Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Boxing Without Boxing: The Magnificent Max Baer

Careers end.


Characters endure.

It’s as true in boxing as in many other walks of life. Lives lived vibrantly, colorfully, often outlive their active moments in time. Former heavyweight champion Max Baer last stepped into the ring in April 1941, stopped for the second time by Lou Nova. Baer left the earth 18 years later.

Yet, even in 2020, it doesn’t take long for new followers of boxing to happen upon his name and start to find some of what makes him enduring. Published in 2018, author Colleen Aycock (with David Wallace) attempted to capture so much of why in her enjoyable biography, The Magnificent Max Baer: The Life of the Heavyweight Champion and Film Star.

Aycock lets it be known early on the personal connection she feels to Baer, stating in the preface: feelings about the man are deeply rooted in my own family history. I know what life is like for the professional always on the road, mastering his trade, competing for titles, satisfying sponsors and other public demands. Although Max loved his family, he spent more time on the road than at home. He literally died on the road. My brother was a PGA touring golf pro who also died close to the age Max died. The long haul for any touring professional is gritty, and takes its toll on the body and family. My father also faced that toll. He was one of Max Baer’s many sparring partners. He eventually died from pugilistica dementia. Yet the stories my father told me and the opinions he held of Max were very different from those reflected in a movie that my father never lived to see.


Some readers will recall controversy around Cinderalla Man, the Ron Howard biopic of Jim Braddock, regarding its depiction of Baer. Aycock makes multiple references to the film in her book and one can see her biography as a corrective.

She doesn’t do so by painting Baer as a saint.

A saint would never have been so fun.

Instead, following an introduction to the life and family history of Baer, moving from Nebraska to Colorado and then finally to Northern California. Readers learn how Baer came to the sport, heading to Oakland to begin chasing his dreams in his late teens. It’s in the early stages that the flamboyant personality of Baer is seen already emerging with a taste for fast cars and nice clothes stressing early management.

The book takes care throughout to show how the managing of Baer framed much of his professional life with Baer building a trail of future lawsuits on the road to a lasting relationship with manager and promoter Ancil Hoffman. It also pays careful attention to the relationship Baer developed with former heavyweight champion Jack Dempsey. Dempsey would serve as a friend, mentor, and backer of Baer over the years and Baer’s punching power allowed for easy, early hopes he could be the next Dempsey.

Big for the era at nearly 6’3 and regularly over 200 lbs. as he matured, those aspirations were never quite achieved. Some of that is traced to the death of Frankie Campbell after Campbell was knocked out by Baer in 1930 and a change in Baer’s aggression. It would be compounded later when former foe Ernie Schaf succumbed to injuries in a bout with Primo Carnera just months after a physically exacting loss to Baer.

Writing about the Campbell loss in particular, and the ensuing legal fallout, Aycock relates:

The headline death in the ring brought national attention to both victim and victor. The twenty-one year old (Baer) was horrified at what had happened, and he would never recover. Had it not been for this ring tragedy, Dan Parker said in the New York Mirror, his “killer instinct would have made Baer [the] greatest.”

As the book moves along, readers will find he was still great enough. He fell short of hopes in his New York debut, losing to Schaf in their first encounter and to the great Tommy Loughran but made his way back. Following a decision loss to Paulino Uzcudun in Reno in 1931, Baer would reel off 14 wins in a row including a knockout of former champion Max Schmeling and a toppling of Carnera for the crown.

It was in this phase of his career that Baer became more than just a boxer. Baer became a celebrity, complete with a tumultuous marriage to movie star Dorothy Dunbar and a starring role in The Prizefighter and the Lady. Baer would portray “Steve Morgan,” complete with a ring robe he would go on to use for real fights later on. Shades of the Oceans Eleven remake scene where Lennox Lewis and Wladimir Klitschko were brought together as fiction, Baer faced off with Carnera on screen before they met in reality.

Unlike Lewis and the younger Klitschko, life imitated art.

The win over Carnera was Baer’s apex. What followed, due to promotional struggles and turf battles not much different than what fans grow frustrated with today, Baer was left to the exhibition circuit for the year after Carnera. Aycock makes a strong case for an injured Baer arriving at his infamous upset loss to Jim Braddock with plenty of other colorful opines on what may have gone wrong that night.

The loss to Braddock was followed by a more devastating loss to Joe Louis that saw Baer slapped with a quitter label, in part due to harsh words from referee and Baer antagonist Art Donovan. Baer would work hard to shed the label, building another lengthy winning streak, hitting more turbulence in the ring, heading abroad to extend his fame, and never quite arriving at the second chance at the title he badly wanted.

Following his career, the book gives a good account of how Baer extended his public life in military service in World War II, on stage, on screen, and as a popular pitchman. It is ultimately as thorough an account of the life of Baer as one can find told from the voice of an admirer. For fans interested in a period in boxing when traveling from town to town just to be seen for a few rounds was still a vibrant part of the game, New York was the center of the fistic universe, and film noir vibes could feel like real life, Aycock’s biography of Baer will be a satisfying read and comes well recommended.

The Magnificent Max Baer can be found in print or for Kindle on Amazon.        

While the sport is largely postponed, boxing has a rich library of classic fights, films, and books to pass the time. In terms of fights, readers are welcome to get involved. Feel free to email, comment in the forum, or tweet @roldboxing with classic title fight suggestions. If they are widely available on YouTube, and this scribe has never seen them or simply wants to see them again, the suggestion will be credited while the fight is reviewed in a future chapter of Boxing Without Boxing.     

Previous Installments of Boxing Without Boxing

Gentleman Jim

Smokestack Lightning - Harry Greb, 1919

Roger Mayweather Vs. Serrano/Arredondo 

Ruben Olivares-Zensuke Utagawa

Hands of Stone

Eddie Mustafa Muhamad vs. Michael Spinks

Hitchcock’s The Ring 

Michael Carbajal-Muangchai Kittikasem


Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by eco1 on 04-03-2020

[QUOTE=landotter;20493840]Curious me has to ask: What are some of your favorites?[/QUOTE] There are many but to name only one: Raging bull would be the one. And as I said, I love Rocky, just the first one, the others suck.

Comment by landotter on 04-02-2020

[QUOTE=eco1;20492229]AS much as I love Rocky, from a cinematographic point of view, it is really very distant from the best boxing movies. Then , it is still a great movie on it's own.[/QUOTE] Curious me has to ask: What are…

Comment by Dasmius Shinobi on 04-02-2020

Max Baer power always make chill my spine. If this accident that rob him to become more famous and greatest was not happened, then he one who was going to be in the best top 5. :boxing:

Comment by eco1 on 04-01-2020

[QUOTE=landotter;20490527]First off... I love "Cinderella Man". Just think it hits on almost every dramatic note: -Maybe the greatest movie about the great depression made in the last 30 years. Not even sure what would be 2nd. -One of the greatest…

Comment by landotter on 04-01-2020

[QUOTE=crold1;20490534]For whatever reason, haven’t got to it yet. Have it on DVR[/QUOTE] It is a really fantastic movie. Honest. Hit "play", you will not be disappointed.

Top Headlines
Alejandra Jimenez: I Want Justice, I Will Always Be World Champ at 168! Estrada's Trainer Aims For Chocolatito, Does Not Rule Out Inoue Fight Kambosos Confident of Beating Selby, Eyes Loma-Lopez Winner Stevenson: I Watched One Round Of Caraballo; Nowhere Near On My Level Anthony Joshua Suffers Left Knee Injury, Marches For Black Lives Matter In Watford Jose Ramirez Considers Close Win Over Jose Zepeda Worst Performance Of Career Shakur Stevenson: Me And Gary Russell Jr. Would Be A Hell Of A Fight Jesse Hart Has Hand Surgery, Takes Aim at Michael Seals Clash Derevyanchenko: Fight With Jermall Charlo Will Happen In Due Time Thurman: My Biggest Mistake In 2019 Was My Weight Management Ryan Garcia: They're Gonna Say Linares Was Old, Has No Chin When I Catch Him Daily Bread Mailbag: Mayweather-Ortiz, Canelo, Plant, More Ivan Golub on Training With Lomachenko, Targeting Big Names at 147 Junior Younan Inks Managerial Pact With Peter Kahn Fortuna's Promoter Will Not Allow Haney-Campbell Clash To Come Off Arum on Fury-Wilder: Investors in Macau Ready To Put Up The Money Curtis Cokes: 'Boxing Has Been My Life' Berchelt's Trainer: Lomachenko is The One We Want To Beat! Felix Verdejo Improving His Skills in Training, Says Salas Deontay Wilder Breaks His Silence, Speaks On Black Lives Matter Movement Erickson Lubin's Coach: We Accept Gausha's Challenge Manager: Salamov, Vlasov Waiting To Hear From Top Rank For Fight Date Toka Kahn Clary Pulls Out of ESPN Co-Feature Against Abraham Nova Hatton: I Would've Beaten Anyone Night I Fought Tszyu, Including Mayweather Jerry Forrest Inks Promotional Pact With Lou DiBella Tom Schwarz Could Be Facing Charges For Alleged Assault on Woman Stevenson: Mayweather Comparisons Feel Good, But I'm Gonna Surpass Floyd Golden Boy Pleased With WBC Restoring Crews-Dezurn's Title Reign Devin Haney vs. Luke Campbell Eyed For August or September Nonito Donaire: I Know After Inoue Fight I Have A Lot Of Gas In My Tank Crawford: Garcia No Joke For Spence; Sturdier, Punches Harder Than Porter Arum Explains How "The Bubble" Will Work at Upcoming Top Rank Events Ellerbe: Badou Jack's Number One Option Is Rematch With Jean Pascal Melissa Oddessa Turns Pro, Will Be Guided By Andre Rozier Chisora Sees No Issue With More Boxing in Saudi Arabia - Explains Why Golden Boy Prez: Canelo Has 5 or 6 Options - GGG is Not One! News: Mitchell Barton, Quinton Randall, Jonathan Walsh Caraballo: If Stevenson Thinks I'm Easy, It’s Gonna Be A Long Night For Him Manny Pacquiao Might Fight Golovkin, Freddie Roach Says Holyfield Breaks Down His Strategy in Upset of Mike Tyson
Latest Forum Threads