Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Pound For Pound Update - October 1

[UNBIASED BOXING]

Rigo was too small, that was worst than Canelo vs Khan fight.

Walters won the fight against Donaire that was sh.it out of the 122 pounds.

Linares was K.Oed bueno DeMarco, Salgado and Thompson.

Román and Sosa are garbage.

What are you talking about?

Khan fought below 140 for the vast majority of his career. He even got knocked out at both 135 and 140...

Rigo was a P4P fighter, undefeated, unbeaten, and many dumb**** fans claimed Loma was ducking (or that Arum wouldn't make the fight), and a career 122 lber. Khan wasn't a P4P and was much smaller than the now full fledged 160lber Canelo.


Walters dominated Donaire and stopped him. 4-years later, Frampton couldn't stop him and won by a decent decision. No other fighter has ever stopped Donaire. Walters was highly rated back in the day before his "No Mas". He easily KO'd Vic and dominated Sosa in his first fight at 130.

You can **** talk Sosa all you want, but it doesn't change the fact he stopped Fortuna which is a good win and earns him more credit than you give.

Linares had not lost in 6 years, 13 fights. He has always been seen as the #1-2 fighter at 135 when people were calling Mikey to fight him.

You got nothing bad to say about Russell Jr., good.


Now let's talk about Canelo.

Lara and the 2x Golovkin fights were controversial.
Cotto was old, shot, and not a real middleweight. Hell, he lost to Sadam Ali...
Kirkland was nothing special. Post prison and not the same fighter.

And so forth...




What are YOU talking about?

[Death_Adder]

Three weight division champion, first undisputed champion in...I don't even know how long, beat all of his opponents convincingly, ducked by the Pacman, passes the eye test without a shadow of doubt, in flying colours.

He beat bums and nobodies.

Has the worst resume right now.

[Shadoww702]

Rigo was too small, that was worst than Canelo vs Khan fight.

Walters won the fight against Donaire that was sh.it out of the 122 pounds.

Linares was K.Oed bueno DeMarco, Salgado and Thompson.

Román and Sosa are garbage.

What are you talking about?

EXACTLY! Rig. was tiny as *** compared to Loma.

Linares has a worse chin then Khan.

Walters LMFAO

Roman and Sosa dog sht on top of more dog sht.

[NearHypnos]

Why don't you just come out and say what you're really thinking, "Golovkin was old!" instead of trying to appease both sides. We all know you're a Canelo hater.

Lmao. Right? But doesnt acknowledge how Bud and Mikey dont even make the fights period. We cant even in get them in against great fighters that we can argue about being old...

I may s hit in ginger boy at times but he’s by far the clear #1 right now based off ACTUAL merit. Canelo could go up and beat Wilder and Aj on the same night and he’d say “Wilder’s skills were never great and AJ was always too big and robotic to compete. All he beat was an old Wlad and had real issues with Povetkin.”

[MehdiQaos]

Terence Crawford is good but he did nothing to deserve p4p number 1

[BoxingIsGreat]

Terence Crawford is good but he did nothing to deserve p4p number 1

Golovkin was at #1 a couple of years ago. What has he EVER done? Beat a bunch of bums? I've never had Golovkin anywhere near a top 10. Crawford, on the other hand, has crazy skills and an OK resume.

[The Big Dunn]

Does Wilder make the list for beating Ortiz and Fury consecutively (assuming he beats Fury)?

Homie you already know the answer is no for me. Wilder would have to beat Fury and AJ for me to consider him. I would have to see where he is after each fight but to be completely honest, I doubt I will ever rank him in my top 10 given the way he fights.

His power is phenomenal but his skill set and ring IQ are way too low for me. He punches too wide, can't really set up shots. I don't know how he improves at age 32.

[Boxing Goat]

Lol @ this garbage ranking!

Rold never ceases to surprise me. (negatively)

Sor Rungvisai and Garcia over GGG is a joke.

5 and 6 wins in title fights just doesn't cut it when we know GGG really beat Canelo at least once.

[Boxing Goat]

Crawford number 1 and Mikey Garcia number 3 Lol, I stopped reading after that.

This dude is a joke with an agenda against EU fighters. I have destroyed him several times over it.
He must've been a cold war victim or something.

[Boxing Goat]

Crawford at number 1, and I stopped reading after that. Crawford's resume is a blown up featherweight who has been exposed as mediocre with a glass jaw, Postol, and Jeff Horn (who robbed Pacquiao in his home country)...

Wow, some resume for a number 1 pound for pound fighter. Boxing is dead.

It's ridiculous. He has one decent win on his ledger. His resume is crap otherwise. Full of nobodies.