Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Pound For Pound Update - October 1

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • royjonesjrKTFO
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • May 2004
    • 1125
    • 32
    • 1
    • 12,803

    #81
    Lomachenko #1.. Best oppositions, Best skills/talent, etc.

    Comment

    • Vegemil
      Errol Spence Nuthugger
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Apr 2016
      • 4877
      • 190
      • 113
      • 250,131

      #82
      I love how in 5 for the future you have both AJ and Wilder but no Fury.

      Comment

      • Mexican_Puppet
        Undisputed Champion
        • Sep 2014
        • 7879
        • 431
        • 924
        • 66,971

        #83
        Originally posted by 1hourRun
        Mickey-Mouse ahead of Canelo?! 39 pro fights and his best win is a washed Adrien Broner, no no no.

        Olek Usyk has accomplished more in half the amount of time; five years pro, UNDISPUTED, WBSS tournament winner, compare that to Mickey's ten + year cherry-picking streak. Shameful! He couldn't even beat a Jorge Linares at 135 for the #1. spot, unbelievable -- Kosei Tanaka probably has a better argument for P4P.
        His best win is Salido


        Salido was way better than Broner

        Comment

        • Mexican_Puppet
          Undisputed Champion
          • Sep 2014
          • 7879
          • 431
          • 924
          • 66,971

          #84
          Originally posted by iamboxing
          Why don't you just come out and say what you're really thinking, "Golovkin was old!" instead of trying to appease both sides. We all know you're a Canelo hater.
          Yeah, Cliff is a fu.cking hater of Canelo

          Comment

          • Mexican_Puppet
            Undisputed Champion
            • Sep 2014
            • 7879
            • 431
            • 924
            • 66,971

            #85
            Originally posted by SniXSniPe
            -Rigondeaux (P4P but smaller)
            -Gary Russell Jr. - Top 3 fighter @ 126 and as of right now, probably borderline P4P.
            -Walters (borderline P4P) - Top 2 fighter @ 126, Top 5 fighter @ 130. Never had a close fight and got robbed of a dominant victory over Sosa. Only person to EVER stop Donaire.
            -Linares (world champ) - Top 3 fighter @ 135
            -Sosa (world champ) - weakest link, still a world champion and was able to pull off a KO against Fortuna.
            -Roman Martinez (world champ) - Completely schooled and dominated. Same guy that dropped Mikey.


            Canelo:
            Controversial/close win against Lara.
            Controversial fights against Golovkin.
            Win over Trout. Good win, close fight.
            Win over Cotto, who didn't do much his last 5 years besides beat a broken Sergio Martinez. Lost to Trout, Floyd, Canelo, and then ended his career with a defeat to Sadam Ali...



            There is definitely room to make an argument here. Just because a fighter is higher than another one doesn't mean it's not close. For what it's worth, I have: Crawford, Loma, Usyk, Canelo, and then Mikey--- and it's close between them all. Even then, this is only under the assumption I believe he won the last GGG fight (and I don't know, I didn't score it, I personally felt after watching it is was a close fight for sure, however. Would have been fine with a draw).

            Rigo was too small, that was worst than Canelo vs Khan fight.

            Walters won the fight against Donaire that was sh.it out of the 122 pounds.

            Linares was K.Oed bueno DeMarco, Salgado and Thompson.

            Román and Sosa are garbage.

            What are you talking about?

            Comment

            • Mexican_Puppet
              Undisputed Champion
              • Sep 2014
              • 7879
              • 431
              • 924
              • 66,971

              #86
              Originally posted by Shadoww702
              So you pump the sht out of one resume and spit on anothers to try and make your BIASED as *** point??

              1st Cotto was ranked P4P #9 at the time.

              2nd Salido was a BAD loss. He was a HUGE, HUGE underdog with double digit losses. Which Garcia dropped like 5 times and won practically every round

              Walters SUKS.

              Linares Kahn Jr. has a Round 1 KO loss and a round 2. Guys have 9 and 5 losses now. A dude Broner smashed TKO'd him also.

              Martinez LOL you brought him up?? Just because he dropped Mikey???

              Man this dude is ALL on LOMA's NUTS!!!
              Exactly.

              That guy is pathetic.

              Comment

              • aztec_warriors
                Contender
                Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                • Oct 2005
                • 236
                • 17
                • 0
                • 7,781

                #87
                Wtf???!

                BoxingScene or Cliff Rold... wtf y’all smoking???

                you crack heads stop smoking when creating Pound for Pound rankings

                Comment

                • Sledgeweather17
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jun 2015
                  • 3587
                  • 154
                  • 5
                  • 34,855

                  #88
                  Originally posted by The Big Dunn
                  The usual suspects triggered as usual by someone that knows the sport putting Crawford ahead of Loma.

                  I have posted before that Usyk IMO has a real case to be #1 so I really disagree with him being down at 5. Way too low IMO. I have the following list as of now:

                  1. Crawford
                  2. Lomachenko
                  3. Usyk
                  4. Mikey
                  5. Inoue
                  6. Sor Rungvisai
                  7. Canelo Alvarez
                  8. GGG
                  9. Spence
                  10. Joshua

                  If you have Crawford, Loma or Usyk #1 I don't really have an issue.
                  Does Wilder make the list for beating Ortiz and Fury consecutively (assuming he beats Fury)?

                  Comment

                  • Sledgeweather17
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jun 2015
                    • 3587
                    • 154
                    • 5
                    • 34,855

                    #89
                    Originally posted by Death_Adder
                    How is Crawford so high? He hasn't beaten anyone. Seriously, why is he so far up? What has he done to prove he belongs at the top spot?
                    Three weight division champion, first undisputed champion in...I don't even know how long, beat all of his opponents convincingly, ducked by the Pacman, passes the eye test without a shadow of doubt, in flying colours.

                    Comment

                    • Sledgeweather17
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Jun 2015
                      • 3587
                      • 154
                      • 5
                      • 34,855

                      #90
                      Originally posted by 187 Proof
                      My list is the best:

                      1. Canelo
                      2. Crawford
                      3. Usyk
                      4. M. Garcia
                      5. Inoue
                      6. Lomachenko
                      7. Estrada
                      8. Joshua
                      9. Spence
                      10. Golovkin
                      P4P, in other words, if all these guys were the same weight class who would win? That's what it means right?

                      So lemmie ask, you really think Canelo would beat all of these guys if they were in the same weight class as him?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP