So did Mayweather officially duck Margarito now that it's over?

[amagnin]

he is a legit Welter in his PRIME. current title holder..Floyd has not fought the best at 140 and now again at 147. he is calling out past their prime Mosley and Dela. Dela is figting twice in three years...

if Floyd decides to fight Baldi and wins, he will no doubt be the "ring" champ at 147 BUT he will not have proven himself against the best once again in another weight class.

I agree with you that Floyd was not the champ at 140, but your analysis here says that IF Floyd had beaten Hatton and not Cotto then he would not have been the champ at 140 because he hadn't taken on all worthy opponents. If Floyd beats Baldomir he will be a recognized champ at 147. Now if you are talking legacy all boxing fans like us will know that even though he was the linear champ at 147, he avoided fighting a dangerous titlist in Margarito. On the other hand our dislike of Floyd's career management shouldn't jade our opinons of his accomplishments.

[charlie31]

I agree with you that Floyd was not the champ at 140, but your analysis here says that IF Floyd had beaten Hatton and not Cotto then he would not have been the champ at 140 because he hadn't taken on all worthy opponents. If Floyd beats Baldomir he will be a recognized champ at 147. Now if you are talking legacy all boxing fans like us will know that even though he was the linear champ at 147, he avoided fighting a dangerous titlist in Margarito. On the other hand our dislike of Floyd's career management shouldn't jade our opinons of his accomplishments.

not true..i said he will not have beatin the best...he would still be the "champ".now if you feel Miguel Cotto is the BEST..at 140 that is your opinion.....def not mine

[guru]

i'm disgusted by the thought of PBF fighting spinks or baldy... neither guy has a snow ball chance in hell of beating him...

[cortdawg25]

he is a legit Welter in his PRIME. current title holder..Floyd has not fought the best at 140 and now again at 147. he is calling out past their prime Mosley and Dela. Dela is figting twice in three years...

if Floyd decides to fight Baldi and wins, he will no doubt be the "ring" champ at 147 BUT he will not have proven himself against the best once again in another weight class.

he is a LEGIT jr middleweight u mean and he is a current paper title holder. Floyd didnt fight the best at 140 because they didnt want to fight. And what makes Margarito the best at 147, I know u not talking about his skill, I know u not talking about his record, I know u not talking about his weak belt. who did Margarito beat at 147, HELL AT ALL, to make him the best at 147?

[TheGreat1]

If he Baldo it's ok, because he is the true champ. But i really Dont care i'd rather see see Margarito and Baldo fight if i could pick any fight. PBF knows how easy he would and could beat Tony,

[charlie31]

he is a LEGIT jr middleweight u mean and he is a current paper title holder. Floyd didnt fight the best at 140 because they didnt want to fight. And what makes Margarito the best at 147, I know u not talking about his skill, I know u not talking about his record, I know u not talking about his weak belt. who did Margarito beat at 147, HELL AT ALL, to make him the best at 147?

who did Floyd beat at WELTER? SHARMBA MITCHELL?? ZU'S LEFTOVERS! IT WAS SHARMA MICTHELL FIRST FIGHT AT WELTER...THEN HE FOUGHT JUDAH WHO WAS JUST BEAT BY BALDI!! WHO BY THE WAY WAS KO'S BY ZU ASWELL .REAL BOXING FANS KNOW WHO AND WHAT MARGARITO IS TO THE WELTER WEIGHT DIVISION.

[charlie31]

If he Baldo it's ok, because he is the true champ. But i really Dont care i'd rather see see Margarito and Baldo fight if i could pick any fight. PBF knows how easy he would and could beat Tony,

then get paid 8 mil to do it. dumb

[amagnin]

who did Floyd beat at WELTER? SHARMBA MITCHELL?? ZU'S LEFTOVERS! IT WAS SHARMA MICTHELL FIRST FIGHT AT WELTER...THEN HE FOUGHT JUDAH WHO WAS JUST BEAT BY BALDI!! WHO BY THE WAY WAS KO'S BY ZU ASWELL .REAL BOXING FANS KNOW WHO AND WHAT MARGARITO IS TO THE WELTER WEIGHT DIVISION.

I think it is fair to say that both of them are fairly untested at welterweight. Margarito won the title in a title eliminator and has only beaten Cintron; 6 heads Lewis; and Gomez in terms of big names. Floyd beat Mitchell and Judah. Both of these resumes leave plenty to do at WW. Margarito never fought any of the other recognized title holders like Collazo or Judah. Mayweather won a totally bogus title from a defeated Judah. Neither of them are the real champion of the division. Baldomir is plain and simple. He beat the undisputed champion and thereby became the champ. If I had to pick a resume, I choose Floyd's because at least he beat Judah who recently was "the man" at 147.

[cortdawg25]

who did Floyd beat at WELTER? SHARMBA MITCHELL?? ZU'S LEFTOVERS! IT WAS SHARMA MICTHELL FIRST FIGHT AT WELTER...THEN HE FOUGHT JUDAH WHO WAS JUST BEAT BY BALDI!! WHO BY THE WAY WAS KO'S BY ZU ASWELL .REAL BOXING FANS KNOW WHO AND WHAT MARGARITO IS TO THE WELTER WEIGHT DIVISION.

All that what u said is true, Floyd did beat Sharmba and Zab. That was Sharmba 1st fight at welter and they both did get KO by Kostya, true. But the question I asked was " Who did MARGARITO beat at all to even make him the best at 147?" What makes Margarito the best? By the way Sharmba and Zab skills and career are better. Sharmba and Zab have more accomplishments in the sport and fought better fighters. margarito has never faced someone of Kostya caliber, let alone Mayweather's caliber. U want Floyd to fight the best at 147, what makes Margarito the best?

[TheGreat1]

then get paid 8 mil to do it. dumb

i beleive he thiks, that if he waits for Tony to beat another big name, then he could add a few more million to that pot