Is it now safe to say that Mayweather is the greatest fighter of his generation?

[RED REP]

Any doubts were done away with May 2nd. The real question is who rates higher between Manny and BHop.

This.

Both B Hop and Manny have utterly amazing résumés.

[jas]

Floyd didn't win fighter of the decade

And he won't win it this decade unless he beats a healthy manny

Ggg /ward / wlad / kovalev will win it this decade

Whoever stays unbeaten out of the above

[IMDAZED]

This.

Both B Hop and Manny have utterly amazing résumés.

I have Manny ahead of Hopkins by a decent margin.

[Szef]

I don't think that's debatable at this point.

Sure, some butt hurt fans will disagree, but what sane person cares what they think?

I know I don't.

[hugh grant]

Any doubts were done away with May 2nd. The real question is who rates higher between Manny and BHop.

Pac is the best of this generation. Because BH and Floyd have similar hugging and spoiling styles, people want to know who is the best between FLoyd and BH.

Pacs and Floyds resumes have similar victims, albeit with Pac knocking people more readily and with greater names like Barrera and Morales.
Floyd would need to do something that tops Pac for example a win over GGG at middleweight. Floyd is bigger than Pac afterall. He hasn't beat as great fighters as Pac did, so at least beat bigger fighters where you are underdog.

[Espy]

Pac is the best of this generation. Because BH and Floyd have similar hugging and spoiling styles, people want to know who is the best between FLoyd and BH.

I've been lurking this board for the last 5+ years and Floyd beat almost everyone you said he would lose to yet you still hate on him.

You were riding real hard for Pac to beat him too. LOL.

[Dudley]

:AOR: please STFU!!!! Floyd aint shlt! Running hugging clinching ref in pocket judges in pocket DONT make you the greatest of any generation! lmfao

Who would you rate higher?

[Dudley]

Pac is the best of this generation. Because BH and Floyd have similar hugging and spoiling styles, people want to know who is the best between FLoyd and BH.

Pacs and Floyds resumes have similar victims, albeit with Pac knocking people more readily and with greater names like Barrera and Morales.
Floyd would need to do something that tops Pac for example a win over GGG at middleweight. Floyd is bigger than Pac afterall. He hasn't beat as great fighters as Pac did, so at least beat bigger fighters where you are underdog.

Who did Pac lose to?

Because for a second there, i thought your talking about most loved fighter, not best of their generation.

[Dudley]

Floyd didn't win fighter of the decade

And he won't win it this decade unless he beats a healthy manny

Ggg /ward / wlad / kovalev will win it this decade

Whoever stays unbeaten out of the above

Manny is healthy now... . . . As odd as it may seem... . . . seeing an injury heal in 2 months which usually takes 8 months to a year to heal...

[SilverMiles]

Pretty much every boxing scribe considers floyd t g e greatest fighter of this generation. Not even a reason to argue the point anymore.

No true at all, you're using the opinion of American writers who have a clear bias in favor of the American fighter.

I recently read that top 20 of the last 20 years or something like that list and those idiots has Hopkins over Manny and Marquez. Straight bias if I ever saw it.

Their trying to change history with a bull**** list, but no true list can be done without a national view point.

If you did a list with most of the contributors being Filipino I bet Manny would rank #1.