Why Max Kellerman is Wrong On Mayweather Pacquiao Pound For Pound

[Left Hook Tua]

Thing is its very easy to see when facts are important not twisted innuendo , opinions from the Manny fanboys is a tip toe through the tulips while in a hot tub time machine . , how the fck is a guy better when he has lost a number of times , fought lessor weight drained versions of common opponents and then lost head to head , lol Manny fanboys are in denial and always have been .

List all of Floyd's big wins and pacs.

Pac has way better wins.

[IronDanHamza]

He's entitled to his opinion.

But his logic is ridiculous and non sensical.

[Left Hook Tua]

6-2-1 vs. Barrera, Morales and Marquez

Floyd has done nothing that can compete with that tbh.

[Left Hook Tua]

He's entitled to his opinion.

But his logic is ridiculous and non sensical.

I dont get the argument of more weight classes means better p4p

You can be top p4p staying in one weight all your career

[IronDanHamza]

6-2-1 vs. Barrera, Morales and Marquez

Floyd has done nothing that can compete with that tbh.

Looks better on paper than it actually is though.

But then so does Floyd's resume.

[Spoon23]

I suppose Floyd is the better fighter but I think it would have clear if the fight took place much sooner, before their respective reigns at welterweight. On the otherhand, Pac is without a doubt the greater fighter in terms of accomplishments. What he has done shouldn't have and never will be done again. I mean can you imagine Floyd beating those charlo twins, J Rock, Lara, Andrare and moving up to face golovkin, Quillen, Lumiex, Jacobs. And then going even further to face a prime ward, froch, badou jack, gilberto ramirez. I realize the timeline doesn't quite match up but essentially this is the mountain pac had to climb.

That's exactly what Pac did. Amazing guy.

# a true legend

[Left Hook Tua]

Looks better on paper than it actually is though.

But then so does Floyd's resume.

Maybe the last morales fight was a meaningless win.

The rest were great wins, even great losses/draws

[Johnwoo8686]

Dang dude this old news, did it bother you that much that Max and others think Pacquiao is greater than Floyd?

Not really. I see guys are still talking about this even weeks later. He's entitled to his opinion. But it is clear he has an agenda.

[IronDanHamza]

Maybe the last morales fight was a meaningless win.

The rest were great wins, even great losses/draws

Not really impressed with Barrera 2.

Barrera 1 obviously no need to explain.

The Marquez bouts were all great but IMO he's 0-3-1 in those. Obviously Pac arguably won 3 of the 4 himself so can't knock it.

Morales 2 I'm also not that impressed by.

Definitely looks better on paper, IMO the only two elite wins out of those fights are Barrera 1 and Marquez 2. But that's JMO.

[boliodogs]

Pound for pound is based strictly on personal opinion so there really are no right or wrong answers, just different opinions. I agree with you that Mayweather should rate a bit over Pacquiao. Mayweather never lost a fight while Pacquiao lost several times. I don't see what difference it makes what weight they turned pro at. Both of them ended up welterweights although I think Mayweather is naturally about 6 or 7 pounds bigger than Pacquiao. Mayweather is older but when they fought Mayweather won a clear ud. They had a common opponent in Marquez who was easily defeated by Mayweather but gave Pacquiao lots of trouble and knocked him out in their 4th fight. All things considered I give Mayweather the edge. Mayweather had an advantage in the beginning because Mayweather always had good nutrition and proper training and a great trainer while Pacquiao did not.