My P4P top 10 list

[Rokozoko]

My current top P4P list

1: Hector Camacho
2: Mike McCallum
3: Donald Curry
4: Thomas Hearns
5: Roberto Duran
6: Marvin Hagler
7: Evander Holyfield
8: Mike Tyson
9: Rocky Marciano
10: Salvador Sanchez.

I mean sure, none of them have fought for a while, and just like Ward, they have not done anything in years. Since everyone else though Wants to keep Ward at #2 just for things he did in the distant past, I will keep my guys on my list also

I would appreciate if we keep this thread free from trolling and stay serious. I kinda hope that we all can reach an agreement on a complete, unbiased P4P list.

[bigjavi973]

My current top P4P list

1: Hector Camacho
2: Mike McCallum
3: Donald Curry
4: Thomas Hearns
5: Roberto Duran
6: Marvin Hagler
7: Evander Holyfield
8: Mike Tyson
9: Rocky Marciano
10: Salvador Sanchez.

I mean sure, none of them have fought for a while, and just like Ward, they have not done anything in years. Since everyone else though Wants to keep Ward at #2 just for things he did in the distant past, I will keep my guys on my list also

Green K for you, sir!

[VG_Addict]

I would appreciate if we keep this thread free from trolling and stay serious. I kinda hope that we all can reach an agreement on a complete, unbiased P4P list.

You can't reach an agreement on a P4P list. P4P, by its very nature, is subjective.

[Rokozoko]

You can't reach an agreement on a P4P list. P4P, by its very nature, is subjective.

I just think it's so unbelievable ******ed that people add Canelo, Cotto and Golovkin to their P4P lists when none of them have done anything deserving of getting them there.

[HEND]

Mine:

1. Floyd Mayweather
2.Andre Ward
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Guillermo Rigondeaux
5.Roman Gonzalez
6.Wladimir Klitschko
7. Timothy Bradley
8. Sergey Kovalev
9. Canelo Alvarez
10. James Degale

[just the facts]

Ward at number 2??? The guy has had one fight in a year and a half against an overweight, out of shape clown who's manager is now begging to retire. Ward will not belong back on a P4P list at ANY position until he has beaten at least two top 10 contenders with significant ease.

I can live without Rigo on a P4P list as with only 15 fights I do not see how he possibly belongs there. But Roman Gonzalez definitely belongs on any valid list. And I agree that DeGale, Wilder and Povetkin have no place on any top ten list. Bradley may be borderline and hold a number 10 spot at the most.

I realize that facing quality opposition means little to you, but Rigo dominated Donaire who was in the top ten p4p at the time and has done nothing to lose his top ten p4p.

[SilverMiles]

1: Rigo almost got KO'ed by a Japanese journeyman and has hated boxing ever since.
2: Golovkin has done nothing remarkable in his entire career.
3: Gonzaled and Kovalev are good, but not P4P #1 material yet.
4: Ward is debatable at #1, but he needs to be more active.

As for Deontay Wilder, I see no reason to rank Golovkin above him.

Dude reading your posts its obvious the only reason you made this thread and list was to **** on GGG.

Plus lb for lb list have little to do with past achievements. Right now head to head if Floyd was the same size as GGG, Kovalev, and Ward they would all beat him. Floyd is done his defense now is basically clinching his opponents and his offense is below average.

As for Deontay the guy belongs no where near this list.

[Rokozoko]

Dude reading your posts its obvious the only reason you made this thread and list was to **** on GGG.

Plus lb for lb list have little to do with past achievements. Right now head to head if Floyd was the same size as GGG, Kovalev, and Ward they would all beat him. Floyd is done his defense now is basically clinching his opponents and his offense is below average.

As for Deontay the guy belongs no where near this list.

I had Golovkin P4P #11 in the world, right behind Wilder at #10 (which you would know if you read my first post). Now I have Golovkin #12 and Wilder at #11, due to realizing that Gonzales deserves #10 more. How can I be $h!ting on Golovkin if I have him #12 in the world?

[just the facts]

Did I mention Golovkin in my post? Has ANYONE other than YOU mentioned Golovkin in this thread?


NO!!!

So how about you just STFU and go away and find another thread to spread your hate in. My opinion regarding Ward is very valid as he has done nothing in over 2 years to deserve inclusion on a P4P list. Such lists, like top 10 rankings, are based on current activity, not historical data.

You post that any top ten list including Ward is automatically garbage, then complain about someone else spreading hate?

[Showtime..]

Garbage list.

Honestly I don't like that Floyd is still #1. He hasn't looked pretty at all in the last 1.5 years, but he's still winning & no one else has stepped up to the throne (thanks for losing to Pacquiao, Bradley).

Wlad 2nd.. No real debate. Could be #1 if he grows balls and beats Wilder/Fury.

Kova is 3rd. Pretty clear..

Pac is 4th. Not what he was, but still beats everyone 140-147 alongside Floyd.

Rigo is 5th. Don't like it, but can't deny the talent. Outclasses everybody..

Choco 6th. **** you bum for fighting a washed up Segura instead of Estrada or Inoue.

7. GGG
8. Crawford
9. Bradley.. Beat Vargas convincingly and he goes up..
10 Povetkin (KO wins over Charr, Takam, & Perez are really good; 2 of those guys were HW Top Tens)