Should Manny Still Be Placed Above Floyd On The ATG List?

[The Big Dunn]

Floyd divides opinion. In some polls he is above pac and below PAC in some others.
Some have Floyd top 10, some do nt have Floyd top 30.

There is no legitimate ranking of fighters that has Floyd below Manny. Now when you make polls and give disgruntled fans like you, Mr. Fantastic and some others a choice, they will vote Manny just because. Just like the 24% of **********s that vote yes they think ***** was born in Kenya.

You can't do anything with that level of bias/******ity/hate.

[Caught Square]

one of the worst title fights in recent history...neither were ever ranked at 154 before or after this fight....Maragrito lost every fight he had over 147 and Pac fought another big name at a cacthweight after a bad beating....no he gets very little credit...irs not about who you beat but about when in their career as well

Yep and some people defend it and act like it was some great victory, Pac can do no wrong in some people's eyes.

[hugh grant]

one of the worst title fights in recent history...neither were ever ranked at 154 before or after this fight....Maragrito lost every fight he had over 147 and Pac fought another big name at a cacthweight after a bad beating....no he gets very little credit...irs not about who you beat but about when in their career as well

This fight is what we in boxing call a risky fight with little reward. Only someone real bias towards Floyd would say it was a nothing fight for PAC as if getting in the ring with someone with all the physical advantages is easy?
Whilst the Floyd v berto fight is what we in boxing call a little risk and little crredit fight. But Floyd will add it to his stats of most former champs beat won't he?

[therealpugilist]

There is no legitimate ranking of fighters that has Floyd below Manny. Now when you make polls and give disgruntled fans like you, Mr. Fantastic and some others a choice, they will vote Manny just because. Just like the 24% of **********s that vote yes they think ***** was born in Kenya.

You can't do anything with that level of bias/******ity/hate.

post of the day

[hugh grant]

There is no legitimate ranking of fighters that has Floyd below Manny

You can't do anything with that level of bias/******ity/hate.

Its the other way round unfortunately.

[therealpugilist]

This fight is what we in boxing call a risky fight with little reward. Only someone real bias towards Floyd would say it was a nothing fight for PAC as if getting in the ring with all the physical advantages is easy?
Whilst the Floyd v berto fight was little risk and little crredit

physical advantages dont mean much when you are lacking in skill....did he not have size on Mosley? Cotto?

What did Margarito do well skill-wise??? his skills were rudimentary on the elite level and being at 147 benefited him being 5'11" and weighing 160+ fight night...he had a great chin, and good stamina but not much else


Margarito was a good fighter just not on Mayweather or Manny's calibre

[Doctor_Tenma]

Thought Mayweather had the better resume before the fight, the results only reassured that fact.

[b00g13man]

Floyd was ahead prior to the fight, so **** no.

[The Big Dunn]

Its the other way round unfortunately.

No. you are the perfect example of my point.

You said Floyd would be an ATG if he did certain things. Then when he did them, you changed your mind. You fault everyone that did not fight GGG but fault Floyd for Manny walking away 3 times. Then, when this question is posed, you pretend Floyd was prime and Manny was washed up and that's why Manny lost, so you give him a break.

In every credible rankings of fighters, Floyd finishes ahead of Manny. There is a reason the opinions of "fans" such as yourself differs so greatly from those credible rankings.

[Zaroku]

My ATG fighters don't look dead after being KTFO. Mosley had Floyd in trouble, but ..... That was that. Then broke him down.

How many times has Floyd been down? KTFO?

Silence

Drop the microphone and urinate in slow motion on pact@rds as I slowly walk off stage.