Comments Thread For: IBHOF Modern Ballot: Rule Changes Create Tough Decisions For 2020

[Oregonian]

gatti is a special case. he's arguably the most exciting fighter ever. adn you're either being intentionally difficult or really just that clueless if you don't understand that and feel the need to compare his resume to tim bradley's like it means anything.

———-

Would you say Ward or EDIson Miranda or even Khan were exciting?
THey are all the same so if Gatti is HoF caliber and exciting then these too should be in there too, don’t you think?

This list has Tarver for heaven’s sake!! Tarver is only remembered for his KO of Roy. He literally did shït after that

[Shadoww702]

I would drop Mosley and Tarver for Diego and Sergio

[Shadoww702]

Moorer is more worthy then Tarver starting out at LHW and beating Holyfield and he fought some GREAT HW’s.

[Oregonian]

I would drop Mosley and Tarver for Diego and Sergio

——-

Tarver is garbage. He’s still riding his KO of Roy other than that he’s done literally nothing.
I can’t believe this writer!!

Mosley not getting this clown’s vote is a joke.
Sergio’s resume is 10 times better than Tarver.

[£-4-£]

B-Hop & JMM will get in for sure.

After that who knows.

Mosley, Bradley, Calderon, Martinez will get in too I feel. I'd like to see Froch get in too one day - I was at Wembley!

Interesting to see that he/they consider Sergio Martinez's 154lbs IBO and interim-WBC to be worthy of note in this so he's a '2 division champ'. But not Jorge Arce's 5 defences of his interim-WBC Flyweight title to make him a '5 division champ'.

[Chrismart]

That's a tough list.

[Dyl-G]

They let Arturo Gatti into the Hall of Fame so you might as well let anyone in now.

For example: I like Tim Bradley and consider him a pretty good little fighter. Is he Hall of Fame material, though? I would say no.

But wait...was he better than Gatti? Hell yes. So then that means he deserves to be in.

Its called hall of fame...not hall of the best

[Shadoww702]

Its called hall of fame...not hall of the best

They made a movie about Micky Ward with A list actors??? Just sayn

[Shadoww702]

———-

Would you say Ward or EDIson Miranda or even Khan were exciting?
THey are all the same so if Gatti is HoF caliber and exciting then these too should be in there too, don’t you think?

This list has Tarver for heaven’s sake!! Tarver is only remembered for his KO of Roy. He literally did shït after that

I buy Khans fights just to see him get Knocked-Out! I still want to see glass jaw vs. glass eye

[Shadoww702]

——-

Tarver is garbage. He’s still riding his KO of Roy other than that he’s done literally nothing.
I can’t believe this writer!!

Mosley not getting this clown’s vote is a joke.
Sergio’s resume is 10 times better than Tarver.

I don’t want Mosley because he’s a cheat and admits it.