The Case For AJ/Wilder Being 50/50

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JRB123
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Dec 2010
    • 1446
    • 47
    • 72
    • 12,428

    #81
    Originally posted by Robbie Barrett
    Joshua is bigger worldwide and isn't far off Wilder in the states either.
    This.

    Oh on the part about the Martin situation...Charles Martin got offered that money to fight in the O2 Arena. If that fight was in the US then he would not have even been close to reaching that amount.

    Folks just have to realize that AJ was built into a star while Wilder was still having fights in Alabama. Doesn't matter if Wilder has a belt...he can't even draw a fanbase outside of his home state.

    Ever since he beat Stiverne in Vegas, he has not been there since. Isn't he the longest reigning heavyweight champion?

    No way Hearn is going to put up as much money for Wilder as he would for Joshua for the fight to happen in any location.

    Comment

    • KillaCamNZ
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Feb 2016
      • 3967
      • 200
      • 156
      • 29,082

      #82
      Originally posted by koolkc107
      The same amount as AJ- which is one of several reasons why it is a 50/50 fight.
      It looks like you're so deeply buried in your opinion, you're struggling to get out.

      Effectively you're saying, because Joshua is untested in one part of the market, it should be a 50-50 fight. Ignoring the fact that the US is only one part of the market - a market which is Wilder's backyard, which Wilder hasn't drawn in at all.

      Add it up - one has a record of drawing, the other doesn't. It's not ****ing rocket science - even though you're struggling with it.

      Comment

      • koolkc107
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Nov 2012
        • 4251
        • 218
        • 3
        • 59,059

        #83
        Originally posted by KillaCamNZ
        It looks like you're so deeply buried in your opinion, you're struggling to get out.

        Effectively you're saying, because Joshua is untested in one part of the market, it should be a 50-50 fight. Ignoring the fact that the US is only one part of the market - a market which is Wilder's backyard, which Wilder hasn't drawn in at all.

        Add it up - one has a record of drawing, the other doesn't. It's not ****ing rocket science - even though you're struggling with it.
        One has a track record of drawing in his own country.

        Wildly successful.

        Just like certain TV shows in Britain.

        But, that doesn't mean those same TV shows are going to do as well in the US.

        And you cannot demand the same in the US based on what has been done in Britain.

        There is no dis*****g that if this fight took place in Vegas, it would do a better gate than anything AJ has done in Britain.

        What AJ fanboys can't get their head around is that if the fight is in Vegas, AJ's PPV buys from British TV are almost irrelevant.
        Last edited by koolkc107; 12-07-2017, 06:22 PM.

        Comment

        • kafkod
          I am Fanboy. Very Fanboy
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Sep 2013
          • 24850
          • 2,203
          • 1,823
          • 405,373

          #84
          Originally posted by club fighter
          Really?...that's all you can come up with?
          No, but its all you deserve for those dumb comments of yours.

          Comment

          • KillaCamNZ
            Undisputed Champion
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Feb 2016
            • 3967
            • 200
            • 156
            • 29,082

            #85
            Originally posted by koolkc107
            One has a track record of drawing in his own country.

            Wildly successful.

            Just like certain TV shows in Britain.

            But, that doesn't mean those same TV shows are going to do as well in the US.

            And you cannot demand the same in the US based on what has been done in Britain.

            There is no dis*****g that if this fight took place in Vegas, it would do a better gate than anything AJ has done in Britain.

            What AJ fanboys can't get their head around is that if the fight is in Vegas, AJ's PPV buys from British TV are almost irrelevant.
            The PPV buys from the British market alone will be massive - they aren't suddenly going to disappear. They will still make up a significant portion of the overall revenue.

            You can't just single out a whole chunk of the product and proclaim it to be irrelevant - that's ****ing ******.

            And still none of this bull**** explains why you think Wilder should get 50% of the cut. You're going around in circles and avoiding the point.

            Get on with a proper argument about why Wilder should get half, or shut the **** up already.

            Comment

            • Real King Kong
              Undisputed Champion
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • May 2010
              • 12029
              • 460
              • 24
              • 105,905

              #86
              Originally posted by koolkc107
              The thing AJ fans love to point out- with decent enough reason- is what AJ has made in some of his last few fights.

              AJ made 8M pounds vs Martin

              AJ made 15M pounds vs Klitschko

              AJ made 10M pounds vs Takam

              (Against guys like Whyte, Molina, and Brazeale his purse were smaller, ranging from 1.5M to 3M pounds.)

              The 3 big fights cited above are miles above and beyond anything Wilder has made in any of his fights, they say, so Deontay should not ask for a 50/50 split.

              And that might actually make sense until you actually look at what his opponents got in those fights.

              Martin made 6M pounds.

              Wlad made 15M pounds.

              Takam made 750,000 pounds.

              Takam was a challenger taking the fight on 12 days notice. So he got a 90/10 split. The split for the fight with Pulev was going to be 80/20, again quite reasonable for an A-side champion vs a not too well known challenger.

              But Martin, as an unknown champion asked to defend his title, got better than a 40% split (almost 43%).

              Klitschko, a title-less aging former champ, got a 50/50 split.

              Given this information, and given that AJ vs Wilder is the biggest fight that can be made in boxing, it is quite understandable why Wilder is asking for 50/50.

              And given what AJ and Hearns have paid in the past, Wilder deserves it.

              Martin, an unknown got near 45%.
              Wlad with no title and coming off a loss, got 50%.

              Wilder, better known than Martin and actually holding a belt unlike Wlad, should at a minimum get what Martin got no matter where the fight is. And truth is, he deserves the same deal as Wlad. He is a longer reigning champion than AJ is, and unlike even the Klitschko fight, this fight if marketed the right way can do extremely well on American PPV.

              This is why folks who claim Wilder is pricing himself out of a fight actually have it backwards.

              Offering another champion 20-35% is a clear sign that it is Hearn who doesn't want the fight.

              And you don't have to have an opinion about what is fair or who is a bigger star.

              All you have to do is look at the track record of what was offered and received in other big fights and see if what is offered here IN THE BIGGEST FIGHT OF ALL OF THEM lines up comparably.

              And the answer is, it doesn't.
              you must have though pac deserved 50/50 with mayweather too.

              Comment

              • daggum
                All time great
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Feb 2008
                • 43689
                • 4,652
                • 3
                • 166,270

                #87
                Originally posted by koolkc107
                One has a track record of drawing in his own country.

                Wildly successful.

                Just like certain TV shows in Britain.

                But, that doesn't mean those same TV shows are going to do as well in the US.

                And you cannot demand the same in the US based on what has been done in Britain.

                There is no dis*****g that if this fight took place in Vegas, it would do a better gate than anything AJ has done in Britain.

                What AJ fanboys can't get their head around is that if the fight is in Vegas, AJ's PPV buys from British TV are almost irrelevant.
                no dispute? unknown british fighter vs unknown american fighter is going to do more than 11 million dollars in vegas at the gate? based on what? that would have to be one hell of a promotion to take 2 unknown guys and reach the level of floyd-mosley and pac-marquez 4. you usually dont go from zero to 100 like that in boxing. it usually takes one big star to reach that level. here we have zero so not sure how there is no dispute. i doubt they would even price the tickets that high so they could have the possibility of reaching 11 mill
                Last edited by daggum; 12-07-2017, 07:36 PM.

                Comment

                • Randall Cunning
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Oct 2015
                  • 6041
                  • 163
                  • 30
                  • 84,599

                  #88
                  Martin actually got 75% of the purse, Joshua got 2mil for that fight. Imagine where we'd be if Wilder offered Martin a decent purse, and took a hit on his own. Fought Klitschko in Vegas 50/50, and won. Was unified WBC, IBF, WBA Champion. Joshua wouldnt have his Wembley fight, no massive popularity boost. Wilder calling all the shots

                  But he didnt, didnt have the foresight. So here we are

                  Comment

                  • daggum
                    All time great
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Feb 2008
                    • 43689
                    • 4,652
                    • 3
                    • 166,270

                    #89
                    Originally posted by Randall Cunning
                    Martin actually got 75% of the purse, Joshua got 2mil for that fight. Imagine where we'd be if Wilder offered Martin a decent purse, and took a hit on his own. Fought Klitschko in Vegas 50/50, and won. Was unified WBC, IBF, WBA Champion. Joshua wouldnt have his Wembley fight, no massive popularity boost. Wilder calling all the shots

                    But he didnt, didnt have the foresight. So here we are
                    people forget the reason hearn paid martin so much is because other fighters wanted to fight him so there was a bidding war. then with the belt he jumped into a huge super fight. wilder jumped into 6 bum fights after winning the belt. i dont think fighting wilder is in high demand since everyone knows hes a paper tiger and just wants to fight bums. if they dont fight wilder who is going to steal him? stirverne, spilzka, washington lmao

                    Comment

                    • kafkod
                      I am Fanboy. Very Fanboy
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Sep 2013
                      • 24850
                      • 2,203
                      • 1,823
                      • 405,373

                      #90
                      Originally posted by koolkc107
                      This past September, we just saw a guy who had sold 1M PPV his last fight take on a guy who had only sold 130K PPVs his last fight.

                      Canelo/G did pretty well.

                      And those were not heavyweights, one guy had a loss, and one guy had a controversial fight prior.

                      These are 2 Undefeated Heavyweight wrecking machines who both speak english and both are charismatic.

                      This fight will sell better than that one.

                      Especially with casuals.
                      Originally posted by Robbie Barrett
                      Comparing two PPV fighters to 2 non PPV fighters. Joshua and Wilder can't even get 1 mil on Showtime but you expect them to sell 1+ mil PPV?.
                      Originally posted by daggum
                      no dispute? unknown british fighter vs unknown american fighter is going to do more than 11 million dollars in vegas at the gate? based on what? that would have to be one hell of a promotion to take 2 unknown guys and reach the level of floyd-mosley and pac-marquez 4. you usually dont go from zero to 100 like that in boxing. it usually takes one big star to reach that level. here we have zero so not sure how there is no dispute. i doubt they would even price the tickets that high so they could have the possibility of reaching 11 mill
                      If all it would take to make a Vegas mega fight - bigger than GGG/Canelo - is two unbeaten, English speaking HW champs with high KO ratios .. then why didn't Haymon do it with Wilder and Martin, who are both American and both signed to him?

                      And why is Wilder going crazy calling out AJ, but not interested at all in unbeaten WBO champ Parker?

                      What is it about AJ that makes him different from Martin and Parker?

                      You don't think AJ's huge UK fan base has any relevance in this business ... seriously?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP