Comments Thread For: Kovalev-Yarde Finally Confirmed For August 24 in Chelyabinsk

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SchoolTheseCats
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2015
    • 4241
    • 315
    • 24
    • 42,519

    #51
    Originally posted by tophat1
    yes , I'm not 100% but I think cotto won the middleweight title against Martinez at a catchweight too
    Above the sww limit cw was 157lbs I believe

    Comment

    • kafkod
      I am Fanboy. Very Fanboy
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Sep 2013
      • 24747
      • 2,174
      • 1,789
      • 405,373

      #52
      Originally posted by Greedo's Lawyer
      I was the main person saying this on the board when Spence fought Mikey and even still, about 20 times.

      But aside from that...

      Name me some fights where a guy fought at his highest weight class, for instance Canelo at 168 vs Fielding, and then GOING DOWN to 164 as you say, from an even bigger fighter than Fielding such as Kovalev at LHW.

      YOu KNOW the usual practice would be for Canelo to CAP at lets say 169 against Kovalev NOT 164.

      Stop playing the fool. Waiting for your list of fights
      Rules are rules and the rules are what I was talking about. How fighters handle moving up and down in weight is a different subject.

      Comment

      • Thuglife Nelo
        Banned
        • Dec 2018
        • 26836
        • 1,299
        • 1,822
        • 654,176

        #53
        Originally posted by kafkod
        Rules are rules and the rules are what I was talking about. How fighters handle moving up and down in weight is a different subject.
        Everybody knows the rules we're talking about consistency. You want to be consistent? OK. I'll play your game. BJS said he can still make 160lbs and fought at 178lbs right after his scandal from 160lbs...

        Would BJS fight Yarde at a 164lb catchweight for a LHW title since you illustrate hypotheticals that Canelo would fight Kovalev at 164 for a LHW title?

        You guys are ret@rded. I don't like BJS but I don't go full ret@rd on the sport like yall hatin on Canelo
        Last edited by Thuglife Nelo; 07-12-2019, 01:03 PM.

        Comment

        • kafkod
          I am Fanboy. Very Fanboy
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Sep 2013
          • 24747
          • 2,174
          • 1,789
          • 405,373

          #54
          Originally posted by Greedo's Lawyer
          Everybody knows the rules we're talking about consistency. You want to be consistent? OK. I'll play your game. BJS said he can still make 160lbs and fought at 178lbs right after his scandal from 160lbs...

          Would BJS fight Yarde at a 164lb catchweight for a LHW title since you illustrate hypotheticals that Canelo would fight Kovalev at 164 for a LHW title?

          You guys are ret@rded. I don't like BJS but I don't go full ret@rd on the sport like yall hatin on Canelo
          Rules are nothing if not rational and logical. You are anything but rational and logical, as you are proving now.

          Do yourself a favour and don't even try to think about stuff like rules.

          Comment

          • MastaBlasta
            Undisputed Champion
            • Jul 2017
            • 1851
            • 236
            • 328
            • 36,075

            #55
            Fights at catchweights should ALWAYS be EXHIBITIONS.

            They should never count towards a title. No sactioning body should allow it to count. It undermines everything.

            You think you better than a LHW, you either fight him at LHW or it's an exhibition.

            Catchweights = "I could beat them if they were smaller" WTF?

            If he's too big then don't fight him.

            Comment

            • Thuglife Nelo
              Banned
              • Dec 2018
              • 26836
              • 1,299
              • 1,822
              • 654,176

              #56
              Originally posted by kafkod
              Rules are nothing if not rational and logical. You are anything but rational and logical, as you are proving now.

              Do yourself a favour and don't even try to think about stuff like rules.
              Yeah Josh Taylor should fight Julian Williams at a 147lb catchweight and deem it a Super Welterweight fight.

              You guys are ret@rded.

              Because “it’s the rules.” Lol

              Comment

              • Nomadic
                Undisputed Champion
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Mar 2013
                • 5533
                • 226
                • 969
                • 28,516

                #57
                Originally posted by MDPopescu
                ... canelo wants shit... he "wants" CW and rehydration clause and whatever... he wants shit, tbh...
                You got that right.

                Comment

                • moltres.
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jan 2015
                  • 1225
                  • 45
                  • 31
                  • 22,614

                  #58
                  this will be a good fight, i look forward to it. hopefully its not on ppv, even though likely it will.

                  Comment

                  • Alan Smithee
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Feb 2018
                    • 2353
                    • 280
                    • 133
                    • 56,492

                    #59
                    Originally posted by MastaBlasta
                    Fights at catchweights should ALWAYS be EXHIBITIONS.

                    They should never count towards a title. No sactioning body should allow it to count. It undermines everything.

                    You think you better than a LHW, you either fight him at LHW or it's an exhibition.

                    Catchweights = "I could beat them if they were smaller" WTF?

                    If he's too big then don't fight him.
                    I disagree. Super milddle limit is 168 and light heavy is 175. A catchweight at 170 or172 could still be for a light heavyweight title. Is it a little shady? Sure but as long as you are above the lower weight limit and right at or below the current one then it can be for a title. The solution is to not accept the clause but if it is a big money offer a lot of dudes take the payday. Can't blame them!

                    Comment

                    • Boxing Scene
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                      • Jan 2007
                      • 7105
                      • 915
                      • 1,705
                      • 29,819

                      #60
                      A huge **** YOU to Canelo and his ****ty ass catch weights and rehydration clauses. Got fight the Liam Smith's and Rocky Fieldings of the world azzhole.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP