Comments Thread For: Fighter of The Decade? Mayweather, Ward Top List of Candidates

[Feint First]

Based strictly off wins and losses, #1 Ward by a landslide, #2 Manny, #3 Floyd.

Manny has wins vs. Clottey, Margarito, Mosley, Marquez, Bradley twice, Broner, and only two legit losses. One was to Floyd but he has more solid wins than Floyd.

Lomo is borderline. Crawford and lil g don't even belong in the conversation with their weak opponents/lack of quality wins. Sor Rungvisai deserves a mention over them with wins vs. Gonzalez twice and Estrada.

[Letmaku]

All 10 P4P Boxers share FOTD 😁

[Marvlus Marv]

1. Mayweather
2. Pacman
3. Buglioni

[Weebler I]

Mayweather effectively retired in 2015, only has 6 fights, so it's hard to view him as fighter of the decade.

Klitschko has 3 good wins over Haye, Povetkin and Pulev but also two significant losses.

If Hauser's picks are accurate then it's between the other three, Canelo, Golovkin & Ward

GGG and Canelo have given us nearly 20 fights each, Ward just 9 and some of those weren't great (Brand, Smith Jr. and a consensus loss to Kovalev where he was dropped).

It's GGG or Canelo imo, Canelo favorite, but maybe the trilogy in September settles matters.

[Letmaku]

No cherry picker for FOTD please 😁

[Letmaku]

Based strictly off wins and losses, #1 Ward by a landslide, #2 Manny, #3 Floyd.

Manny has wins vs. Clottey, Margarito, Mosley, Marquez, Bradley twice, Broner, and only two legit losses. One was to Floyd but he has more solid wins than Floyd.

Lomo is borderline. Crawford and lil g don't even belong in the conversation with their weak opponents/lack of quality wins. Sor Rungvisai deserves a mention over them with wins vs. Gonzalez twice and Estrada.

Agree to disagree sir but good one.

[Madison Boxing]

Ward?!??!?!?!?!?!

[Feint First]

Agree to disagree sir but good one.

Care to elaborate?

[Bjl12]

Based strictly off wins and losses, #1 Ward by a landslide, #2 Manny, #3 Floyd.

Manny has wins vs. Clottey, Margarito, Mosley, Marquez, Bradley twice, Broner, and only two legit losses. One was to Floyd but he has more solid wins than Floyd.

Lomo is borderline. Crawford and lil g don't even belong in the conversation with their weak opponents/lack of quality wins. Sor Rungvisai deserves a mention over them with wins vs. Gonzalez twice and Estrada.

Floyd has Manny and Canelo. That alone trumps anything Manny has done, possibly in his entire career.

[IronDanHamza]

Probably Mayweather or Pacquiao if he picks up a big win to close things out.

Pacquaio has 0% chance of winning it.