Historian Monte Cox: Floyd no top 10 welter. No ATG.

[djtmal]

Im fine if this is how he sees things but his analysis is faulty and not factual.

Manny and Shane waited to fight Floyd, not the other way round. He also unified the division when he defeated Manny.

Well this is one legit historian that doesn't even recognize Floyd one way or the other.

Pull up your list of legit historians that refute everything this guy is saying.

[BodyBagz]

Did this historian mention ''the great 8'' ?!?!?

[MONGOOSE66]

http://coxscorner.tripod.com/divisional_ratings.html

Your fooken kidding right?
Boxing historian??
A fooken self proclaimed historian?
Professional bible thumper??

[The Big Dunn]

Well this is one legit historian that doesn't even recognize Floyd one way or the other.

Pull up your list of legit historians that refute everything this guy is saying.

read my comments in this thread. Have no issue with his opinion outside of it isn’t factual- he claimed Floyd never unified which he did.

Comments made in 2012 Before wins over manny cotto and canelo.

[hugh grant]

Where on earth is Pac on this list?

[#1PaperChamp]

http://coxscorner.tripod.com/divisional_ratings.html

The ONLY issue I have with writers reasoning is he places ALL the blame on Floyd.

Mosley is literally on record saying he wouldnt fight Floyd because he had a dentist appointment...that literally happened.

Some people dont like to hear this but Manny couldve taken the drug tests in 2009 and the fight wouldve happened. Hell Freddy Roach even suggested the 1st negotiations were Mannys fault.

But you can say Manny and Mosley were too late. Floyd has a weird record where collectively its very strong but theres no SINGLE weight class where he dominated

[djtmal]

read my comments in this thread. Have no issue with his opinion outside of it isn’t factual- he claimed Floyd never unified which he did.

Comments made in 2012 Before wins over manny cotto and canelo.

You were the one crowing about legit historians and this guy is supposed to be as legit as they get and he has no respect for Floyd's ww run at all seems like.

[BodyBagz]

Does the historian ever mention the name Pac ????

[BodyBagz]

Where on earth is Pac on this list?

Doesn't exist

[GhostofDempsey]

Whoever this ****** is no one cares about what he has to say. The moment he said Floyd avoided Mosley and Pacquiao then you know he aint no historian.

I'm pretty sure more people care about what he has to say than you. Don't be salty because he is right. If it hurts your feelings any less, he didn't put Manny on the list either. Feel better now?