Should Manny Still Be Placed Above Floyd On The ATG List?

[Zaroku]

Like I said PAC being ko'ed like that means nothing. Duran was koed by hearns in2 rounds and Duran will always be greater than hearns.

Not the same. Duran came back and punished fools post getting KTFO.

PAC??? Post getting KTFO?? PAC ain't BACK. Just a shadow of his roided up self. Last KO was 6 years ago right???

Duran had a much bigger man, Iran the Blade down post getting KTFO!

Pre JMM 4 & post getting KTFO, he fought Aligierie Rios, and lacked the roids to get it done. If hearns fought 12 rounders he beat Leonard.

I can forgive the haggler loss, but the Marquez loss was .... Bigger.

[NearHypnos]

I really don't get the double standard with the JMM thing. One could say I borderline hate Floyd (i do not discredit his genius in the ring though ). That's the same weight JMM knocked Manny out and JMM was also younger then.



Pacquiao beat some of these guys not just after we knew they were past it but even past that (De la Hoya, Marg, Shane?). Imagine...you're the "killer" at your weight... Lets say GGG. Now lets say GGG's next fight is vs Sergio Martinez. That's how ridiculous the de la hoya and mosley fights were for Pacquiao lol. Is William Joppy a bad ass for beating Duran? Come on.

Floyd is significantly above Pacquiao.... I'd even rank JMM above Pacquiao. Simply put...they were better fighters. Doesnt matter if Pacquiao could knock God/Jesus/Allah/Buddha or (insert deity here) if he is still getting merc'd by JMM or horrifically outboxed by Mayweather. If someone is better than you they belong above you. Simple as that. When it's all said and done, if Pac shared ANY division with JMM or Floyd he's already not even the best fighter at that division.

Floyd can still go eff himself for all I care and JMM says he wants two more fights? Unless he's fighting Eric Morales or Jorge Arce he's gonna get knocked out

[iLovesoccermoms]

pacquiao has lost a **** load of times and lost every fight with marquez [if it wasn't for points given rule I'd have marquez winning that 1st fight] and manny has been knocked down but also has been brutally Knocked the **** out more than once AND got a 12round ass kicking by Mayweather himself too lmao

placed above Floyd??

bwahahahahahahahahahahahaha!!!!!

[torosboxing75]

I say Manny simply because he is very small and should've never been able to dominate above 135. This is a little beast fighting giants. If he would've never left his safe zone of 130 to 135 nobody would've beat him without a lucky punch.
What Manny did would be the equivalent to Floyd fighting the last couple years of his career at 154 and 160 and beating the best in those divisions.

[BlackSoul]

manny pacquiao is a MARGINAL fighter whom was HYPED to the MAX
and when you REALLY break down his resume its C- resume.
mayweather is in my top 20 ALL-TIME maybe top 15 MAYBE top 10 JUST SKATING IN but pacquiao isnt even in my top 40, MAYBE 50 but not top 40

[ironmt]

There Is no doubt as to who has the better resume. Pacquiao's destruction of the great Eric Morales and Marco Antonio Barrera alone without even mentioning all of the other greats he beat trumps any and all opponents Floyd has faced.

As far as where they are ranked, or should be ranked, Floyd takes this one. Pacquiao had an opportunity and blew It. He only has himself to blame. He entered the biggest stage/fight of his life and chose not to throw any punches.

[IMDAZED]

I question the intelligence of anyone who has Pacquiao over Mayweather at this point. If you're a troll/loser like LeftHookTua it's understandable. No other excuse otherwise.

[ironmt]

manny pacquiao is a MARGINAL fighter whom was HYPED to the MAX
and when you REALLY break down his resume its C- resume.
mayweather is in my top 20 ALL-TIME maybe top 15 MAYBE top 10 JUST SKATING IN but pacquiao isnt even in my top 40, MAYBE 50 but not top 40

There Isn't anything C- about Pacquiao's resume. All of Mayweather and Pacquiao's common opponents other than Marquez were beat In more spectacular fashion by Pacquiao. Who does Floyd have on his resume that Is equivalent to Barrera and Morales?

[ShoulderRoll]

Floyd beat Manny head to head. He also beat many of the same opponents BEFORE Manny did, when they weren't as old /shot/weight drained.

It's no contest really.

[Zaroku]

There is no legitimate ranking of fighters that has Floyd below Manny. Now when you make polls and give disgruntled fans like you, Mr. Fantastic and some others a choice, they will vote Manny just because. Just like the 24% of **********s that vote yes they think ***** was born in Kenya.

You can't do anything with that level of bias/******ity/hate.

Big Dunn, but what about watching PAC win in slow motion???

In Slow Motion PAC is undefeated!!! LMAO