RJJ is my favorite fighter of all time. He was fun to watch, and the way he moved, the angles he threw punches from, with the speed and power he did it with, he looked an otherworldly athlete. He was very special to watch because of these things. A true HOF’er and an ATG, probably the best P4P fighter in his prime. Legitimately unbeatable in his prime. Like who can realistically beat that guy, same size and all?
But Mayweather is better fundamentally. Truth be told, you are teaching your child to box, you do not tell them to copy what RJJ. While fun, the hands low, moving to avoid punches, and relying on handspeed to hit your target, isn’t the way you want to teach boxing. That’s one of the reasons why RJJ was so famous and so fun to watch: he did everything you shouldn’t do, and got away with it, and was really good at it.
You want to show your kid Mayweather fights if you want him to really get what is boxing and what are boxing fundamentals.
In a sense you're right... But still...it isn't like RJJ is fundamentally sloppy... it's BECAUSE he has a strong fundamental base (that was hammered into him as a child just like Floyd) that he was able to look so otherworldy when he utilized his natural athleticism WITH his boxing skills... There are a lot of extremely athletic NFL and NBA players that can't throw a punch to save their lives despite the fact their "fast twitchy," and explosive.
Also...Everyone on this thread is painting a picture that Floyd is some supreme fundamental skilled boxer that didn't RELY on HIS superior athleticism in fights do the things that more "traditional" boxers would never do. Floyd used to do a leaping left hook too, or putting his hands down and doing his signature pull right hand counter.... Floyd RELIED on his reflexes just like Roy... It's just that his OVERALL fight plan utilized more "traditional" boxing because he was forced to because he wasn't AS athletic as Roy... If Floyd was able to do what Roy could... He would of done it, period... Roy didn't need to do the shoulder roll...It's not like Roy couldn't do it if he wanted to...
Talking of skills.... Was Floyd able to switch to south paw as smoothly and effectively as Roy?
A lot of kids will never have the cat like reflexes of Floyd, so i wouldn't say Floyd's style of boxing is some supreme template for doing boxing the "right" "traditional" way... Maybe someone like Roberto Duran or oscar de la hoya... Someone very skilled but without the "flashy" style which is impossible to mimic unless you're super athletic yourself... or maybe the cuban style...
And I am sorry, but RJJ getting KO’ed by Tarver like that, would have been equal to Mayweather getting KO’ed by Mosley with the couple of good right hands in the 2nd round. And RJJ getting KO’ed by Glen Johnson like that would have been equivalent to Mayweather getting KO’ed by Maidana.
But that didn’t happen because as Mayweather aged, his boxing fundamentals stayed the same or better. He blocked instead of just moved. He setup big punches with jabs, instead of throwing 1 super fast power shot from a weird angle, hoping to KO his opponent. He clinched when he had to, instead of being a sitting duck, taking power shots.
RJJ didn’t know how to do any of this, and it showed as he aged at 33-35 vs Tarver 3x and Johnson. When RJJ’s superpowers were gone, he didn’t have the basic boxing fundamentals that his insane instincts bailed him out of in the past.
H2H, both in their prime, RJJ beats Mayweather. But that doesn’t mean he’s had the better career.
Floyd wouldn't even fight spence or Crawford when he was still active... And he would of most likely beat them... He just didn't want to take any unnecessary risks... What was Floyd's excuse for such blatant dodges? His last real fight was against freaking Berto....How can anyone say he had the better career....Floyd's blatant ducks were Spence, Crawford and Lara....Because even though those were all winnable fights they would of been close... Floyd fought maidana TWICE... TWICE... but avoided all those fights
Roy was a literal warrior who went up to heavyweight...
When Roy dropped down in weight he no longer looked invincible, you're right... But this has less to do with Roy lacking fundamentals... And more to Roy just being stubborn and trying to box the way he always did... Even the Glenn Johnson fight... he was still pretty damn fast... faster than probably any current boxer still... But his reflexes slowed down just enough that he was getting hit was stuff he would never get hit with before...
Floyd's blend of athleticism and boxing allowed him to be dominant until the very end of his career... perhaps if Roy made adjustments to his style of boxing he would of taken less punishment... But Roy was a stubborn warrior... Floyd was a "smart" boxer who carefully chose his opponents....
All this isn't to say I don't think Floyd isn't a great fighter... But he's just not a "better" fighter or TBE...