the queensbury, or at least a lot of them - fought hard and lived hard with no regard to self preservation. Many died in their 30s and 40s (although not all, but it was common)

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by them_apples View Post
            He was always described as having this overwhelming and brutal unpredictable style, be so curious to see how it would look.

            interestingly enough, there are just so many boxing writers and even guys that fought after him that sparred him that lost to greb or went on to say he was the best fighter ever.

            considering he lost his eyes and was likely punch drunk greb sounded like a throwback in even the throwback era. All the bare knuckle guys before the marquee of the queensbury, or at least a lot of them - fought hard and lived hard with no regard to self preservation. Many died in their 30s and 40s (although not all, but it was common)
            By the time they got to their rematch fight Tunney had him figured out. One newspaper described the final eight rounds with Greb refusing to move forward. The windmill style disappeared and Greb went totally defensive.

            Like any human being once Greb started getting beat up he started protecting himself.

            Nobody ever talks about that fight.

            P.S. Before I hear about it from you all, YES Boxrec claims it was a hotly disputed decision.

            But read to the end. It goes on to say Greb abandoned his windmill style because he feared being DQ. So says Boxrec.

            Others say it was because Tunney took him to school.

            P.S.S. The biggest complainer about the decision was Muldoon. I leave you to decide how much validity that holds.

            Slugfester Slugfester likes this.

            Comment


            • #7
              One must surely rewrite the parameters that determine greatness among heavyweights, if little Harry can even be afforded a modicum of a chance to beat any "great" heavyweight. He didn't have much punch, just a lot of them.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post
                Found this on Facebook in a boxing group I read. Found it absolutely fascinating.

                https://m.facebook.com/story.php?sto...ibextid=Nif5oz

                “Cassius Clay wouldn’t know where he was once Greb began to swarm and climb all over him. He would bewilder and confuse Clay.”—Ray Arcel, 1966 .
                “I don’t put nobody over Greb. He could have licked Dempsey, Tunney and Louis, all in the same week.”—Whitey Bimstein
                .
                “All Abe Simon had to do to make Joe (Louis) fumble like a novice was to feint him fast, and you can imagine what Billy Conn will do to a fellow who fumbles like that. And he had Joe very tired by the ninth round. If Joe tired under a pace like that imagine what a fast-moving Conn will do to him. He'll gore the champ to death. I shudder to think what Harry Greb would have done to Louis last night.

                I was in Dempsey’s training camp when Jack Kearns ran in Greb as a sparring partner. It was murder. Greb was too fast and hit from too many angles. We had to chase him out. It’s going to take speed to beat Louis, and Greb had speed. He was on top of you before you knew what had happened, with both hands working….I think he would have given Louis a bad headache. You can’t afford to let Louis get set. It was always hard to get set against Greb.” —Tommy Walsh
                .
                “In my opinion, Louis would have had as much trouble handling Harry Greb as anyone else.”—Grantland Rice
                .
                Over the decades, several respected boxing persons who saw them fight in person have given the opinion that Greb could have beaten Jack Dempsey and Joe Louis. Now even the great Ali can be added to that list.

                Many people who never saw Harry in action chuckle at the notion that he could beat these all-time greats of the heavyweight division. And perhaps justifiably so. But keep this in mind:

                Nobody ever talked about Stanley Ketchel, Tiger Flowers, Mickey Walker, Sugar Ray Robinson, Carlos Monzon, Marvin Hagler or any other of the middleweight greats as having a chance vs Dempsey, Louis or Ali (nobody even mentions them as having a prayer against Gene Tunney on the night Harry beat him either).
                .
                Only Harry Greb is ever mentioned as having a real chance. Not just to be competitive against these heavyweight greats, but to win. Whether we agree or not, it's still a notable trend.
                .
                Tony Galento, who actually fought Joe Louis and many other top heavies, stated that Harry would have beaten him "and everybody else....he was the greatest fighter I ever saw. No one else was close to him."

                Even Jack Blackburn, who fought Greb and trained Louis, admitted that Joe would have major problems dealing with Harry’s awkward, elusive attack.
                .
                Out of all the all-time middleweight champions, it is only Harry Greb who is considered a match for the greatest heavyweights in history. And not by fanciful historians in their dreamy flights of fancy, but by expert eyewitnesses who saw both Greb and these heavyweights firsthand.
                .
                As they say online these days, “let that sink in…”
                - - Bunch of ol'timers gumming their history. I rate Greb highly, but he ain't beating prime to prime any heavy great and would have trouble enough again modern LH greats.

                At best he's a middle good enough to beat top 5 middles as well as lose to them.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by QueensburyRules View Post

                  - - Bunch of ol'timers gumming their history. I rate Greb highly, but he ain't beating prime to prime any heavy great and would have trouble enough again modern LH greats.

                  At best he's a middle good enough to beat top 5 middles as well as lose to them.
                  So if you believe he'd have trouble against modern light heavyweights, you must think Tunney would as well. Is the correct?

                  And let's face it, Greb tore Dempsey up so bad in sparring the jack wanted nothing to do with him, instead fighting Harry's leftovers.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post

                    So if you believe he'd have trouble against modern light heavyweights, you must think Tunney would as well. Is the correct?

                    And let's face it, Greb tore Dempsey up so bad in sparring the jack wanted nothing to do with him, instead fighting Harry's leftovers.
                    Nobody tears anyone apart in sparing.

                    Fitzsimmons had Greb under contract and he two agendas . . .

                    To build up Greb because he was on the Miske under card

                    He was trying to make a Dempsey-Greb fight after the Miske fight.

                    Dempsey owed Rickard a fight, that became the Brennan fight.

                    Then Fitz tried to get Dempsey-Greb going but he couldn't meet Kearns demand of $300,000 up front. Kearns didn't like taking the risk of a percentage, especially after the Brennan fight lost Rickard money.

                    Rickard could meet 300K demand for Carpentier. **

                    And before I have to listen how Kearns picked the easier fighter, that is nonsense. That is 20-20 hindsight. No one knew how good Carpentier was in 1921.

                    You're placing too much emphasis on a 'fight camp' talk and concluding that the sparing session is the end-all of the story. Na!

                    Look at the big picture.

                    ** He offered Kearns a 100K and a percentage but Kearns would not bite. Had Kearns taken the percentage he would have cleared 470K.

                    Kearns ended up leaving 170K in Rickard's pocket instead of Dempsey's. The newspapers rode Kearns about the call and he didn't like it.

                    This is also one of the reasons why Kearns wouldn't consider the Pittsburg offer he got in 1922 to fight Greb. Again the promoter only had 100K and was offering a percentage. And again Kearns said no.

                    You say "duck" way too fast!
                    Willow The Wisp Willow The Wisp likes this.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP