Is Pacquiao top 10 AT? Top 20? Top 30?

[billeau2]

Like Calzaghe. ATG at super middle and Light Heavy.

Lol if you think so...

[DeeMoney]

I know it raises some dander when I write something like this, but it depends on what criteria you use. Is it how good he was at his peak on a relative his best weight class (my personal favorite)? Is it longevity? Is it a tally mark of accomplishments and diversity of accomplishments (which he is very high in)? Is it a weighted mix of these?

I think in some measurements, he is top 5, in others probably in that 15-20 range. But even at his lowest ranked criteria he is still legendary, atg, (insert adjective here).

[The Old LefHook]

Calzaghe is NOT an ATG at light heavy. He only is one at super middle because the division is so barren. Wouldn't fight. Sorry, we do not reward that with accolades.

[IronDanHamza]

1. Langford
2. Greb
3. Robinson
4. Armstrong
5. Charles
6. Pep
7. B. Leonard
8. Duran
9. Gans
10. Moore
11. Walker
12. R. Leonard
13. Ross
14. Mayweather
15. Conn
16. Canzoneri
17. Jones
18. Pacquiao
19. Monzon
20. Tunney

This was my last top 20 p4p list. But I'll be damned if many of the points being made here aren't compelling me to move Pacquiao up to the ninth spot and move everyone below down a notch. I personally can't justify putting him higher, but he surely ranks higher than I originally gave him credit for.

Nice list mate.

[Willie Pep 229]

Nice list mate.

Weak list, no Billy Miske.

[just the facts]

Top 20 but not top 10. My opinion…….

[Ropss]

Catchweight Master

[Nash out]

Nowhere near that high, I'm not sure where, but definitely below Jeff "the Hornet" Horn, and Ugas. I know the Mayweather fight was a big event, but well past prime Mayweather beating prime Pac 118-110, did him no favours either. Nash brings you the truth whether you like it or not. Nash out.

[QueensburyRules]

Nowhere near that high, I'm not sure where, but definitely below Jeff "the Hornet" Horn, and Ugas. I know the Mayweather fight was a big event, but well past prime Mayweather beating prime Pac 118-110, did him no favours either. Nash brings you the truth whether you like it or not. Nash out.

- - Nash out to lunch again with no credit card, is it? 2 scorecards 116-112 meaning a two round fight difference would've been majority draw.

And the Vegas commish needing to rejigger their official 3 card amalgamation card after the fact and then two weeks later issuing a backdated TUE for l'l floydy so they can give him an official sanctimonious sanctioned win.

In Ring's 100 year compilation of Ring Ratings, Manny made the top 10 in direct comparison to the historic record.

Jus da fax, ma'am...

[Nash out]

- - Nash out to lunch again with no credit card, is it? 2 scorecards 116-112 meaning a two round fight difference would've been majority draw.

And the Vegas commish needing to rejigger their official 3 card amalgamation card after the fact and then two weeks later issuing a backdated TUE for l'l floydy so they can give him an official sanctimonious sanctioned win.

In Ring's 100 year compilation of Ring Ratings, Manny made the top 10 in direct comparison to the historic record.

Jus da fax, ma'am...

Those scorecards were shocking. Pac won R4 and R6 clearly, and lost the rest clearly. Fact. Nash out.