Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Pound For Pound Update - October 1

[aboutfkntime]

So no one?

You admit Toney doesn't have a single significant win on his record?

only a corn-fed gimp would suggest such a thing

jog on clown

do you still think Shannon Briggs is the greatest HW ever ?

[elfag]

How can loma be that many spots ahead of canelo.

Canelo's resume is light years ahead of loma's. Its well ahead of any other fighter's today, including crawford, but atleast crawford is lineal in 2 divisions so maybe if you hate on canelo I get why you have him as number 1.

[suffolkbull3]

Loma should be top of the list, the size difference between him and Linares was more obvious than Crawford against Horn. Plus Horn is nowhere near the ability level of Linares.
If Usyk can go up to HW and beat someone of the caliber of Whyte, he'd go straight to the top of the list. Beating Bellew at CW, while it would be a very good win over someone who's fought at HW wouldn't be enough to do it.
I've always liked GGG (and I still think he beat Canelo both times, but could agree with a draw on 2nd fight), but he's definitely on the way down and is possibly the one fighter who should no longer be on this list.

You dont hold any weight behind loma being knocked down in his last fight and losing to salido against him at all? i also think loma is great but i cant have a guy at the top the very top of the p4p list who been knocked down recently andd although it was a while ago, has a L on his record vs a very avg champion. Dont get me wrong, i think what loma is doing is great but i cant put him at #1 in all of boxing right now

[markther]

The list seems out of order and I would at least have (1) HW Champion on that list, probably Joshua. Let’s you know what they think about the (2) HW champs, over rated. Ali is in his grave shouting, “they’re bums!”

And the strawweight Champion that is 51-0 gets NO love, Menayothin. I told you people think his record is a joke. How does a guy who broke that record not even land 10th on the list. So disrespectful-LOL!!

[MisanthropicNY]

no it has not

and P4P has not been " a thing " for most of "the history of boxing"

P4P is about..... who would win, if all things were equal (weight)

it mostly comes down to style/skills

ATG comes down to resume, not P4P..... big diff there

you absolutely can rate a rookie, which I did with Lomachenko 2-3 years ago

if it only comes down to resume', then why the fk should Golovkin be ranked?

GGG should have been up there only after getting robbed in the first Canelo fight and beating Jacobs. Definitely not before that.

[Vlad_]

My Top 5:

Crawford
Usyk
Canelo
Spence
Mikey

Not always about resume. It's mainly based on skills.

Skills? And Loma is not on your list?

[Johnston]

My Top 5:

Crawford
Usyk
Canelo
Spence
Mikey

Not always about resume. It's mainly based on skills.

Yea, because spences skills and resume are superior to lomachenko..

[Vasyl’s dad]

All those 0s in the top 10 and no Menayothin?

Doesnt get any better than 51-0.

The agenda is real.

[187 Proof]

My list is the best:

1. Canelo
2. Crawford
3. Usyk
4. M. Garcia
5. Inoue
6. Lomachenko
7. Estrada
8. Joshua
9. Spence
10. Golovkin

[187 Proof]

Crazy how Canelo is 2 years younger than Crawford, Garcia and Lomachenko yet arguably has a deeper resume than all 3 of them combined.