Is Floyd the G.O.A.T why or why not?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Marchegiano
    Banned
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Aug 2010
    • 12208
    • 1,790
    • 2,307
    • 165,288

    #11
    More proficient in more forms than any other boxer who ever lived.

    You can take your Sugars and Armstrong and what nots and brag about their resume until the cows come home, you can brag about the weights they covered right there with their resume too. It don't really mean that much in All Time to me.


    Resume is something that will fade, no one will care in a hundred years, no one will care in a thousand for damn sure. None of you give any ****s about Klietomachos at all.

    Weight? What does Pythagoras of Samos mean to you? How about Tommy Ryan? Hmm....is it exclusively a GOAT marker for modern boxing? Not Queensberry, Tommy did that, but modern? from like the 30s-now? Those are the only guys whose names rest against high rank opposition at multiple weight classes or actual weights?


    What I'm trying to say is SRR, SRL, Armstrong, you know, you usual GOAT names, did absolutely nothing original in the sport as a whole but rather something special and original in their era of sport. When times change, so will the fans' interpretation of these men AND their importance to the sport.



    Bob Fitzsimmons is the first MW to HW except that was actually really normal in bare knuckle and Bob was a transition figure....so....was it really anything but timing?

    Roy Jones Jr is the first, and the only man to weigh at MW, go up to HW and weigh at HW, and be champion. Bob weighed his middleweight weight at heavyweight. Roy actually gained the pounds and was still successful.


    I love Bob, but, all time? Bob's just repetition of a thing that happened in boxing repeatedly and consistently from the ancient period through bare knuckle period. Bob is literally one of many, in All Time boxing. Roy is alone, the only man. You can go back 3k years you will not find another MW champion who became HW champion while weighing in at HW instead of weighing their normal MW weight.



    Back to Floyd, the first man to show no reliance on any aspect of boxing. He used plenty but relied on nothing.

    SRR lost because he was reliant

    SRL lost because he was reliant

    Armstrong lost because he was reliant

    Floyd never lost because Floyd could and did adapt to any situation. Floyd can box or punch or mix between them. Floyd has chin and head movement. Floyd can dance and plant. Traps? He'll set you up while you think you are setting him up.

    What beats Floyd? I dunno, nor do you. That would be conjecture, and in this case, wrong to do. It's denial of the one thing Floyd actually relied on; being plastic. Being unreliant is what he relied on his entire career. Take away Wilder's right hand and what have you got? Take away Floyd's and he's still Floyd. Nonreliant. He proved it. Slow him down and make him old? Still Floyd, still beating young men on their rise up to be the next p4p king. Unlike SRR where taking away his power would be difficult but if you could it'd be effective, taking away Floyd's power is ineffective and does little to change the course of his fights. Now he just doesn't hit you as hard, but, he's still hitting you, and often. Damn hard nut to crack which is why it never happened.








    The most prepared fighter of all time, by a ****load.





    Dig this, you want to know how I know Floyd would beat SRR if they shared a time? SRR is willing to show up drunk, Floyd isn't. Most prepared fighter of all time. Not just repeating an award that has happened a bunch of times, a real all time record for the gods. Floyd would definitely get Sugar on the bottle.



    If you like Sugars or Henry, that's cool, this isn't a hit piece, I wouldn't ever attack you for ranking them so highly or argue in Floyd's favor, but for me, Floyd and honestly it isn't even that hard for me to say that.


    Do you really think Wlad's the only man to reign a decade over a ****show? He's just repetition promoted like it isn't.

    Y'all really believe Manny covered the most weight? Children used to box.

    Marciano's the only unbeaten HW champion, except for the ten others that existed before him.


    Floyd Mayweather, most prepared fighter to ever fight, alone, singular, there is only him.

    Comment

    • hugh grant
      Undisputed Champion
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Apr 2006
      • 30534
      • 2,198
      • 921
      • 105,596

      #12
      He is arguably the greatest unbeaten boxer who ever walked the earth

      Comment

      • QueensburyRules
        Undisputed Champion
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • May 2018
        • 22582
        • 2,475
        • 18
        • 187,708

        #13
        Originally posted by Blue54
        Pls give valid reasons for your opinions.
        - -TBA TUE 51-0 = Limp

        Comment

        • Canelo and GGG
          NSB's Golden Boy
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Sep 2016
          • 4582
          • 106
          • 92
          • 15,725

          #14
          Originally posted by Marchegiano
          More proficient in more forms than any other boxer who ever lived.

          You can take your Sugars and Armstrong and what nots and brag about their resume until the cows come home, you can brag about the weights they covered right there with their resume too. It don't really mean that much in All Time to me.


          Resume is something that will fade, no one will care in a hundred years, no one will care in a thousand for damn sure. None of you give any ****s about Klietomachos at all.

          Weight? What does Pythagoras of Samos mean to you? How about Tommy Ryan? Hmm....is it exclusively a GOAT marker for modern boxing? Not Queensberry, Tommy did that, but modern? from like the 30s-now? Those are the only guys whose names rest against high rank opposition at multiple weight classes or actual weights?


          What I'm trying to say is SRR, SRL, Armstrong, you know, you usual GOAT names, did absolutely nothing original in the sport as a whole but rather something special and original in their era of sport. When times change, so will the fans' interpretation of these men AND their importance to the sport.



          Bob Fitzsimmons is the first MW to HW except that was actually really normal in bare knuckle and Bob was a transition figure....so....was it really anything but timing?

          Roy Jones Jr is the first, and the only man to weigh at MW, go up to HW and weigh at HW, and be champion. Bob weighed his middleweight weight at heavyweight. Roy actually gained the pounds and was still successful.


          I love Bob, but, all time? Bob's just repetition of a thing that happened in boxing repeatedly and consistently from the ancient period through bare knuckle period. Bob is literally one of many, in All Time boxing. Roy is alone, the only man. You can go back 3k years you will not find another MW champion who became HW champion while weighing in at HW instead of weighing their normal MW weight.



          Back to Floyd, the first man to show no reliance on any aspect of boxing. He used plenty but relied on nothing.

          SRR lost because he was reliant

          SRL lost because he was reliant

          Armstrong lost because he was reliant

          Floyd never lost because Floyd could and did adapt to any situation. Floyd can box or punch or mix between them. Floyd has chin and head movement. Floyd can dance and plant. Traps? He'll set you up while you think you are setting him up.

          What beats Floyd? I dunno, nor do you. That would be conjecture, and in this case, wrong to do. It's denial of the one thing Floyd actually relied on; being plastic. Being unreliant is what he relied on his entire career. Take away Wilder's right hand and what have you got? Take away Floyd's and he's still Floyd. Nonreliant. He proved it. Slow him down and make him old? Still Floyd, still beating young men on their rise up to be the next p4p king. Unlike SRR where taking away his power would be difficult but if you could it'd be effective, taking away Floyd's power is ineffective and does little to change the course of his fights. Now he just doesn't hit you as hard, but, he's still hitting you, and often. Damn hard nut to crack which is why it never happened.








          The most prepared fighter of all time, by a ****load.





          Dig this, you want to know how I know Floyd would beat SRR if they shared a time? SRR is willing to show up drunk, Floyd isn't. Most prepared fighter of all time. Not just repeating an award that has happened a bunch of times, a real all time record for the gods. Floyd would definitely get Sugar on the bottle.



          If you like Sugars or Henry, that's cool, this isn't a hit piece, I wouldn't ever attack you for ranking them so highly or argue in Floyd's favor, but for me, Floyd and honestly it isn't even that hard for me to say that.


          Do you really think Wlad's the only man to reign a decade over a ****show? He's just repetition promoted like it isn't.

          Y'all really believe Manny covered the most weight? Children used to box.

          Marciano's the only unbeaten HW champion, except for the ten others that existed before him.


          Floyd Mayweather, most prepared fighter to ever fight, alone, singular, there is only him.
          For me there is no GOAT in boxing (and any other sport) ,you bring great point about Floyd allways being fit and prepared ,Many great athletes were drinking and living unhealthy in the past (there are some now a day ,but you need to be much more healthy to compete now )

          Then you talk about SRR ,but we need to notice that when you fight 2 time a year you can prepere for your opponent ,study him , have great training camp ,now if you fight 10 times a year or more , often with same boxers which get to know you ,(its like playing a team game ,some dominant teams often play very close games with domestic rival despite being much better team in general) , quality of fights suffer ,you are getting hit more ,and as i said fighting same people many times results in bigger chance of loss.


          IMO we cant compare they'r careers and be fair for many reasons.

          Comment

          • Smash
            Undisputed Champion
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Nov 2008
            • 16338
            • 6,600
            • 7,978
            • 21,172

            #15
            floyd is the best boxer of this era imo but prime pac didnt happen and he has to take a big hit for that one, yes he could and should have made that fight but he choose not to and others too when he retired first time with big names there, he shoulh have cleaned 147 out at that time instead of retiriing imo thats what the goat woiuld have gone

            Comment

            • Smash
              Undisputed Champion
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Nov 2008
              • 16338
              • 6,600
              • 7,978
              • 21,172

              #16
              Originally posted by anonymous2.0
              I love Floyd Mayweather but he ain't the G.O.A.T, that honor belongs to Ray Robinson
              lmao........

              Comment

              • ruedboy
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jul 2015
                • 4164
                • 386
                • 381
                • 101,745

                #17
                A better question would be ,"What fighter besides Floyd and Ali has ever put themselves forward as TBE. Most of the time when Ali said it, it was part of his shtick. As for Floyd, I don't even think he truly believes it.

                Comment

                • hugh grant
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Apr 2006
                  • 30534
                  • 2,198
                  • 921
                  • 105,596

                  #18
                  Originally posted by ruedboy
                  A better question would be ,"What fighter besides Floyd and Ali has ever put themselves forward as TBE. Most of the time when Ali said it, it was part of his shtick. As for Floyd, I don't even think he truly believes it.
                  Floyd knows people don't think he's the best ever. Floyd s knows he's not got the best resume ever, but he believes he's got the best defence ever or even skills.
                  Someone should start a thread about how do people think Floyd feels about knowing people dont think he's the best ever! Does he lose sleep over it? To what level does it bother him that most don't think he's as great as pac?
                  I don't start threads usually I don't like spotlight
                  Last edited by hugh grant; 05-11-2020, 04:40 PM.

                  Comment

                  • ruedboy
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jul 2015
                    • 4164
                    • 386
                    • 381
                    • 101,745

                    #19
                    Originally posted by hugh grant
                    Floyd knows people don't think he's the best ever. Floyd s knows he's not got the best resume ever, but he believes he's got the best defence ever or even skills.
                    Someone should start a thread about how do people think Floyd feels about not thinking he's the best ever! I don't start threads usually I don't like spotlight
                    It's not hard to analyze Floyd. He comes from a basic sense of insecurity. So all his actions are about compensating for that. The TBE, TMT, the domestic abuse, the flaunting of his wealth are all about compensating for that little voice telling him he's not good enough. Floyd's great work ethic, his focus on always being in shape and his perfectionism are all about not allowing himself to be criticized. Floyd's an overachiever, always trying to measure up to what he thinks he should be. IMO :-)

                    Comment

                    • hugh grant
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Apr 2006
                      • 30534
                      • 2,198
                      • 921
                      • 105,596

                      #20
                      Originally posted by ruedboy
                      It's not hard to analyze Floyd. He comes from a basic sense of insecurity. So all his actions are about compensating for that. The TBE, TMT, the domestic abuse, the flaunting of his wealth are all about compensating for that little voice telling him he's not good enough. Floyd's great work ethic, his focus on always being in shape and his perfectionism are all about not allowing himself to be criticized. Floyd's an overachiever, always trying to measure up to what he thinks he should be. IMO :-)
                      I don't think Floyd could have trained harder, or dedicated himself harder.But
                      I don't think Floyd took the career path to make himself the best ever or best of era.
                      Someone should ask Floyd how he feels about people not thinking he's as highly rated as pac!
                      Pac s often cited as top 3. Floyd knows he himself don't belong in that company. How does that make Floyd feel, does it upset floyd?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP