Mayweather wins fighter if the decade yahoo.com

[Larry the boss]

every win means something man. in that case, lets take out mosley, cotto, maidana, guerrero and berto from floyd's list. you cool with that? im listing all the fights he fought, win or lose. it's to show the work he put in for that "decade"...

Mosley was p4p#3 and WBA champ

Cotto was WBA champ

Maidana was WBA champ

so why would we take them off??

how many CURRENT world champs did each beat??

Floyd beat

Mosley-p4p #3
Cotto
Canelo-p4p #9
Maidana
Pacquiao-p4p #2

Manny beat

Thurman
Vargas

thats all i am saying

[sicko]

Can't complain about Mayweather getting FOTD

Made a lot of history this Decade

[The Big Dunn]

so if we go by this, and count the loss manny has, we also have to count the win he accomplished after those loss. so if you add those up, he outdid floyd. this is an award for FOTD, not an award for the fighter with the best record or best win.

It’s more than 1 loss. If you say accomplishments are all that counts, ok cool. Going undefeated is an accomplishment that manny didn’t achieve.

Beating a top 2 p4p fighter is something manny didn’t accomplish.

Going undefeated in title fights.

Losses have to factor in somehow because the losses prevent you from accomplishing everything you wanted.

Also, if I read some posters Manny was washed in 2015, so how exactly does he get to be fotd if he was washed half way through the decade? Is Alfred Angelo or James Kirkland also fotd material?

[hugh grant]

To be fotd you need to be seen to have taken risks and not try get advantages. You gotta be succinct with these Floyd boys
But these Floyd boys are so desperate no matter what logic you throw at them. Floyd never took risks, he only fought half a decade? Where does it stop? Can you only fight 3 years of a decade and be fotd or is that taking it a bit too far?
Ok Floyd is Fotd if it means so much to you. For gosh sake.

[djtmal]

It’s more than 1 loss. If you say accomplishments are all that counts, ok cool. Going undefeated is an accomplishment that manny didn’t achieve.

Beating a top 2 p4p fighter is something manny didn’t accomplish.

Going undefeated in title fights.

Losses have to factor in somehow because the losses prevent you from accomplishing everything you wanted.

Also, if I read some posters Manny was washed in 2015, so how exactly does he get to be fotd if he was washed half way through the decade? Is Alfred Angelo or James Kirkland also fotd material?

Beating an all time great fighter in their prime is something Floyd never did.
Are you going to offer up an excuse or just accept it

[djtmal]

To be fotd you need to be seen to have taken risks and not try get advantages. You gotta be succinct with these Floyd boys
But these Floyd boys are so desperate no matter what logic you throw at them. Floyd never took risks, he only fought half a decade? Where does it stop? Can you only fight 3 years of a decade and be fotd or is that taking it a bit too far?
Ok Floyd is Fotd if it means so much to you. For gosh sake.

They could name Floyd fighter of the millennium for beating Adrien Broner, and Dunn and Larry will defend it.

[Larry the boss]

because he;s still better than the rest of them! holy shiiet!! so you're saying a 41 year old manny is not shot and is still in the best shape of his life? it goes to show you that he was cut from a different cloth when you compare him to the comp now.

there is a difference between being old and being shot..Manny is far from shot

[Larry the boss]

To be fotd you need to be seen to have taken risks and not try get advantages. You gotta be succinct with these Floyd boys
But these Floyd boys are so desperate no matter what logic you throw at them. Floyd never took risks, he only fought half a decade? Where does it stop? Can you only fight 3 years of a decade and be fotd or is that taking it a bit too far?
Ok Floyd is Fotd if it means so much to you. For gosh sake.

I just dont see how you can say him fighting

Pacquiao at 38
Canelo at 36

just those 2 is not taking a risk..that would mean you really have high standards for floyd...

[Larry the boss]

Oh I must have touched a nerve.
You gonna admit you said, that a prime Zab Judah was Floyd's best win?

I never said Judah was floyds best win, I said it was a prime fighter he beat

Can you please back up the claims that he was forced to face Manny?? People literally said he was forced to fight Canelo to..only to down grade the win after

[IceTrayDaGang]

Mosley was p4p#3 and WBA champ

Cotto was WBA champ

Maidana was WBA champ

so why would we take them off??

how many CURRENT world champs did each beat??

Floyd beat

Mosley-p4p #3
Cotto
Canelo-p4p #9
Maidana
Pacquiao-p4p #2

Manny beat

Thurman
Vargas

thats all i am saying

lucas was WBA champ
horn was WBO champ
algieri was WBO champ

like i said, this is the award for FOTD, not an award for fighter with the best record.